Planet Russell


Planet DebianSteinar H. Gunderson: Nageru 1.7.2 released

I've released version of 1.7.2 of Nageru, my free video mixer.

The main new feature this time round is the ability to use sound from video inputs. This was originally intended for IP camera inputs from Android, but I suppose you could also it for playout if you're brave. :-) A/V sync keeps being a hard problem (it's easy to make something that feels reasonable and works 99% of the time, but fails miserably the last percent), so I don't recommend running your cameras over IP if you can avoid it, but sometimes lugging SDI around really is too inconvenient.

Apart from that, the git log this time is dominated by a lot of small tweaks and bugfixes; things are getting increasingly refined as we get more experience with the larger setups. I wondered for a bit whether I should give it a version bump to 1.8.0, but in the end, I didn't consider IP inputs (nor the support for assisting Cubemap with HLS output) important enough. So 1.7.2 it is.

The full changelog (with lots of things hidden under the last point :-) ) follows. As usual, new packages are also on their way up to Debian, although unfortunately, my CEF-enabling patch to Chromium still hasn't received any love, so if you want CEF support, you'll have to compile yourself.

Nageru 1.7.2, April 28th, 2018

  - Several improvements to video (FFmpeg) inputs: You can now use
    them as audio sources, you can right-click on video channels
    to change URL/filename on-the-fly, themes can ask for forced
    disconnection (useful for network sources that are hanging),
    and various other improvements. Be aware that the audio support
    may still be somewhat rough, as A/V sync of arbitrary video
    playout is a hard problem.

  - The included themes have been fixed to properly make the returned
    chain preparation functions independent of global state (e.g. if
    the white balance for a channel was changed before the frame was
    actually rendered). If you are using a custom theme, you may want
    to apply similar fixes to it.

  - In Metacube stream output, mark each keyframe with a pts metadata
    block. This allows Cubemap 1.4.0 or newer to serve fMP4 fragments
    for HLS from Nageru's output, without any further remuxing or

  - If needed, Nageru will now automatically try to autodetect a
    usable --va-display parameter by probing all DRM nodes for H.264
    encoders. This removes the need to set --va-display in almost all
    cases, and also removes the dependency on libpci.

  - For GPUs that support querying available memory (in practice only
    NVIDIA GPUs at the current time), expose the amount of used/total
    GPU memory both on standard output and in the Prometheus metrics
    (as well as included Grafana dashboard).

  - The Grafana dashboard now supports heatmaps for the chosen x264
    speedcontrol preset (requires Grafana 5.1 or newer). (There used to
    be a heatmap earlier, but it was all broken.)

  - Various bugfixes.

Planet Linux AustraliaJulien Goodwin: PoE termination board

For my next big project I'm planning on making it run using power over ethernet. Back in March I designed a quick circuit using the TI TPS2376-H PoE termination chip, and an LMR16020 switching regulator to drop the ~48v coming in down to 5v. There's also a second stage low-noise linear regulator (ST LDL1117S33R) to further drop it down to 3.3v, but as it turns out the main chip I'm using does its own 5->3.3v conversion already.

Because I was lazy, and the pricing was reasonable I got these boards manufactured by who I'd used for the USB-C termination boards I did a while back.

Here's the board running a Raspberry Pi 3B+, as it turns out I got lucky and my board is set up for the same input as the 3B+ supplies.

One really big warning, this is a non-isolated supply, which, in general, is a bad idea for PoE. For my specific use case there'll be no exposed connectors or metal, so this should be safe, but if you want to use PoE in general I'd suggest using some of the isolated convertors that are available with integrated PoE termination.

For this series I'm going to try and also make some notes on the mistakes I've made with these boards to help others, for this board:
  • I failed to add any test pins, given this was the first try I really should have, being able to inject power just before the switching convertor was helpful while debugging, but I had to solder wires to the input cap to do that.
  • Similarly, I should have had a 5v output pin, for now I've just been shorting the two diodes I had near the output which were intended to let me switch input power between two feeds.
  • The last, and the only actual problem with the circuit was that when selecting which exact parts to use I optimised by choosing the same diode for both input protection & switching, however this was a mistake, as the switcher needed a Schottky diode, and one with better ratings in other ways than the input diode. With the incorrect diode the board actually worked fine under low loads, but would quickly go into thermal shutdown if asked to supply more than about 1W. With the diode swapped to a correctly rated one it now supplies 10W just fine.
  • While debugging the previous I also noticed that the thermal pads on both main chips weren't well connected through. It seems the combination of via-in-thermal-pad (even tented), along with Kicad's normal reduction in paste in those large pads, plus my manufacturer's use of a fairly thin application of paste all contributed to this. Next time I'll probably avoid via-in-pad.

Coming soon will be a post about the GPS board, but I'm still testing bits of that board out, plus waiting for some missing parts (somehow not only did I fail to order 10k resistors, I didn't already have some in stock).

Planet Linux AustraliaChris Smart: Fedora on ODROID-HC1 mini NAS (ARMv7)

Hardkernel is a Korean company that makes various embedded ARM based systems, which it calls ODROID.

One of their products is the ODROID-HC1, a mini NAS designed to take a single 2.5″ SATA drive (HC stands for “Home Cloud”) which comes with 2GB RAM and a Gigabit Ethernet port. There is also a 3.5″ model called the HC2. Both of these are based on the ODROID-XU4, which itself is based on the previous iteration ODROID-XU3. All of these are based on the Samsung Exynos5422 SOC and should work with the following steps.

The Exynos SOC needs proprietary first stage bootloaders which are embedded in the first 1.4MB or so at the beginning of the SD card in order to load U-Boot. As these binary blobs are not re-distributable, Fedora cannot support these devices out of the box, however all the other bits are available including the kernel, device tree and U-Boot. So, we just need to piece it all together and the result is a stock Fedora system!

To do this you’ll need the ODROID device, a power supply (5V/4A for HC1, 12V/2A for HC2), one of their UART adapters, an SD card (UHS-I) and probably a hard drive if you want to use it as a NAS (you may also want a battery for the RTC and a case).

ODROID-HC1 with UART, RTC battery, SD card and 2.5″ drive.

Note that the default Fedora 27 ARM image does not support the Realtek RTL8153 Ethernet adapter out of the box (it does after a kernel upgrade) so if you don’t have a USB Ethernet dongle handy we’ll download the kernel packages on our host, save them to the SD card and install them on first boot. The Fedora 28 image works out of the box, so if you’re installing 28 you can skip that step.

Download the Fedora Minimal ARM server image and save it in your home dir.

Install the Fedora ARM installer and U-Boot bootloader files for the device on your host PC.

sudo dnf install fedora-arm-installer uboot-images-armv7

Insert your SD card into your computer and note the device (mine is /dev/mmcblk0) using dmesg or df commands. Once you know that, open a terminal and let’s write the Fedora image to the SD card! Note that we are using none as the target because it’s not a supported board and we will configure the bootloader manually.

sudo fedora-arm-image-installer \
--target=none \
--image=Fedora-Minimal-armhfp-27-1.6-sda.raw.xz \
--resizefs \
--norootpass \

First things first, we need to enable the serial console and turn off cpuidle else it won’t boot. We do this by mounting the boot partition on the SD card and modifying the extlinux bootloader configuration.

sudo mount /dev/mmcblk0p2 /mnt
sudo sed -i "s|append|& \
console=tty1 console=ttySAC2,115200n8|" \

As mentioned, the kernel that comes with Fedora 27 image doesn’t support the Ethernet adapter, so if you don’t have a spare USB Ethernet dongle, let’s download the updates now. If you’re using Fedora 28 this is not necessary.

cd /mnt
sudo wget \ \
cd ~/

Unmount the boot partition.

sudo umount /mnt

Now, we can embed U-Boot and the required bootloaders into the SD card. To do this we need to download the files from Hardkernel along with their script which writes the blobs (note that we are downloading the files for the XU4, not HC1, as they are compatible). We will tell the script to use the U-Boot image we installed earlier, this way we are using Fedora’s U-Boot not the one from Hardkernel.

Download the required files from Hardkernel.

mkdir hardkernel ; cd hardkernel
wget \ \ \
chmod a+x

Copy the Fedora U-Boot files into the local dir.

cp /usr/share/uboot/odroid-xu3/u-boot.bin .

Finally, run the fusing script to embed the files onto the SD card, passing in the device for your SD card.
sudo ./ /dev/mmcblk0

That’s it! Remove your SD card and insert it into your ODROID, then plug the UART adapter into a USB port on your computer and connect to it with screen (check dmesg for the port number, generally ttyUSB0).

sudo screen /dev/ttyUSB0

Now power on your ODROID. If all goes well you should see the SOC initialise, load Fedora’s U-Boot and boot Fedora to the welcome setup screen. Complete this and then log in as root or your user you have just set up.

Welcome configuration screen for Fedora ARM.

If you’re running Fedora 27 image, install the kernel updates, remove the RPMs and reboot the device (skip this if you’re running Fedora 28).
sudo dnf install --disablerepo=* /boot/*rpm
sudo rm /boot/*rpm
sudo reboot

Fedora login over serial connection.

Once you have rebooted, the Ethernet adapter should work and you can do your regular updates

sudo dnf update

You can find your SATA drive at /dev/sda where you should be able to partition, format, mount it, share it and well, do whatever you want with the box.

You may wish to take note of the IP address and/or configure static networking so that you can SSH in once you unplug the UART.

Enjoy your native Fedora embedded ARM Mini NAS 🙂

Planet DebianMichal Čihař: What's being cooked for Weblate 3.0

Next release on Weblate roadmap is called 3.0 and will bring some important changes. Some of these are already present in the Git repository and deployed on Hosted Weblate, but more of that will follow.

Component discovery

Component discovery is useful feature if you have several translation components in one repository. Previously import_project management command was the only way to help you, however it had to be executed manually on any change. Now you can use Component discovery addon which does quite similar thing, however is triggered on VCS update, so it can be used to follow structure of your project without any manual interaction. This feature is already available in Git and on Hosted Weblate, though you have to ask for initial setup there.

Code cleanups

Over the years (first Weblate release was more than six years ago) the code structure is far from optimal. There are several code cleanups scheduled and some of them are already present in Git repository. This will make Weblate easier to maintain and extend (eg. with third party file format drivers).

User management

Since the beginning Weblate has relied on user management and permissions as provided by Django. This is really not a good fit for language / project matrix permissions which most people need so we've come with Group ACL to extend this. This worked quite well for some use cases, but it turned out to be problematic for others. It is also quite hard to setup properly. For Weblate 3.0 this will be dropped and replaced by access control which fits more use cases. This is still being finalized in our issue tracker, so if you have any comments to this, please share them.

Migration path

Due to above mentioned massive changes, migrations across 3.0 will not be supported. You will always have to upgrade to 3.0 first and then upgrade to further versions. The code cleanups will also lead to some changes in the configuration, so take care when upgrading and follow upgrading instructions.

Filed under: Debian English SUSE Weblate


CryptogramFriday Squid Blogging: Bizarre Contorted Squid

This bizarre contorted squid might be a new species, or a previously known species exhibiting a new behavior. No one knows.

As usual, you can also use this squid post to talk about the security stories in the news that I haven't covered.

Read my blog posting guidelines here.

Krebs on SecuritySecurity Trade-Offs in the New EU Privacy Law

On two occasions this past year I’ve published stories here warning about the prospect that new European privacy regulations could result in more spams and scams ending up in your inbox. This post explains in a question and answer format some of the reasoning that went into that prediction, and responds to many of the criticisms leveled against it.

Before we get to the Q&A, a bit of background is in order. On May 25, 2018 the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) takes effect. The law, enacted by the European Parliament, requires companies to get affirmative consent for any personal information they collect on people within the European Union. Organizations that violate the GDPR could face fines of up to four percent of global annual revenues.

In response, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) — the nonprofit entity that manages the global domain name system — has proposed redacting key bits of personal data from WHOIS, the system for querying databases that store the registered users of domain names and blocks of Internet address ranges (IP addresses).

Under current ICANN rules, domain name registrars should collect and display a variety of data points when someone performs a WHOIS lookup on a given domain, such as the registrant’s name, address, email address and phone number. Most registrars offer a privacy protection service that shields this information from public WHOIS lookups; some registrars charge a nominal fee for this service, while others offer it for free.

But in a bid to help registrars comply with the GDPR, ICANN is moving forward on a plan to remove critical data elements from all public WHOIS records. Under the new system, registrars would collect all the same data points about their customers, yet limit how much of that information is made available via public WHOIS lookups.

The data to be redacted includes the name of the person who registered the domain, as well as their phone number, physical address and email address. The new rules would apply to all domain name registrars globally.

ICANN has proposed creating an “accreditation system” that would vet access to personal data in WHOIS records for several groups, including journalists, security researchers, and law enforcement officials, as well as intellectual property rights holders who routinely use WHOIS records to combat piracy and trademark abuse.

But at an ICANN meeting in San Juan, Puerto Rico last month, ICANN representatives conceded that a proposal for how such a vetting system might work probably would not be ready until December 2018. Assuming ICANN meets that deadline, it could be many months after that before the hundreds of domain registrars around the world take steps to adopt the new measures.

In a series of posts on Twitter, I predicted that the WHOIS changes coming with GDPR will likely result in a noticeable increase in cybercrime — particularly in the form of phishing and other types of spam. In response to those tweets, several authors on Wednesday published an article for Georgia Tech’s Internet Governance Project titled, “WHOIS afraid of the dark? Truth or illusion, let’s know the difference when it comes to WHOIS.”

The following Q&A is intended to address many of the more misleading claims and assertions made in that article.

Cyber criminals don’t use their real information in WHOIS registrations, so what’s the big deal if the data currently available in WHOIS records is no longer in the public domain after May 25?

I can point to dozens of stories printed here — and probably hundreds elsewhere — that clearly demonstrate otherwise. Whether or not cyber crooks do provide their real information is beside the point. ANY information they provide — and especially information that they re-use across multiple domains and cybercrime campaigns — is invaluable to both grouping cybercriminal operations and in ultimately identifying who’s responsible for these activities.

To understand why data reuse in WHOIS records is so common among crooks, put yourself in the shoes of your average scammer or spammer — someone who has to register dozens or even hundreds or thousands of domains a week to ply their trade. Are you going to create hundreds or thousands of email addresses and fabricate as many personal details to make your WHOIS listings that much harder for researchers to track? The answer is that those who take this extraordinary step are by far and away the exception rather than the rule. Most simply reuse the same email address and phony address/phone/contact information across many domains as long as it remains profitable for them to do so.

This pattern of WHOIS data reuse doesn’t just extend across a few weeks or months. Very often, if a spammer, phisher or scammer can get away with re-using the same WHOIS details over many years without any deleterious effects to their operations, they will happily do so. Why they may do this is their own business, but nevertheless it makes WHOIS an incredibly powerful tool for tracking threat actors across multiple networks, registrars and Internet epochs.

All domain registrars offer free or a-la-carte privacy protection services that mask the personal information provided by the domain registrant. Most cybercriminals — unless they are dumb or lazy — are already taking advantage of these anyway, so it’s not clear why masking domain registration for everyone is going to change the status quo by much. 

It is true that some domain registrants do take advantage of WHOIS privacy services, but based on countless investigations I have conducted using WHOIS to uncover cybercrime businesses and operators, I’d wager that cybercrooks more often do not use these services. Not infrequently, when they do use WHOIS privacy options there are still gaps in coverage at some point in the domain’s history (such as when a registrant switches hosting providers) which are indexed by historic WHOIS records and that offer a brief window of visibility into the details behind the registration.

This is demonstrably true even for organized cybercrime groups and for nation state actors, and these are arguably some of the most sophisticated and savvy cybercriminals out there.

It’s worth adding that if so many cybercrooks seem nonchalant about adopting WHOIS privacy services it may well be because they reside in countries where the rule of law is not well-established, or their host country doesn’t particularly discourage their activities so long as they’re not violating the golden rule — namely, targeting people in their own backyard. And so they may not particularly care about covering their tracks. Or in other cases they do care, but nevertheless make mistakes or get sloppy at some point, as most cybercriminals do.

The GDPR does not apply to businesses — only to individuals — so there is no reason researchers or anyone else should be unable to find domain registration details for organizations and companies in the WHOIS database after May 25, right?

It is true that the European privacy regulations as they relate to WHOIS records do not apply to businesses registering domain names. However, the domain registrar industry — which operates on razor-thin profit margins and which has long sought to be free from any WHOIS requirements or accountability whatsoever — won’t exactly be tripping over themselves to add more complexity to their WHOIS efforts just to make a distinction between businesses and individuals.

As a result, registrars simply won’t make that distinction because there is no mandate that they must. They’ll just adopt the same WHOIS data collection and display polices across the board, regardless of whether the WHOIS details for a given domain suggest that the registrant is a business or an individual.

But the GDPR only applies to data collected about people in Europe, so why should this impact WHOIS registration details collected on people who are outside of Europe?

Again, domain registrars are the ones collecting WHOIS data, and they are most unlikely to develop WHOIS record collection and dissemination policies that seek to differentiate between entities covered by GDPR and those that may not be. Such an attempt would be fraught with legal and monetary complications that they simply will not take on voluntarily.

What’s more, the domain registrar community tends to view the public display of WHOIS data as a nuisance and a cost center. They have mainly only allowed public access to WHOIS data because ICANN’s contracts state that they should. So, from registrar community’s point of view, the less information they must make available to the public, the better.

Like it or not, the job of tracking down and bringing cybercriminals to justice falls to law enforcement agencies — not security researchers. Law enforcement agencies will still have unfettered access to full WHOIS records.

As it relates to inter-state crimes (i.e, the bulk of all Internet abuse), law enforcement — at least in the United States — is divided into two main components: The investigative side (i.e., the FBI and Secret Service) and the prosecutorial side (the state and district attorneys who actually initiate court proceedings intended to bring an accused person to justice).

Much of the legwork done to provide the evidence needed to convince prosecutors that there is even a case worth prosecuting is performed by security researchers. The reasons why this is true are too numerous to delve into here, but the safe answer is that law enforcement investigators typically are more motivated to focus on crimes for which they can readily envision someone getting prosecuted — and because very often their plate is full with far more pressing, immediate and local (physical) crimes.

Admittedly, this is a bit of a blanket statement because in many cases local, state and federal law enforcement agencies will do this often tedious legwork of cybercrime investigations on their own — provided it involves or impacts someone in their jurisdiction. But due in large part to these jurisdictional issues, politics and the need to build prosecutions around a specific locality when it comes to cybercrime cases, very often law enforcement agencies tend to miss the forest for the trees.

Who cares if security researchers will lose access to WHOIS data, anyway? To borrow an assertion from the Internet Governance article, “maybe it’s high time for security researchers and businesses that harvest personal information from WHOIS on an industrial scale to refine and remodel their research methods and business models.”

This is an alluring argument. After all, the technology and security industries claim to be based on innovation. But consider carefully how anti-virus, anti-spam or firewall technologies currently work. The unfortunate reality is that these technologies are still mostly powered by humans, and those humans rely heavily on access to key details about domain reputation and ownership history.

Those metrics for reputation weigh a host of different qualities, but a huge component of that reputation score is determining whether a given domain or Internet address has been connected to any other previous scams, spams, attacks or other badness. We can argue about whether this is the best way to measure reputation, but it doesn’t change the prospect that many of these technologies will in all likelihood perform less effectively after WHOIS records start being heavily redacted.

Don’t advances in artificial intelligence and machine learning obviate the need for researchers to have access to WHOIS data?

This sounds like a nice idea, but again it is far removed from current practice. Ask anyone who regularly uses WHOIS data to determine reputation or to track and block malicious online threats and I’ll wager you will find the answer is that these analyses are still mostly based on manual lookups and often thankless legwork. Perhaps such trendy technological buzzwords will indeed describe the standard practice of the security industry at some point in the future, but in my experience this does not accurately depict the reality today.

Okay, but Internet addresses are pretty useful tools for determining reputation. The sharing of IP addresses tied to cybercriminal operations isn’t going to be impacted by the GDPR, is it? 

That depends on the organization doing the sharing. I’ve encountered at least two cases in the past few months wherein European-based security firms have been reluctant to share Internet address information at all in response to the GDPR — based on a perceived (if not overly legalistic) interpretation that somehow this information also might be considered personally identifying data. This reluctance to share such information out of a concern that doing so might land the sharer in legal hot water can indeed have a chilling effect on the important sharing of threat intelligence across borders.

According to the Internet Governance article, “If you need to get in touch with a website’s administrator, you will be able to do so in what is a less intrusive manner of achieving this purpose: by using an anonymized email address, or webform, to reach them (The exact implementation will depend on the registry). If this change is inadequate for your ‘private detective’ activities and you require full WHOIS records, including the personal information, then you will need to declare to a domain name registry your specific need for and use of this personal information. Nominet, for instance, has said that interested parties may request the full WHOIS record (including historical data) for a specific domain and get a response within one business day for no charge.”

I’m sure this will go over tremendously with both the hacked sites used to host phishing and/or malware download pages, as well as those phished by or served with malware in the added time it will take to relay and approve said requests.

According to a Q3 2017 study (PDF) by security firm Webroot, the average lifespan of a phishing site is between four and eight hours. How is waiting 24 hours before being able to determine who owns the offending domain going to be helpful to either the hacked site or its victims? It also doesn’t seem likely that many other registrars will volunteer for this 24-hour turnaround duty — and indeed no others have publicly demonstrated any willingness to take on this added cost and hassle.

I’ve heard that ICANN is pushing for a delay in the GDPR as it relates to WHOIS records, to give the registrar community time to come up with an accreditation system that would grant vetted researchers access to WHOIS records. Why isn’t that a good middle ground?

It might be if ICANN hadn’t dragged its heels in taking GDPR seriously until perhaps the past few months. As it stands, the experts I’ve interviewed see little prospect for such a system being ironed out or in gaining necessary traction among the registrar community to accomplish this anytime soon. And most experts I’ve interviewed predict it is likely that the Internet community will still be debating about how to create such an accreditation system a year from now.

Hence, it’s not likely that WHOIS records will continue to be anywhere near as useful to researchers in a month or so than they were previously. And this reality will continue for many months to come — if indeed some kind of vetted WHOIS access system is ever envisioned and put into place.

After I registered a domain name using my real email address, I noticed that address started receiving more spam emails. Won’t hiding email addresses in WHOIS records reduce the overall amount of spam I can expect when registering a domain under my real email address?

That depends on whether you believe any of the responses to the bolded questions above. Will that address be spammed by people who try to lure you into paying them to register variations on that domain, or to entice you into purchasing low-cost Web hosting services from some random or shady company? Probably. That’s exactly what happens to almost anyone who registers a domain name that is publicly indexed in WHOIS records.

The real question is whether redacting all email addresses from WHOIS will result in overall more bad stuff entering your inbox and littering the Web, thanks to reputation-based anti-spam and anti-abuse systems failing to work as well as they did before GDPR kicks in.

It’s worth noting that ICANN created a working group to study this exact issue, which noted that “the appearance of email addresses in response to WHOIS queries is indeed a contributor to the receipt of spam, albeit just one of many.” However, the report concluded that “the Committee members involved in the WHOIS study do not believe that the WHOIS service is the dominant source of spam.”

Do you have something against people not getting spammed, or against better privacy in general? 

To the contrary, I have worked the majority of my professional career to expose those who are doing the spamming and scamming. And I can say without hesitation that an overwhelming percentage of that research has been possible thanks to data included in public WHOIS registration records.

Is the current WHOIS system outdated, antiquated and in need of an update? Perhaps. But scrapping the current system without establishing anything in between while laboring under the largely untested belief that in doing so we will achieve some kind of privacy utopia seems myopic.

If opponents of the current WHOIS system are being intellectually honest, they will make the following argument and stick to it: By restricting access to information currently available in the WHOIS system, whatever losses or negative consequences on security we may suffer as a result will be worth the cost in terms of added privacy. That’s an argument I can respect, if not agree with.

But for the most part that’s not the refrain I’m hearing. Instead, what this camp seems to be saying is if you’re not on board with the WHOIS changes that will be brought about by the GDPR, then there must be something wrong with you, and in any case here a bunch of thinly-sourced reasons why the coming changes might not be that bad.

Rondam RamblingsCredit where it's due

Richard Nixon is rightfully remembered as one of the great villains of American democracy.  But he wasn't all bad.  He opened relations with China, appointed four mostly sane Supreme Court justices, and oversaw the establishment of the EPA among many other accomplishments.  Likewise, I believe that Donald Trump will eventually go down in history as one of the worst (if not the worst) president

Rondam RamblingsAn open letter to Jack Phillips

[Jack Phillips is the owner of the Masterpiece Cake Shop in Lakewood, Colorado.  Mr. Phillips is being sued by the Colorado Civil Rights Commission for refusing to make a wedding cake for a gay couple.  His case is currently before the U.S. Supreme Court.  Yesterday Mr. Phillips published an op-ed in The Washington Post to which this letter is a response.] Dear Mr. Phillips: Imagine your child

Rondam RamblingsPaul Ryan forces out House chaplain

Just in case there was the slightest ember of hope in your mind that Republicans actually care about religious freedom and are not just odious hypocritical power-grubbing opportunists, this should extinguish it once and for all: House Chaplain Patrick Conroy’s sudden resignation has sparked a furor on Capitol Hill, with sources in both parties saying he was pushed out by Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis

CryptogramTSB Bank Disaster

This seems like an absolute disaster:

The very short version is that a UK bank, TSB, which had been merged into and then many years later was spun out of Lloyds Bank, was bought by the Spanish bank Banco Sabadell in 2015. Lloyds had continued to run the TSB systems and was to transfer them over to Sabadell over the weekend. It's turned out to be an epic failure, and it's not clear if and when this can be straightened out.

It is bad enough that bank IT problem had been so severe and protracted a major newspaper, The Guardian, created a live blog for it that has now been running for two days.

The more serious issue is the fact that customers still can't access online accounts and even more disconcerting, are sometimes being allowed into other people's accounts, says there are massive problems with data integrity. That's a nightmare to sort out.

Even worse, the fact that this situation has persisted strongly suggests that Lloyds went ahead with the migration without allowing for a rollback.

This seems to be a mistake, and not enemy action.

Worse Than FailureError'd: Billboards Show Obvious Disasters

"Actually, this board is outside a casino in Sheffield which is next to the church, but we won't go there," writes Simon.


Wouter wrote, "The local gas station is now running ads for Windows 10 updates."


"If I were to legally change my name to a GUID, this is exactly what I'd pick," Lincoln K. wrote.


Robert F. writes, "Copy/Paste? Bah! If you really want to know how many log files are being generated per server, every minute, you're going to have to earn it by typing out this 'easy' command."


"I imagine someone pushed the '10 items or fewer' rule on the self-checkout kiosk just a little too far," Michael writes.


Wojciech wrote, "To think - someone actually doodled this JavaScript code!"


[Advertisement] Forget logs. Next time you're struggling to replicate error, crash and performance issues in your apps - Think Raygun! Installs in minutes. Learn more.


Planet DebianSteinar H. Gunderson: Anandtech and HPET issues

Anandtech spots differences in their Intel-vs-Ryzen benchmarks compared to other media, pinpoints it to differences in whether HPET or TSC is used as the primary system timer on Windows, and goes on to immediately retract their Ryzen 2000-series benchmarks for correction.

That's… impressive integrity and competence. I already trusted their benchmarks a far bit, and this doesn't exactly hurt.

Cory DoctorowRaleigh-Durham, I’m headed your way! CORRECTED!

CORRECTION! The Flyleaf event is at 6PM, not 7!

I’m delivering the annual Kilgour lecture tomorrow morning at 10AM at UNC, and I’ll be speaking at Flyleaf Books at 6PM — be there or be oblong!

Also, if you’re in Boston, Waterloo or Chicago, you can catch me in the coming weeks!.

Abstract: For decades, regulators and corporations have viewed the internet and the computer as versatile material from which special-purpose tools can be fashioned: pornography distribution systems, jihadi recruiting networks, video-on-demand services, and so on.

But the computer is an unprecedented general purpose device capable of running every program we can express in symbolic language, and the internet is the nervous system of the 21st century, webbing these pluripotent computers together.

For decades, activists have been warning regulators and corporations about the peril in getting it wrong when we make policies for these devices, and now the chickens have come home to roost. Frivolous, dangerous and poorly thought-through choices have brought us to the brink of electronic ruin.

We are balanced on the knife-edge of peak indifference — the moment at which people start to care and clamor for action — and the point of no return, the moment at which it’s too late for action to make a difference. There was never a more urgent moment to fight for a free, fair and open internet — and there was never an internet more capable of coordinating that fight.

Cory DoctorowLittle Brother is 10 years old today: I reveal the secret of writing future-proof science fiction

It’s been ten years since the publication of my bestselling novel Little Brother; though the novel was written more than a decade ago, and though it deals with networked computers and mobile devices, it remains relevant, widely read, and widely cited even today.

In an essay for, I write about my formula for creating fiction about technology that stays relevant — the secret is basically to assume that people will be really stupid about technology for the foreseeable future.

And now we come to how to write fiction about networked computers that stays relevant for 12 years and 22 years and 50 years: just write stories in which computers can run all the programs, and almost no one understands that fact. Just write stories in which authority figures, and mass movements, and well-meaning people, and unethical businesses, all insist that because they have a *really good reason* to want to stop some program from running or some message from being received, it *must* be possible.

Write those stories, and just remember that because computers can run every program and the internet can carry any message, every device will someday be a general-purpose computer in a fancy box (office towers, cars, pacemakers, voting machines, toasters, mixer-taps on faucets) and every message will someday be carried on the public internet. Just remember that the internet makes it easier for people of like mind to find each other and organize to work together for whatever purpose stirs them to action, including terrible ones and noble ones. Just remember that cryptography works, that your pocket distraction rectangle can scramble messages so thoroughly that they can never, ever be descrambled, not in a trillion years, without your revealing the passphrase used to protect them. Just remember that swords have two edges, that the universe doesn’t care how badly you want something, and that every time we make a computer a little better for one purpose, we improve it for every purpose a computer can be put to, and that is all purposes.

Just remember that declaring war on general purpose computing is a fool’s errand, and that that never stopped anyone.

Ten Years of Cory Doctorow’s Little Brother [Cory Doctorow/]

(Image: Missy Ward, CC-BY)

TEDTED hosts first-ever TED en Español Spanish-language speaker event at NYC headquarters

Thursday, April 26, 2018 – Today marks the first-ever TED en Español speaker event hosted by TED in its New York City office. The all-Spanish daytime event, held in TED’s theater in Manhattan, will feature eight speakers, a musical performance, five short films and fifteen 1-minute talks given by members of the audience. 150 people are expected to attend from around the world, and about 20 TEDx events in 10 countries plan to tune in to watch remotely.

The New York event is just the latest addition to TED’s sweeping new Spanish-language TED en Español initiative, designed to spread ideas to the global Hispanic community. Led by TED’s Gerry Garbulsky, also head of the world’s largest TEDx event – TEDxRiodelaPlata in Argentina – TED en Español includes a Facebook community, Twitter feed, weekly ¨Boletín¨ newsletter, YouTube channel and – as of earlier this month – an original podcast created in partnership with Univision Communications.

“As part of our nonprofit mission at TED, we work to find and spread the best ideas no matter where the speakers live or what language they speak,” said Gerry. “We want everyone to have access to ideas in their own language. Given the massive global Hispanic population, we’ve begun the work to bring Spanish-language ideas directly to Spanish-speaking audiences, and today event is a major step in solidifying our commitment to that effort.”

Today´s speakers include chef Gastón Acurio, futurist Juan Enriquez, entrepreneur Leticia Gasca, data scientist César A. Hidalgo, founder and funder Rebeca Hwang, ocean expert Enric Sala, assistant conductor of the LA Philharmonic Paolo Bortolameolli, and psychologist and dancer César Silveyra. Musical group LADAMA will perform.


CryptogramNew NSA/Cyber Command Head Confirmed by Senate

Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: A first program in golang, with a short aside about Google


I have reached the point in my life where I needed to write my first program in golang. I pondered for a disturbingly long time what exactly to write, but then it came to me…

Back in the day Google had an internal short URL service (think, but for internal things). It was called “go” and lived at http://go. So what should I write as my first golang program? go of course.

The implementation is on github, and I am sure it isn’t perfect. Remember, it was a learning exercise. I mostly learned that golang syntax is a bit bonkers, and that etcd hates me.

This code stores short URLs in etcd, and redirects you to the right place if it knows about the short code you used. If you just ask for the root URL, you get a list of the currently defined short codes, as well as a form to create new ones. Not bad for a few hours hacking I think.


Worse Than FailureCodeSOD: If Not Null…

Robert needed to fetch some details about pump configurations from the backend. The API was poorly documented, but there were other places in the code which did that, so a quick search found this block:

var getConfiguration = function(){
    var result = null;
    result = getPumpConfiguration (areaID,subStationID,mngmtUnitID,lastServiceDate,service,format,result);
    result = getPumpConfiguration (areaID,subStationID,null,lastServiceDate,null,format,result);
    result = getPumpConfiguration (areaID,subStationID,null,lastServiceDate,service,null,result);
    result = getPumpConfiguration (areaID,subStationID,mngmtUnitID,lastServiceDate,null,null,result);
    result = getPumpConfiguration (areaID,subStationID,null,lastServiceDate,null,null,result);
    return result;

This collection of lines lurked at the end of a 100+ line function, which did a dozen other things. At a glance, it’s mildly perplexing. I can see that result gets passed into the function multiple times, so perhaps this is an attempt at a fluent API? So this series of calls awkwardly fetches the data that’s required? The parameters vary a little with every call, so that must be it, right?

Let’s check the implementation of getPumpConfiguration

function getPumpConfiguration (areaID,subStationID,mngmtUnitID,lastServiceDate,service,format,result) {
    if (result==null) {
    result = queryResult;
    return result;

Oh, no. If the result parameter has a value… we just return it. Otherwise, we attempt to fetch data. This isn’t a fluent API which loads multiple pieces of data with separate requests, it’s an attempt at implementing retries. Hopefully one of those calls works.

[Advertisement] Continuously monitor your servers for configuration changes, and report when there's configuration drift. Get started with Otter today!

Planet Linux AustraliaLinux Users of Victoria (LUV) Announce: LUV May 2018 Workshop

May 19 2018 12:30
May 19 2018 16:30
May 19 2018 12:30
May 19 2018 16:30
Infoxchange, 33 Elizabeth St. Richmond

Topic to be announced

There will also be the usual casual hands-on workshop, Linux installation, configuration and assistance and advice. Bring your laptop if you need help with a particular issue. This will now occur BEFORE the talks from 12:30 to 14:00. The talks will commence at 14:00 (2pm) so there is time for people to have lunch nearby.

The meeting will be held at Infoxchange, 33 Elizabeth St. Richmond 3121.  Late arrivals please call (0421) 775 358 for access to the venue.

LUV would like to acknowledge Infoxchange for the venue.

Linux Users of Victoria is a subcommittee of Linux Australia.

May 19, 2018 - 12:30

Planet Linux AustraliaLinux Users of Victoria (LUV) Announce: LUV May 2018 Main Meeting: "Share" with FOSS Software

May 1 2018 18:30
May 1 2018 20:30
May 1 2018 18:30
May 1 2018 20:30
Kathleen Syme Library, 251 Faraday Street Carlton VIC 3053


6:30 PM to 8:30 PM Tuesday, May 1, 2018
Meeting Room 3, Kathleen Syme Library, 251 Faraday Street Carlton VIC 3053


Linux Users of Victoria is a subcommittee of Linux Australia.

May 1, 2018 - 18:30

read more

Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: etcd v2 and v3 data stores are separate


Just noting this because it wasted way more of my time that it should have…

So you write an etcd app in a different language from your previous apps and it can’t see the data that the other apps wrote? Check the versions of your client libraries. The v2 and v3 data stores in etcd are different, and cannot be seen by each other. You need to convert your v2 data to the v3 data store before it will be visible there.

You’re welcome.



Rondam RamblingsSupport Josh Harder for Congress

I've been quiet lately in part because I'm sinking back into the pit of despair when I think about politics.  The spinelessness and hypocrisy of the Republican party, the insidious and corrosive effects of corporate "free speech" embodied in soulless monsters like Sinclair and Fox News, and the fact that ultimately all this insanity has its foundation in the will of the people (or at least a

TEDCalling all social entrepreneurs + nonprofit leaders: Apply for The Audacious Project

Our first collection of Audacious Project winners takes the stage after a stellar session at TED2018, in which each winner made a big, big wish to move their organization’s vision to the next level with help from a new consortium of nonprofits. As a bonus during the Audacious Project session. we watched an astonishing performance of “New Second Line” from Camille A. Brown and Dancers. From left: The Bail Project’s Robin Steinberg; Heidi M. Sosik of the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute; Caroline Harper of Sight Savers; Vanessa Garrison and T. Morgan Dixon of GirlTrek; Fred Krupp from the Environmental Defense Fund; Chloe Davis and Maleek Washington of Camille A. Brown and Dancers; pianist Scott Patterson; Andrew Youn of the One Acre Fund; and Catherine Foster, Camille A. Brown, Timothy Edwards, Juel D. Lane from Camille A. Brown and Dancers. Obscured behind Catherine Foster is Raj Panjabi of Last Mile Health (and dancer Mayte Natalio is offstage). Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

Creating wide-scale change isn’t easy. It takes incredible passion around an issue, and smart ideas on how to move the needle and, hopefully, improve people’s lives. It requires bottomless energy, a dedicated team, an extraordinary amount of hope. And, of course, it demands real resources.

TED would like to help, on the last part at least. This is an open invitation to all social entrepreneurs and nonprofit leaders: apply to be a part of The Audacious Project in 2019. We’re looking for big, bold, unique ideas that are capable of affecting more than a million people or driving transformational change on a key issue. We’re looking for unexplored plans that have a real, credible path to execution. That can inspire people around the world to come together to act.

Applications for The Audacious Project are open now through June 10. And here’s the best part — this isn’t a long, detailed grant application that will take hours to complete. We’ve boiled it down to the essential questions that can be answered swiftly. So apply as soon as you can. If your idea feels like a good fit, we’ll be in touch with an extended application that you’ll have four weeks to complete.

The Audacious Project process is rigorous — if selected as a Finalist, you’ll participate in an ideation workshop to help clarify your approach and work with us and our partners on a detailed project proposal spanning three to five years. But the work will be worth it, as it can turbocharge your drive toward change.

More than $406 million has already been committed to the first ideas in The Audacious Project. And further support is coming in following the simultaneous launch of the project at both TED2018 and the annual Skoll World Forum last week. Watch the full session from TED, or highlight reel above that screened the next day at Skoll. And who knows? Perhaps you’ll be a part of the program in 2019.

TEDIn Case You Missed It: The dawn of “The Age of Amazement” at TED2018

In Case You Missed It TED2018More than 100 speakers — activists, scientists, adventurers, change-makers and more — took the stage to give the talk of their lives this week in Vancouver at TED2018. One blog post could never hope to hold all of the extraordinary wisdom they shared. Here’s a (shamelessly inexhaustive) list of the themes and highlights we heard throughout the week — and be sure to check out full recaps of day 1, day 2, day 3 and day 4.

Discomfort is a proxy for progress. If we hope to break out of the filter bubbles that are defining this generation, we have to talk to and connect with people we disagree with. This message resonated across the week at TED, with talks from Zachary R. Wood and Dylan Marron showing us the power of reaching out, even when it’s uncomfortable. As Wood, a college student who books “uncomfortable speakers,” says: “Tuning out opposing viewpoints doesn’t make them go away.” To understand how society can progress forward, he says, “we need to understand the counterforces.” Marron’s podcast “Conversations With People Who Hate Me” showcases him engaging with people who have attacked him on the internet. While it hasn’t led to world peace, it has helped him develop empathy for his bullies. “Empathizing with someone I profoundly disagree with doesn’t suddenly erase my deeply held beliefs and endorse theirs,” he cautions. “I simply am acknowledging the humanity of a person who has been taught to think a certain way, someone who thinks very differently than me.”

The Audacious Project, a new initiative for launching big ideas, seeks to create lasting change at scale. (Photo: Ryan Lash / TED)

Audacious ideas for big impact. The Audacious Project, TED’s newest initiative, aims to be the nonprofit version of an IPO. Housed at TED, it’s a collaboration among some of the biggest names in philanthropy that asks for nonprofit groups’ most audacious dreams; each year, five will be presented at TED with an invitation for the audience and world to get involved. The inaugural Audacious group includes public defender Robin Steinberg, who’s working to end the injustice of bail; oceanographer Heidi M. Sosik, who wants to explore the ocean’s twilight zone; Caroline Harper from Sight Savers, who’s working to end the scourge of trachoma; conservationist Fred Krupp, who wants to use the power of satellites and data to track methane emissions in unprecedented detail; and T. Morgan Dixon and Vanessa Garrison, who are inspiring a nationwide movement for Black women’s health. Find out more (and how you can get involved) at

Living means acknowledging death. Philosopher-comedian Emily Levine has stage IV lung cancer — but she says there’s no need to “oy” or “ohhh” over her: she’s OK with it. Life and death go hand in hand, she says; you can’t have one without the other. Therein lies the importance of death: it sets limits on life, limits that “demand creativity, positive energy, imagination” and force you to enrich your existence wherever and whenever you can. Jason Rosenthal’s journey of loss and grief began when his wife, Amy Krouse Rosenthal, wrote about their lives in an article read by millions of people: “You May Want to Marry My Husband” — a meditation on dying disguised as a personal ad for her soon-to-be-solitary spouse. By writing their story, Amy made Jason’s grief public — and challenged him to begin anew. He speaks to others who may be grieving: “I would like to offer you what I was given: a blank sheet of paper. What will you do with your intentional empty space, with your fresh start?”

“It’s the responsibility of all of us to get to know our weaknesses, and make sure they don’t become weapons in the hands of enemies of democracy,” says Yuval Noah Harari. (Photo: Ryan Lash / TED)

Can we rediscover the humanity in our tech?  In a visionary talk about a “globally tragic, astoundingly ridiculous mistake” companies like Google and Facebook made at the foundation of digital culture, Jaron Lanier suggested a way we can fix the internet for good: pay for it. “We cannot have a society in which, if two people wish to communicate, the only way that can happen is if it’s financed by a third person who wishes to manipulate them,” he says. Historian Yuval Noah Harari, appearing onstage as a hologram live from Tel Aviv, warns that with consolidation of data comes consolidation of power. Fascists and dictators, he says, have a lot to gain in our new digital age; and “it’s the responsibility of all of us to get to know our weaknesses, and make sure they don’t become weapons in the hands of enemies of democracy,” he says. Gizmodo writers Kashmir Hill and Surya Mattu survey the world of “smart devices” — the gadgets that “sit in the middle of our home with a microphone on, constantly listening,” and gathering data — to discover just what they’re up to. Hill turned her family’s apartment into a smart home, loading up on 18 internet-connected appliances; her colleague Mattu built a router that tracked how often the devices connected, who they were transmitting to, what they were transmitting. Through the data, he could decipher the Hill family’s sleep schedules, TV binges, even their tooth-brushing habits. And a lot of this data can be sold, including deeply intimate details. “Who is the true beneficiary of your smart home?” he asks. “You, or the company mining you?”

An invitation to build a better world. Actor and activist Tracee Ellis Ross came to TED with a message: the global collection of women’s experiences will not be ignored, and women will no longer be held responsible for the behaviors of men. Ross believes it is past time that men take responsibility to change men’s bad behavior — and she offers an invitation to men, calling them in as allies with the hope they will “be accountable and self-reflective.” She offers a different invitation to women: Acknowledge your fury. “Your fury is not something to be afraid of,” she says. “It holds lifetimes of wisdom. Let it breathe, and listen.”

Wow! discoveries. Among the TED Fellows, explorer and conservationist Steve Boyes’ efforts to chart Africa’s Okavango Delta has led scientists to identify more than 25 new species; University of Arizona astrophysicist Burçin Mutlu-Pakdil discovered a galaxy with an outer ring and a reddish inner ring that was unlike any ever seen before (her reward: it’s now called Burçin’s Galaxy). Another astronomer, University of Hawaii’s Karen Meech saw — and studied for an exhilarating few days — ‘Oumuamua, the first interstellar comet observed from Earth. Meanwhile, engineer Aaswath Raman is harnessing the cold of deep space to invent new ways to keep us cooler and more energy-efficient. Going from the sublime to the ridiculous, roboticist Simone Giertz showed just how much there is to be discovered from the process of inventing useless things.  

Walter Hood shares his work creating public spaces that illuminate shared memories without glossing over past — and present — injustices. (Photo: Ryan Lash / TED)

Language is more than words. Even though the stage program of TED2018 consisted primarily of talks, many went beyond words. Architects Renzo Piano, Vishaan Chakbrabarti, Ian Firth and Walter Hood showed how our built structures, while still being functional, can lift spirits, enrich lives, and pay homage to memories. Smithsonian Museum craft curator Nora Atkinson shared images from Burning Man and explained how, in the desert, she found a spirit of freedom, creativity and collaboration not often found in the commercial art world. Designer Ingrid Fetell Lee uncovered the qualities that make everyday objects a joy to behold. Illustrator Christoph Niemann reminded us how eloquent and hilarious sketches can be; in her portraits of older individuals, photographer Isadora Kosofsky showed us that visuals can be poignant too. Paul Rucker discussed his painful collection of artifacts from America’s racial past and how the artistic act of making scores of Ku Klux Klan robes has brought him some catharsis. Our physical movements are another way we speak  — for choreographer Elizabeth Streb, it’s expressing the very human dream to fly. For climber Alex Honnold, it was attaining a sense of mastery when he scaled El Capitan alone without ropes. Dolby Laboratories chief scientist Poppy Crum demonstrated the emotions that can be read through physical tells like body temperature and exhalations, and analytical chemist Simone Francese revealed the stories told through the molecules in our fingerprints.  

Kate Raworth presents her vision for what a sustainable, universally beneficial economy could look like. (Photo: Bret Hartman / TED)

Is human growth exponential or limited? There will be almost ten billion people on earth by 2050. How are we going to feed everybody, provide water for everybody and get power to everybody? Science journalist Charles C. Mann has spent years asking these questions to researchers, and he’s found that their answers fall into two broad categories: wizards and prophets. Wizards believe that science and technology will let us produce our way out of our dilemmas — think: hyper-efficient megacities and robots tending genetically modified crops. Prophets believe close to the opposite; they see the world as governed by fundamental ecological processes with limits that we transgress to our peril. As he says: “The history of the coming century will be the choice we make as a species between these two paths.” Taking up the cause of the prophets is Oxford economist Kate Raworth, who says that our economies have become “financially, politically and socially addicted” to relentless GDP growth, and too many people (and the planet) are being pummeled in the process. What would a sustainable, universally beneficial economy look like? A doughnut, says Raworth. She says we should strive to move countries out of the hole — “the place where people are falling short on life’s essentials” like food, water, healthcare and housing — and onto the doughnut itself. But we shouldn’t move too far lest we end up on the doughnut’s outside and bust through the planet’s ecological limits.

Seeing opportunity in adversity. “I’m basically nuts and bolts from the knee down,” says MIT professor Hugh Herr, demonstrating how his bionic legs — made up of 24 sensors, 6 microprocessors and muscle-tendon-like actuators — allow him to walk, skip and run. Herr builds body parts, and he’s working toward a goal that’s long been thought of as science fiction: for synthetic limbs to be integrated into the human nervous system. He dreams of a future where humans have augmented their bodies in a way that redefines human potential, giving us unimaginable physical strength — and, maybe, the ability to fly. In a beautiful, touching talk in the closing session of TED2018, Mark Pollock and Simone George take us inside their relationship — detailing how Pollock became paralyzed and the experimental work they’ve undertaken to help him regain motion. In collaboration with a team of engineers who created an exoskeleton for Pollock, as well as Dr. Reggie Edgerton’s team at UCLA, who developed a way to electrically stimulate the spinal cord of those with paralysis, Pollock was able to pull his knee into his chest during a lab test — proving that progress is definitely still possible.

TED Fellow and anesthesiologist Rola Hallam started the world’s first crowdfunded hospital in Syria. (Photo: Ryan Lash / TED)

Spotting the chance to make a difference. The TED Fellows program was full of researchers, activists and advocates capitalizing on the spaces that go unnoticed. Psychiatrist Essam Daod, found a “golden hour” in refugees’ treks when their narratives can sometimes be reframed into heroes’ journeys; landscape architect Kotcharkorn Voraakhom realized that a park could be designed to allow her flood-prone city of Bangkok mitigate the impact of climate change; pediatrician Lucy Marcil seized on the countless hours that parents spend in doctors’ waiting rooms to offer tax assistance; sustainability expert DeAndrea Salvador realized the profound difference to be made by helping low-income North Carolina residents with their energy bills; and anesthesiologist Rola Hallam is addressing aid shortfalls for local nonprofits, resulting in the world’s first crowdfunded hospital in Syria.

Catch up on previous In Case You Missed It posts from April 10 (Day 1), April 11 (Day 2), April 12 (Day 3), and yesterday, April 13 (Day 4).

Planet DebianJonathan McDowell: Using collectd for Exim stats

I like graphing things; I find it’s a good way to look for abnormal patterns or try to track down the source of problems. For monitoring systems I started out with MRTG. It’s great for monitoring things via SNMP, but everything else needs some custom scripts. So at one point I moved my home network over to Munin, which is much better at graphing random bits and pieces, and coping with collecting data from remote hosts. Unfortunately it was quite heavyweight on the Thecus N2100 I was running as the central collection point at the time; data collection resulted in a lot of forking and general sluggishness. So I moved to collectd, which is written in C, relies much more on compiled plugins and doesn’t do a load of forks. It also supports a UDP based network protocol with authentication + encryption, which makes it great for running on hosts that aren’t always up - the collection point doesn’t hang around waiting for them when they’re not around.

The problem is that when it comes to things collectd doesn’t support out of the box it’s not quite so easy to get the stats - things a simple script would sort in MRTG need a bit more thought. You can go the full blown Python module route as I did for my Virgin Super Hub scripts, but that requires a bit of work. One of the things in particular I wanted to graph were stats for my mail servers and having to write a chunk of Python to do that seemed like overkill. Searching around found the Tail plugin, which follows a log file and applies regexes to look for stats. There are some examples for Exim on that page, but none were quite what I wanted. In case it’s of interest/use to anyone else, here’s what I ended up with (on Debian, of course, but I can’t see why it wouldn’t work elsewhere with minimal changes).

First I needed a new data set specification for email counts. I added this to /usr/share/collectd/types.db:

mail_count              value:COUNTER:0:65535

Note if you’re logging to a remote collectd host this needs to be on both the host where the stats are collected and the one receiving the stats.

I then dropped a file in /etc/collectd/collectd.conf.d/ called exim.conf containing the following. It’ll need tweaked depending on exactly what you log, but the first 4 <Match> stanzas should be generally useful. I have some additional logging (via log_message entries in the exim.conf deny statements) that helps me track mails that get greylisted, rejected due to ClamAV or rejected due to being listed in a DNSRBL. Tailor as appropriate for your setup:

LoadPlugin tail

<Plugin tail>
    <File "/var/log/exim4/mainlog">
        Instance "exim"
        Interval 60
            Regex "S=([1-9][0-9]*)"
            DSType "CounterAdd"
            Type "ipt_bytes"
            Instance "total"
            Regex "<="
            DSType "CounterInc"
            Type "mail_count"
            Instance "incoming"
            Regex "=>"
            DSType "CounterInc"
            Type "mail_count"
            Instance "outgoing"
            Regex "=="
            DSType "CounterInc"
            Type "mail_count"
            Instance "defer"
            Regex ": greylisted.$"
            DSType "CounterInc"
            Type "mail_count"
            Instance "greylisted"
            Regex "rejected after DATA: Malware:"
            DSType "CounterInc"
            Type "mail_count"
            Instance "malware"
            Regex "> rejected RCPT <.* is listed at"
            DSType "CounterInc"
            Type "mail_count"
            Instance "dnsrbl"

Finally, because my mail servers are low volume these days, I added a scaling filter to give me emails/minute rather than emails/second. This went in /etc/collectd/collectd.conf.d/filters.conf:

PreCacheChain "PreCache"
LoadPlugin match_regex
LoadPlugin target_scale

<Chain "PreCache">
        <Match "regex">
            Plugin "^tail$"
            PluginInstance "^exim$"
            Type "^mail_count$"
            Invert false
        <Target "scale">
            Factor 60

Update: Some examples…

Total email bytes Incoming email count Outgoing email count Deferred email count Emails rejected due to DNSRBL Greylisted email count Emails rejected due to malware

Krebs on SecurityDDoS-for-Hire Service Webstresser Dismantled

Authorities in the U.S., U.K. and the Netherlands on Tuesday took down popular online attack-for-hire service and arrested its alleged administrators. Investigators say that prior to the takedown, the service had more than 136,000 registered users and was responsible for launching somewhere between four and six million attacks over the past three years.

The action, dubbed “Operation Power Off,” targeted (previously, one of the most active services for launching point-and-click distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) attacks. WebStresser was one of many so-called “booter” or “stresser” services — virtual hired muscle that anyone can rent to knock nearly any website or Internet user offline. (formerly, as it appeared in 2017.

“The damage of these attacks is substantial,” reads a statement from the Dutch National Police in a Reddit thread about the takedown. “Victims are out of business for a period of time, and spend money on mitigation and on (other) security measures.”

In a separate statement released this morning, Europol — the law enforcement agency of the European Union — said “further measures were taken against the top users of this marketplace in the Netherlands, Italy, Spain, Croatia, the United Kingdom, Australia, Canada and Hong Kong.” The servers powering WebStresser were located in Germany, the Netherlands and the United States, according to Europol.

The U.K.’s National Crime Agency said WebStresser could be rented for as little as $14.99, and that the service allowed people with little or no technical knowledge to launch crippling DDoS attacks around the world.

Neither the Dutch nor U.K. authorities would say who was arrested in connection with this takedown. But according to information obtained by KrebsOnSecurity, the administrator of WebStresser allegedly was a 19-year-old from Prokuplje, Serbia named Jovan Mirkovic.

Mirkovic, who went by the hacker nickname “m1rk,” also used the alias “Mirkovik Babs” on Facebook where for years he openly discussed his role in programming and ultimately running WebStresser. The last post on Mirkovic’s Facebook page, dated April 3 (the day before the takedown), shows the young hacker sipping what appears to be liquor while bathing. Below that image are dozens of comments left in the past few hours, most of them simply, “RIP.”

A story in the Serbia daily news site notes that two men from Serbia were arrested in conjunction with the WebStresser takedown; they are named only as “MJ” (Jovan Mirkovik) and D.V., aged 19 from Ruma.

Mirkovik’s fake Facebook page (Mirkovik Babs) includes countless mentions of another Webstresser administrator named “Kris” and includes a photograph of a tattoo that Kris got in 2015. That same tattoo is shown on the Facebook profile of a Kristian Razum from Zapresic, Croatia. According to the press releases published today, one of the administrators arrested was from Croatia.

Multiple sources are now pointing to other booter businesses that were reselling WebStresser’s service but which are no longer functional as a result of the takedown, including powerboot[dot]net, defcon[dot]pro, ampnode[dot]com, ripstresser[dot]com, fruitstresser[dot]com, topbooter[dot]com, freebooter[dot]co and rackstress[dot]pw.

Tuesday’s action against WebStresser is the latest such takedown to target both owners and customers of booter services. Many booter service operators apparently believe (or at least hide behind) a wordy “terms of service” agreement that all customers must acknowledge, under the assumption that somehow this absolves them of any sort of liability for how their customers use the service — regardless of how much hand-holding and technical support booter service administrators offer customers.

In October the FBI released an advisory warning that the use of booter services is punishable under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, and may result in arrest and criminal prosecution.

In 2016, authorities in Israel arrested two 18-year-old men accused of running vDOS, until then the most popular and powerful booter service on the market. Their arrests came within hours of a story at KrebsOnSecurity that named the men and detailed how their service had been hacked.

Many in the hacker community have criticized authorities for targeting booter service administrators and users and for not pursuing what they perceive as more serious cybercriminals, noting that the vast majority of both groups are young men under the age of 21. In its Reddit thread, the Dutch Police addressed this criticism head-on, saying Dutch authorities are working on a new legal intervention called “Hack_Right,” a diversion program intended for first-time cyber offenders.

“Prevention of re-offending by offering a combination of restorative justice, training, coaching and positive alternatives is the main aim of this project,” the Dutch Police wrote. “See page 24 of the 5th European Cyber Security Perspectives and stay tuned on our THTC twitter account #HackRight! AND we are working on a media campaign to prevent youngsters from starting to commit cyber crimes in the first place. Expect a launch soon.”

In the meantime, it’s likely we’ll sooner see the launch of yet more booter services. According to reviews and sales threads at stresserforums[dot]net — a marketplace for booter buyers and sellers — there are dozens of other booter services in operation, with new ones coming online almost every month.

Sociological ImagesBoozy Milkshakes and Sordid Spirits

The first nice weekend after a long, cold winter in the Twin Cities is serious business. A few years ago some local diners joined the celebration with a serious indulgence: the boozy milkshake.

When talking with a friend of mine from the Deep South about these milkshakes, she replied, “oh, a bushwhacker! We had those all the time in college.” This wasn’t the first time she had dropped southern slang that was new to me, so off to Google I went.

According to Merriam-Webster, “to bushwhack” means to attack suddenly and unexpectedly, as one would expect the alcohol in a milkshake to sneak up on you. The cocktail is a Nashville staple, but the origins trace back to the Virgin Islands in the 1970s.

Photo Credit: Beebe Bourque, Flickr CC
Photo Credit: Like_the_Grand_Canyon, Flickr CC

Here’s the part where the history takes a sordid turn: “Bushwhacker” was apparently also the nickname for guerrilla fighters in the Confederacy during the Civil War who would carry out attacks in rural areas (see, for example, the Lawrence Massacre). To be clear, I don’t know and don’t mean to suggest this had a direct influence in the naming of the cocktail. Still, the coincidence reminded me of the famous, and famously offensive, drinking reference to conflict in Northern Ireland.

Battle of Lawrence, Wikimedia Commons

When sociologists talk about concepts like “cultural appropriation,” we often jump to clear examples with a direct connection to inequality and oppression like racist halloween costumes or ripoff products—cases where it is pretty easy to look at the object in question and ask, “didn’t they think about this for more than thirty seconds?”

Cases like the bushwhacker raise different, more complicated questions about how societies remember history. Even if the cocktail today had nothing to do with the Confederacy, the weight of that history starts to haunt the name once you know it. I think many people would be put off by such playful references to modern insurgent groups like ISIS. Then again, as Joseph Gusfield shows, drinking is a morally charged activity in American society. It is interesting to see how the deviance of drinking dovetails with bawdy, irreverent, or offensive references to other historical and social events. Can you think of other drinks with similar sordid references? It’s not all sex on the beach!

Evan Stewart is a Ph.D. candidate in sociology at the University of Minnesota. You can follow him on Twitter.

(View original at

CryptogramTwo NSA Algorithms Rejected by the ISO

The ISO has rejected two symmetric encryption algorithms: SIMON and SPECK. These algorithms were both designed by the NSA and made public in 2013. They are optimized for small and low-cost processors like IoT devices.

The risk of using NSA-designed ciphers, of course, is that they include NSA-designed backdoors. Personally, I doubt that they're backdoored. And I always like seeing NSA-designed cryptography (particularly its key schedules). It's like examining alien technology.

Worse Than FailureThe Search for Truth

Every time you change existing code, you break some other part of the system. You may not realize it, but you do. It may show up in the form of a broken unit test, but that presumes that a) said unit test exists, and b) it properly tests the aspect of the code you are changing. Sadly, more often than not, there is either no test to cover your change, or any test that does exist doesn't handle the case you are changing.

Nicolai Abildgaard - Diogenes der lyser i mørket med en lygte.jpg

This is especially true if the thing you are changing is simple. It is even more true when changing something as complex as working with a boolean.

Mr A. was working at a large logistics firm that had an unusual error where a large online retailer was accidentally overcharged by millions of dollars. When large companies send packages to logistics hubs for shipment, they often send hundreds or thousands of them at a time on the same pallet, van or container (think about companies like Amazon). The more packages you send in these batches the less you pay (a single lorry is cheaper than a fleet of vans). These packages are lumped together and billed at a much lower rate than you or I would get.

One day, a particular developer saw something untidy in the code - an uninitialized Boolean variable in one of the APIs. The entire code change was from this:


to this:

    parcel.consolidated = false;

There are some important things to note: the code was written in NodeJS and didn't really have the concept of Boolean, the developers did not believe in Unit Testing, and in a forgotten corner of the codebase was a little routine that examined each parcel to see if the discount applied.

The routine to see if the discount should be applied ran every few minutes. It looked at each package and if it was marked as consolidated or not, then it moved on to the next parcel. If the flag was NULL, then it applied the rules to see if was part of a shipment and set the flag to either True or False.

That variable was not Boolean but rather tri-state (though thankfully didn't involve FILE_NOT_FOUND). By assuming it was Boolean and initializing it, NO packages had a discount applied. Oopsie!

It took more than a month before anyone noticed and complained. And since it was a multi-million dollar mistake, they complained loudly!

Even after this event, Unit Testing was still not accepted as a useful practice. To this day Release Management, Unit Testing, Automated Testing and Source Code Management remain stubbornly absent...

Not long after this, Mr. A. continued his search for truth elsewhere.

[Advertisement] Continuously monitor your servers for configuration changes, and report when there's configuration drift. Get started with Otter today!

Planet DebianJulien Danjou: Correct HTTP scheme in WSGI with Cloudflare

Correct HTTP scheme in WSGI with Cloudflare

I've recently been using Cloudflare as an HTTP frontend for some applications, and getting things working correctly with WSGI was unobvious.

In Python, WSGI is the standard protocol to write a Web application. All Web frameworks that I know follows it. And many of those Web frameworks leverage some request environment variables to learn how the request has been made.

One of those environment variables is wsgi.url_scheme, and it contains either http or https, depending on the protocol that has been used to connect to your WSGI server.

And that's where things can get messy. If you enable SSL at Cloudflare in "Flexible" mode, your visitor will connect to your Web site using HTTPS, but Cloudflare will connect to your backend using HTTP. That means that for your application, the traffic will appear to be over HTTP, and not HTTPS: wsgi.url_scheme will be set to http.

Correct HTTP scheme in WSGI with Cloudflare

That can lead to several problems with some frameworks. For example, the function url_for of Flask will rely on this variable to generate the scheme part of any URL. In this case, it would, therefore, generate URL starting with http:// whereas your visitors are using https.

The usual workaround is to leverage the X-Forwarded-Proto that is actually set by Cloudflare. In the case where Cloudflare proxies the request to your HTTP host, this will be set to https. By using the werkzeug.contrib.fixers.ProxyFix module, the variable wsgi.url_scheme will be set to what X-Forwarded-Proto is set.

That would work fine for any application that is directly behind Cloudflare, or any single HTTP reverse proxy.

But that does not work as soon as you have multiple reverse proxies. If your application runs on top of Heroku for example, they already provide a reverse proxy and overwrite those headers. That gives the following: Visitor -HTTPS-> Cloudflare -HTTP-> Heroku proxy -HTTP-> Heroku dyno. Once your dyno is reacher, X-Forwarded-For will be set to http.

Damn it!

The proper solution is, therefore, to have all your proxies implement RFC7239. This RFC defines a new Forwarded header that can contain all the hops that have forwarded this request, including all the scheme and IP addresses. Unfortunately, this is not implemented by Cloudflare nor Heroku. Bummer!

Finally, Cloudflare provides yet another custom header named Cf-Visitor. It contains a JSON payload with the original HTTP scheme used by the visitor: we can use that to solve our issue. Here's a WSGI middleware to do that:

class CloudflareProxy(object):
    """This middleware sets the proto scheme based on the Cf-Visitor header."""

    def __init__(self, app): = app

    def __call__(self, environ, start_response):
        cf_visitor = environ.get("HTTP_CF_VISITOR")
        if cf_visitor:
                cf_visitor = json.loads(cf_visitor)
            except ValueError:
                proto = cf_visitor.get("scheme")
                if proto is not None:
                    environ['wsgi.url_scheme'] = proto
        return, start_response)

You can then use it to encapsulate your WSGI application with app = CloudflareProxy(app).

If you're using JavaScript, I noticed that the forwarded library provides that same support for Cloudflare along all the other headers – even RFC7239!

CryptogramComputer Alarm that Triggers When Lid Is Opened

"Do Not Disturb" is a Macintosh app that send an alert when the lid is opened. The idea is to detect computer tampering.

Wired article:

Do Not Disturb goes a step further than just the push notification. Using the Do Not Disturb iOS app, a notified user can send themselves a picture snapped with the laptop's webcam to catch the perpetrator in the act, or they can shut down the computer remotely. The app can also be configured to take more custom actions like sending an email, recording screen activity, and keeping logs of commands executed on the machine.

Can someone please make one of these for Windows?


Planet DebianCarl Chenet: Use Nginx Unit 1.0 with your Django project on Debian Stretch

Nginx Unit 1.0 was released 2018, April the 12th. It is a new application server written by the Nginx team.

Some features are really interesting, such as:

  • Fully dynamic reconfiguration using RESTful JSON API
  • Multiple application languages and versions can run simultaneously

I was setting up a new Django project at this time and it was a great opportunity to start using Unit. It has some unexpected pitfalls to install and configure.

1. Installing Nginx Unit for Django

Installing Unit is quite straightforward. I use a Debian Stretch. If you have another system, have a look at the official documentation.

If you install Unit on a dedicated server using a grsecurity kernel, it won’t work. Using the kernel of your GNU/Linux distributions solves this issue.

First we need to get the key of the remote Debian Nginx repository:

# wget -q -O - | apt-key add

Next, create the /etc/apt/sources.list.d/unit.list file with the following lines:

deb stretch unit
deb-src stretch unit

Now update your list of repositories, install Nginx Unit and the module for Python 3:

# apt-get update
# apt install unit unit-python3.5

Now activate the Systemd unit service (yep, confusing, poor name choice IMO) and start Nginx Unit :

# systemctl enable unit
# systemctl start unit
# systemctl status unit
 ● unit.service - NGINX Unit
 Loaded: loaded (/lib/systemd/system/unit.service; enabled; vendor preset: enabled)
 Active: active (running) since Sat 2018-04-21 16:51:31 CEST; 18h ago

2. Configure Nginx Unit

In order to configure Unit, you need to write a JSON file and post it to the Unit sock file on your server.

Here is my JSON configuration:

 "listeners": {
   "": {
   "application": "myapp"

"applications": {
  "myapp": {
    "type": "python",
    "processes": 5,
    "module": "myapp.wsgi",
    "user": "myapp",
    "group": "myapp",
    "path": "/home/myapp/prod/myapp"

Ok, here is a pitfall. You need to understand that Unit will use the path parameter as your application root, then try to load the from the module parameter. So here it means that my is located in /home/myapp/prod/myapp/myapp/

Now we’re ready to inject our Unit configuration with curl:

# curl -X PUT -d @myapp.unit.json --unix-socket /var/run/control.unit.sock http://localhost/
 "success": "Reconfiguration done."

Great, now we need our good ol’ Nginx web server as a web proxy in front of Nginx Unit.

3. Install and configure Nginx with Let’s Encrypt

Let’s start by installing the Nginx webserver:

# apt install nginx

To configure Nginx, we will define an upstream receiving the requests from the Nginx web server. We also define a /static/ to indicate the Django static directory.

Here is the Nginx configuration you can put in /etc/nginx/conf.d:

upstream unit_backend {

server {
 listen 80;
 return 301$request_uri;

server {
 listen 443 ssl;
 ssl_certificate /etc/letsencrypt/live/;
 ssl_certificate_key /etc/letsencrypt/live/;

 access_log /var/log/nginx/;
 error_log /var/log/nginx/myapp.error.log;

root /home/myapp/prod/myapp;

location = /favicon.ico { access_log off; log_not_found off; }
 location /static {
 root /home/myapps/prod/myapp;

location / {
 proxy_pass http://unit_backend;
 proxy_set_header Host $host;
 location /.well-known {
 allow all;

Before starting Nginx (stop it if it is running), we’ll get our SSL certificate from Let’s Encrypt.

# certbot certonly -d

Spin a temporary web server and get your certificate.

Now we’re almost ready. Start the Nginx web server:

# systemctl start nginx

4. Configure Django for production

Your Django settings file, here the /home/myapp/prod/myapp/myapp/ file should use paths existing on your server e.g you should have  the following STATIC_ROOT in the of your app:

STATIC_ROOT = '/home/myapp/prod/myapp/static/'

Pitfall here: the root in the Nginx configuration for the static we wrote above is one level upper: /home/myapp/prod/myapp Use the correct path or your static won’t appear.

Just a last step for Django: at the root of your Django app, you need to collect the static files in the dedicated directory with the following command:

$ python3 collectstatic


This setup runs in production. Except two pitfalls, it’s quite straightforward to setup. If you encounter any error, please write a comment below and I’ll fix the article.

About Me

Carl Chenet, Free Software Indie Hacker, Founder of, a job board for Free and Open Source Jobs in France.

Follow Me On Social Networks


CryptogramBaseball Code

Info on the coded signals used by the Colorado Rockies.

TEDMore TED2018 conference shorts to amuse and amaze

Even in the Age of Amazement, sometimes you need a break between talks packed with fascinating science, tech, art and so much more. That’s where interstitials come in: short videos that entertain and intrigue, while allowing the brain a moment to reset and ready itself to absorb more information.

For this year’s conference, TED commissioned and premiered four short films made just for the conference. Check out those films here!

Mixed in with our originals, curators Anyssa Samari and Jonathan Wells hand-picked even more videos — animations, music, even cool ads — to play throughout the week. Here’s the program of shorts they found, from creative people all around the world:

The short: Jane Zhang: “Dust My Shoulders Off.” A woman having a bad day is transported to a world of famous paintings where she has a fantastic adventure.

The creator: Outerspace Leo

Shown during: Session 2, After the end of history …

The short: “zoom(art).” A kaleidoscopic, visually compelling journey of artificial intelligence creating beautiful works of art.

The creator: Directed and programmed by Alexander Mordvintsev, Google Research

Shown during: Session 2, After the end of history …

The short: “20syl – Kodama.” A music video of several hands playing multiple instruments (and drawing a picture) simultaneously to create a truly delicious electronic beat.

The creators: Mathieu Le Dude & 20syl

Shown during: Session 3, Nerdish Delight

The short: “If HAL-9000 was Alexa.” 2001: A Space Odyssey seems a lot less sinister (and lot more funny) when Alexa can’t quite figure out what Dave is saying.

The creator: ScreenJunkies

Shown during: Session 3, Nerdish Delight

The short: “Maxine the Fluffy Corgi.” A narrated day in the life of an adorable pup named Maxine who knows what she wants.

The creator: Bryan Reisberg

Shown during: Session 3, Nerdish Delight

The short: “RGB FOREST.” An imaginative, colorful and geometric jaunt through the woods set to jazzy electronic music.

The creator: LOROCROM

Shown during: Session 6, What on earth do we do?

The short: “High Speed Hummingbirds.” Here’s your chance to watch the beauty and grace of hummingbirds in breathtaking slow motion.

The creator: Anand Varma

Shown during: Session 6, What on earth do we do?

The short: “Cassius ft. Cat Power & Pharrell Williams | Go Up.” A split screen music video that cleverly subverts and combines versions of reality.

The creator: Alex Courtès

Shown during: Session 7, Wow. Just wow.

The short: “Blobby.” A stop motion film about a man and a blob and the peculiar relationship they share.

The creator: Laura Stewart

Shown during: Session 7, Wow. Just wow.

The short: “WHO.” David Byrne and St. Vincent dance and sing in this black-and-white music video about accidents and consequences.

The creator: Martin de Thurah

Shown during: Session 8, Insanity. Humanity.

The short: “MAKIN’ MOVES.” When music makes the body move in unnatural, impossible ways.

The creator: Kouhei Nakama

Shown during: Session 9, Body electric

The short: “The Art of Flying.” The beautiful displays the Common Starling performs in nature.

The creator: Jan van IJken

Shown during: Session 9, Body electric

The short: “Kiss & Cry.” The heart-rending story of Giselle, a woman who lives and loves and wants to be loved. (You’ll never guess who plays the heroine.)

The creators: Jaco Van Dormael and choreographer Michèle Anne De Mey

Shown during: Session 10, Personally speaking

The short: “Becoming Violet.” The power of the human body, in colors and dance.

The creator: Steven Weinzierl

Shown during: Session 10, Personally speaking

The short: “Golden Castle Town.” A woman is transported to another world and learns to appreciate life anew.

The creator: Andrew Benincasa

Shown during: Session 10, Personally speaking

The short: “Tom Rosenthal | Cos Love.” A love letter to love that is grand and a bit melacholic.

The creator: Kathrin Steinbacher

Shown during: Session 11, What matters

TEDInsanity. Humanity. Notes from Session 8 at TED2018

If we want to create meaningful technology to counter radicalization, we have to start with the human journey at its core,” says technologist Yasmin Green at Session 8 at TED2018: The Age of Amazement, April 13, Vancouver. Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

The seven speakers lived up to the two words in the title of the session. Their talks showcased both our collective insanity — the algorithmically-assembled extremes of the Internet — and our humanity — the values and desires that extremists astutely tap into — along with some speakers combining the two into a glorious salad. Let’s dig in.

Artificial Intelligence = artificial stupidity. How does a sweetly-narrated video of hands unwrapping Kinder eggs garner 30 million views and spawn more than 10 million imitators? Welcome to the weird world of YouTube children’s videos, where an army of content creators use YouTube “to hack the brains of very small children, in return for advertising revenue,” as artist and technology critic James Bridle describes. Marketing ethics aside, this world seems innocuous on the surface but go a few clicks deeper and you’ll find a surreal and sinister landscape of algorithmically-assembled cartoons, nursery rhymes built from keyword combos, and animated characters and human actors being tortured, assaulted and killed. Automated copycats mimic trusted content providers “using the same mechanisms that power Facebook and Google to create ‘fake news’ for kids,” says Bridle. He adds that feeding the situation is the fact “we’re training them from birth to click on the very first link that comes along, regardless of where the source is.” As technology companies ignore these problems in their quest for ad dollars, the rest of us are stuck in a system in which children are sent down auto-playing rabbit holes where they see disturbing videos filled with very real violence and very real trauma — and get traumatized as a result. Algorithms are touted as the fix, but Bridle declares, “Machine learning, as any expert on it will tell you, is what we call software that does stuff we don’t really understand, and I think we have enough of that already,” he says. Instead, “we need to think of technology not as a solution to all our problems but as a guide to what they are.” After his talk, TED Head of Curation Helen Walters has a blunt question for Bridle: “So are we doomed?” His realistic but ungrim answer: “We’ve got a hell of a long way to go, but talking is the beginning of that process.”

Technology that fights extremism and online abuse. Over the last few years, we’ve seen geopolitical forces wreak havoc with their use of the Internet. At Jigsaw (a division of Alphabet), Yasmin Green and her colleagues were given the mandate to build technology that could help make the world safer from extremism and persecution. “Radicalization isn’t a yes or no choice,” she says. “It’s a process, during which people have questions about ideology, religion — and they’re searching online for answers which is an opportunity to reach them.” In 2016, Green collaborated with Moonshot CVE to pilot a new approach called the “Redirect Method.” She and a team interviewed dozens of former members of violent extremist groups and used that information to create a campaign that deployed targeted advertising to reach people susceptible to ISIS’s recruiting and show them videos to counter those messages. Available in English and Arabic, the eight-week pilot program reached more than 300,000 people. In another project, she and her team looked for a way to combat online abuse. Partnering across Google with Wikipedia and the New York Times, the team trained machine-learning models to understand the emotional impact of language — specifically, to predict comments that were likely to make someone leave a conversation and to give commenters real-time feedback about how their words might land. Due to the onslaught of online vitriol, the Times had previously enabled commenting on only 10 percent of homepage stories, but this strategy led it to open up all homepage stories to comments. “If we ever thought we could build technology insulated from the dark side of humanity, we were wrong,” Green says. “If technology has any hope of overcoming today’s challenges, we must throw our entire selves into understanding these issues and create solutions that are as human as the problems they aim to solve.” In a post-talk Q & A, Green adds that banning certain keywords isn’t enough of a solution: “We need to combine human insight with innovation.”

Living life means acknowledging death. Philosopher-comedian Emily Levine starts her talk with some bad news — she’s got stage 4 lung cancer — but says there’s no need to “oy” or “ohhh” over her: she’s okay with it. After all, explains Levine, life and death go hand in hand; you can’t have one without the other. In fact, therein lies the importance of death: it sets limits on life, limits that “demand creativity, positive energy, imagination” and force you to enrich your existence wherever and whenever you can. Levine muses about the scientists who are attempting to thwart death — she dubs them the Anti-Life Brigade — and calls them ungrateful and disrespectful in their efforts to wrest control from nature. “We don’t live in the clockwork universe,” she says wryly. “We live in a banana peel universe,” where our attempts at mastery will always come up short against mystery. She has come to view life as a “gift that you enrich as best you can and then give back.” And just as we should appreciate that life’s boundary line stops abruptly at death, we should accept our own intellectual and physical limits. “We won’t ever be able to know everything or control everything or predict everything,” says Levine. “Nature is like a self-driving car.” We may have some control, but we’re not at the wheel.

A high-schooler working on the future of AI. Is artificial intelligence actually intelligence? Not yet, says Kevin Frans. Earlier in his teen years — he’s now just 18 — he joined the OpenAI lab to think about the fascinating problem of making AI that has true intelligence. Right now, he says, a lot of we call intelligence is just trial-and-error on a massive scale — machines try every possible solution, even ones too absurd for a human to imagine, until it finds the thing that works best to solve a single discrete problem. That can create computers that are champions at Go or Q-Bert, but it really doesn’t create general intelligence. So Frans is conceptualizing instead a way to think about AI from a skills perspective — specifically, the ability to learn simple skills and assemble them to accomplish tasks. It’s early days for this approach, and for Kevin himself, who is part of the first generation to grow up as AI natives and think with these machines. What can he and these new brains accomplish together?

Come fly with her. From a young age, action and hardware engineer Elizabeth Streb wanted to fly like, well, a fly or a bird. It took her years of painful experimentation to realize that humans can’t swoop and veer like them, but perhaps she could discover how humans could fly. Naturally, it involves more falling than staying airborne. She has jumped through broken glass and toppled from great heights in order to push the bounds of her vertical comfort zone. With her Streb Extreme Action company, she’s toured the world, bringing the delight and wonder of human flight to audiences. Along the way, she realized, “If we wanted to go higher, faster, sooner, harder and make new discoveries, it was necessary to create our very own space-ships,” so she’s also built hardware to provide a boost. More recently, she opened Brooklyn’s Streb Lab for Action Mechanics (SLAM) to instruct others. “As it turns out, people don’t just want to dream about flying, nor do they want to watch people like us fly; they want to do it, too, and they can,” she says. In teaching, she sees “smiles become more common, self-esteem blossom, and people get just a little bit braver. People do learn to fly, as only humans can.”

Calling all haters. “You’re everything I hate in a human being” — that’s just one of the scores of nasty messages that digital creator Dylan Marron receives every day. While his various video series such as “Every Single Word” and “Sitting in Bathrooms With Trans People” have racked up millions of views, they’ve also sent a slew of Internet poison in his direction. “At first, I would screenshot their comments and make fun of their typos but this felt elitist and unhelpful,” recalls Marron. Over time, he developed an unexpected coping mechanism: he calls the people responsible for leaving hateful remarks on his social media, opening their chats with a simple question: “Why did you write that?” These exchanges have been captured on Marron’s podcast “Conversations With People Who Hate Me.” While it hasn’t led to world peace — you would have noticed — he says it’s caused him to develop empathy for his bullies. “Empathizing with someone I profoundly disagree with doesn’t suddenly erase my deeply held beliefs and endorse theirs,” he cautions. “I simply am acknowledging the humanity of a person who has been taught to think a certain way, someone who thinks very differently than me.” And he stresses that his solution is not right for everyone . In a Q & A afterward, he says that some people have told him that his podcast just gives a platform to those espousing harmful ideologies. Marron emphasizes, “Empathy is not endorsement.” His conversations represent his own way of responding to online hate, and he says, “I see myself as a little tile in the mosaic of activism.”

Rebuilding trust at work. Trust is the foundation for everything we humans do, but what do we do when it is broken? It’s a problem that fascinates Frances Frei, a professor at Harvard Business School who recently spent six months trying to restore trust at Uber. According to Frei, trust is a three-legged stool that rests on authenticity, logic, and empathy. “If any one of these three gets shaky, if any one of these three wobbles, trust is threatened,” she explains. So which wobbles did Uber have? All of them, according to Frei. Authenticity was the hardest to fix – but that’s not uncommon. “It is still much easier to coach people to fit in; it is still much easier to reward people when they say something that you were going to say,” Frei says, “but when we figure out how to celebrate difference and how to let people bring the best version of themselves forward, well, holy cow, is that the world I want my sons to grow up in.” You can read more about her talk here.

TEDWhat matters: Notes from Session 11 of TED2018

Reed Hastings, the head of Netflix, listens to a question from Chris Anderson during a sparky onstage Q&A on the final morning of TED2018, April 14, 2018. Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

What a week. We’ve heard so much, from dystopian warnings to bold visions for change. Our brains are full. Almost. In this session we pull back to the human stories that underpin everything we are, everything we want. From new ways to set goals and move business forward, to unabashed visions for joy and community, it’s time to explore what matters.

The original people of this land. One important thing to know: TED’s conference home of Vancouver is built on un-ceded land that once belonged to First Nations people. So this morning, two DJs from A Tribe Called Red start this session by remembering and honoring them, telling First Nations stories in beats and images in a set that expands on the concept of Halluci Nation, inspired by the poet, musician and activist John Trudell. In Trudell’s words: “We are the Halluci Nation / Our DNA is of earth and sky / Our DNA is of past and future.”

The power of why, what and how. Our leaders and our institutions are failing us, and it’s not always because they’re bad or unethical. Sometimes, it’s simply because they’re leading us toward the wrong objectives, says venture capitalist John Doerr. How can we get back on track? The trick may be a system called OKR, developed by legendary management thinker Andy Grove. Doerr explains that OKR stands for ‘objectives and key results’ – and setting the right ones can be the difference between success and failure. However, before you set your objective (your what) and your key results (your how), you need to understand your why. “A compelling sense of why can be the launch pad for our objectives,” he says. He illustrates the power of OKRs by sharing the stories of individuals and organizations who’ve put them into practice, including Google’s Larry Page and Sergey Brin. “OKRs are not a silver bullet. They’re not going to be a substitute for a strong culture or for stronger leadership, but when those fundamentals are in place, they can take you to the mountaintop,” he says. He encourages all of us to take the time to write down our values, our objectives, and our key results – and to do it today. “Let’s fight for what it is that really matters, because we can take OKRs beyond our businesses. We can take them to our families, to our schools, even to our government. We can hold those governments accountable,” he says. “We can get back on the right track if we can and do measure what really matters.”

What’s powering China’s tech innovation? The largest mass migration in the world occurs every year around the Chinese Spring Festival. Over 40 days, travelers — including 290 million migrant workers — take 3 billion trips all over China. Few can afford to fly, so railways strained to keep up, with crowding, fraud and drama. So the Chinese technology sector has been building everything from apps to AI to ease not only this process, but other pain points throughout society. But unlike the US, where innovation is often fueled by academia and enterprise, China’s tech innovation is powered by “an overwhelming need economy that is serving an underprivileged populace, which has been separated for 30 years from China’s economic boom.” The CEO of the China Morning Post, Gary Liu has a front-row seat to this transformation. As China’s introduction of a “social credit rating” system suggests, a technology boom in an authoritarian society hides a significant dark side. But the Chinese internet hugely benefits its 772 million users. It has spread deeply into rural regions, revitalizing education and creating jobs. There’s a long way to go to bring the internet to everyone in China — more than 600 million people remain offline . But wherever the internet is fueling prosperity, “we should endeavor to follow it with capital and with effort, driving both economic and societal impact all over the world. Just imagine for a minute what more could be possible if the global needs of the underserved become the primary focus of our inventions.”

Netflix and chill, the interview. The humble beginnings of Netflix paved the way to transforming how we consume content today. Reed Hastings — who started out as a high school math teacher — admits that making the shift from DVDs to streaming was a big leap. “We weren’t confident,” he admits in his interview with TED Curator Chris Anderson. “It was scary.” Obviously, it paid off over time, with 117 million subscribers (and growing), more than $11 billion in revenue (so far) and a slew of popular original content (Black Mirror, anyone?) fueled by curated algorithmic recommendations. The offerings of Netflix, Hastings says, is a mixture of candy and broccoli — and it allows people to decide what a proper “diet” is for them. “We get a lot of joy from making people happy,” he says. The external culture of the streaming platform reflects its internal culture as well: they’re super focused on how to run with no process, but without chaos. There’s an emphasis on freedom, responsibility and honesty (as he puts it, “disagreeing silently is disloyal”). And though Hastings loves business — competing against the likes of HBO and Disney — he also enjoys his philanthropic pursuits supporting innovative education, such as the KIPP charter schools, and advocates for more variety in educational content. For now, he says, it’s the perfect job.

“E. Pluribus Unum” — ”Out of many, one.” It’s the motto of the United States, yet few citizens understand its meaning. Artist and designer Walter Hood calls for national landscapes that preserve the distinct identities of peoples and cultures, while still forging unity. Hood believes spaces should illuminate shared memories without glossing over past — and present — injustices. To guide his projects, Hood follows five simple guidelines. The first — “Great things happen when we exist in each other’s world” — helped fire up a Queens community garden initiative in collaboration with Bette Midler and hip-hop legend 50 Cent. “Two-ness” — or the sense of double identity faced by those who are “othered,” like women and African-Americans — lies behind a “shadow sculpture” at the University of Virginia that commemorates a forgotten, buried servant household uncovered during the school’s expansion. “Empathy” inspired the construction of a park in downtown Oakland that serves office workers and the homeless community, side-by-side. “The traditional belongs to all of us” — and to the San Francisco neighborhood of Bayview-Hunter’s Point, where Hood restored a Victorian opera house to serve the local community. And “Memory” lies at the core of a future shorefront park in Charleston, which will rest on top of Gadsden Wharf — an entry point for 40% of the United States’ slaves, where they were then “stored” in chains — that forces visitors to confront the still-resonating cruelty of our past.

The tension between acceptance and hope. When Simone George met Mark Pollock, it was eight years after he’d lost his sight. Pollock was rebuilding his identity — living a high-octane life of running marathons and racing across Antarctica to reach the South Pole. But a year after he returned from Antarctica, Pollock fell from a third-story window; he woke up paralyzed from the waist down. Pollock shares how being a realist — inspired by the writings of Admiral James Stockdale, a Vietnam POW — helped him through bleak days after this accident, when even hope seemed dangerous. George explains how she helped Pollock navigate months in the hospital; told that any sensation Pollock didn’t regain in the weeks immediately after the fall would likely never come back, the two looked to stories of others, like Christopher Reeve, who had pushed beyond what was understood as possible for those who are paralyzed. “History is filled with the kinds of impossible made possible through human endeavor,” Pollock says. So he started asking: Why can’t human endeavor cure paralysis in his lifetime? In collaboration with a team of engineers in San Francisco, who created an exoskeleton for Pollock, as well as Dr. Reggie Edgerton’s team at UCLA, who had developed a way to electrically stimulate the spinal cord of those with paralysis, Pollock was able to pull his knee into his chest during a lab test, proving that progress is definitely still possible. For now, “I accept the wheelchair, it’s almost impossible not to,” says Pollock. “We also hope for another life — a life where we have created a cure through collaboration, a cure that we’re actively working to release from university labs around the world and share with everyone who needs it.”

The pursuit of joy, not happiness. “How do tangible things make us feel intangible joy?” asks designer Ingrid Fetell Lee. She pursued this question for ten years to understand how the physical world relates to the mysterious, quixotic emotion of joy. In turns out, the physical can be a remarkable, renewable resource for fostering a happier, healthier life. There isn’t just one type of joy, and its definition morphs from person to person — but psychologists, broadly speaking, describe joy as intense, momentary experience of positive emotion (or, simply, as something that makes you want to jump up and down). However, joy shouldn’t be conflated with happiness, which measure how good we feel over time. So, Lee asked around about what brings people joy and eventually had a notebook filled with things like beach balls, treehouses, fireworks, googly eyes and ice cream cones with rainbow sprinkles, and realized something significant: the patterns of joy have roots in evolutionary history. Things like symmetrical shapes, bright colors, an attraction to abundance and multiplicity, a feeling of lightness or elevation — this is what’s universally appealing. Joy lowers blood pressure, improves our immune system and even increases productivity. She began to wonder: should we use these aesthetics to help us find more opportunities for joy in the world around us? “Joy begins with the senses,” she says. “What we should be doing is embracing joy, and finding ways to put ourselves in the path of it more often.”

And that’s a wrap. Speaking of joy, Baratunde Thurston steps out to close this conference with a wrap that shouts out the diversity of this year’s audience but also nudges the un-diverse selection of topics: next year, he asks, instead of putting an African child on a slide, can we put her onstage to speak for herself? He winds together the themes of the week, from the terrifying — killer robots, octopus robots, genetically modified piglets — to the badass, the inspiring and the mind-opening. Are you not amazed?

Planet DebianOlivier Berger: Added docker container to my org-teaching framework to ease org-mode exports

I’ve improved a bit the org-teaching framework in order to prepare for the next edition of the CSC4101 classes.

I’ve now added a docker container which is in charge of performing the HTML or PDF exports of the slides (using org-reveal) or handbooks (using LaTeX).

Emacs and org-mode are still advised for editing contents, but having this container in the loop ensures that colleagues are able to preview the changes to the teaching material, and I’m no longer a bottleneck for generating the handouts. This also allows to export in a reproducible way, which doesn’t depend on my Emacs config tweaks.

I’ve also added Gitlab pages to the project’s CI so that the docs are updated live at

It’s probably not yet rady for use by anyone else, but I’d be glad to get feedback 😉

Worse Than FailureThe Big Balls of…

The dependency graph of your application can provide a lot of insight into how objects call each other. In a well designed application, this is probably mostly acyclic and no one node on the graph has more than a handful of edges coming off of it. The kinds of applications we talk about here, on the other hand, we have a name for their graphs: the Enterprise Dependency and the Big Ball of Yarn.

Thomas K introduces us to an entirely new iteration: The Big Ball of Mandelbrot

A dependency graph which exhibits self-similarity at different scales

This gives new meaning to points “on a complex plane”.

What you’re seeing here is the relationship between stored procedures and tables. Circa 1995, when this application shambled into something resembling life, the thinking was, “If we put all the business logic in stored procedures, it’ll be easy to slap new GUIs on there as technology changes!”

Of course, the relationship between what the user sees on the screen and the underlying logic which drives that display means that as they changed the GUI, they also needed to change the database. Over the course of 15 years, the single cohesive data model ubercomplexificaticfied itself as each customer needed a unique GUI with a unique feature set which mandated unique tables and stored procedures.

By the time Thomas came along to start a pseudo-greenfield GUI in ASP.Net, the first and simplest feature he needed to implement involved calling a 3,000 line stored procedure which required over 100 parameters.

[Advertisement] Otter - Provision your servers automatically without ever needing to log-in to a command prompt. Get started today!

Planet DebianReproducible builds folks: Reproducible Builds: Weekly report #156

Here’s what happened in the Reproducible Builds effort between Sunday April 15 and Saturday April 21 2018:

  • Holger Levsen announced preliminary result of our poll for our logo which was subsequently verified by Chris Lamb. The winner was “#6”, shown above.

  • Chris Lamb will present at foss-north 2018 on Monday April 23rd in Gothenburg, Sweden to speak about diffoscope, our in-depth “diff-on-steroids” to analyse reproducible issues in packages. He will then be keynoting at FLOSSUK 2018 in Edinburgh, Scotland on April 26th to speak about reproducible builds more generally.

  • Jan Bundesmann, Reiner Herrmann and Holger Levsen wrote an article about Reproducible Builds titled Aus der Schablone (“From the template”) for the May issue of the German “iX” magazine.

  • Holger Levsen began a discussion with the Debian System Administrators regarding redirecting this blog in the future away from the (deprecated) Alioth service. Chris Lamb subsequently started on the migration work.

Packages reviewed and fixed, and bugs filed

In addition, Chris Lamb’s patch to the Freeland VPN client was merged upstream and build failure bugs were reported by Adrian Bunk (48), Paul Gevers (5) and Rafael Laboissière (1). development

A large number of changes were made to our Jenkins-based testing framework, including:

Reviews of unreproducible packages

43 package reviews have been added, 49 have been updated and 97 have been removed in this week, adding to our knowledge about identified issues.

One new issue was added by Chris Lamb: build_path_in_index_files_generated_by_qdoc. In addition, three issue types were removed (random_ispell_hash_files, randomness_in_python_setuptools_pkg_info & timestamps_in_documentation_generated_by_asciidoctora) and one was updated (timestamp_in_pear_registry_files).


This week’s edition was written by Bernhard M. Wiedemann, Chris Lamb, Holger Levsen & reviewed by a bunch of Reproducible Builds folks on IRC & the mailing lists.

Planet DebianHolger Levsen: 20180423-technohippieparadise

Trouble in techno hippie paradise

So I'm in some 'jungle' in Brasil, enjoying a good time with some friends which another friend jokingly labeled as cryptohippies, enjoying the silence, nature, good food, some cats & dogs and 3g internet. Life is good here.

And then we decided to watch "Stare into the lights my pretties" and while it is a very good and insightful movie, it's also disturbing to see just how much we, as human societies, have changed ourselves mindlessly (or rather, out of our own minds) in very recent history.

Even though not a smartphone user myself and while seemingly aware and critical of many changes happening in the last two decades, the movie was still eyeopening to me. Now if there only werent 100 distractions per day I would maybe be able to build up on this. Or maybe I need to watch it every week, though this wouldn't work neither, as the movie explains so well...

The movie also reminded me why I dislike being cc:ed on email so much (unless urgent and when I'm subscribed to the list being posted to). Because usually during the day I (try to) ignore list mails, but I do check my personal inboxes. And if someone cc:s me, this breaks my lines of thoughts. So it seems I still need to get better at ignoring stuff, even if something is pushed to me. Maybe especially then. (And hints for good .procmail rules for this much appreciated.)

Another interesting point: while the number of people addicted to nicotine has been going down globally lately, the number of network addicts has outnumbered those by far now. And yet the long term effects of being online almost 24/365 have not yet been researched at all. The cigarette companies claimed that most doctors smoke. The IT industry claims it's normal to be online. What's your wakeup2smartphone time? Do you check email every day?

This movie also made me wonder what Debian's role will, can and should be in this future. (And where of course I don't only mean Debian, but free software, free societies, in general.)

So, this movie brings up many questions. (And nicely explains why people rather don't like that.) So go watch this movie! You will be touched, think and check your email/smartphone afterwards.

(And finally, of course it's ironic that the movie is on youtube. And so I learned that to download subtitles you need to tell youtube-dl so, and it's easiest by using --all-subs. And btw, youtube-dl-gui needs help with running with python3 and thus with getting into Debian.)


Planet DebianBenjamin Mako Hill: Is English Wikipedia’s ‘rise and decline’ typical?

This graph shows the number of people contributing to Wikipedia over time:

The Rise and Decline of Wikipedia The number of active Wikipedia contributors exploded, suddenly stalled, and then began gradually declining. (Figure taken from Halfaker et al. 2013)

The figure comes from “The Rise and Decline of an Open Collaboration System,” a well-known 2013 paper that argued that Wikipedia’s transition from rapid growth to slow decline in 2007 was driven by an increase in quality control systems. Although many people have treated the paper’s finding as representative of broader patterns in online communities, Wikipedia is a very unusual community in many respects. Do other online communities follow Wikipedia’s pattern of rise and decline? Does increased use of quality control systems coincide with community decline elsewhere?

In a paper that my student Nathan TeBlunthuis is presenting Thursday morning at the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI),  a group of us have replicated and extended the 2013 paper’s analysis in 769 other large wikis. We find that the dynamics observed in Wikipedia are a strikingly good description of the average Wikia wiki. They appear to reoccur again and again in many communities.

The original “Rise and Decline” paper (we’ll abbreviate it “RAD”) was written by Aaron Halfaker, R. Stuart Geiger, Jonathan T. Morgan, and John Riedl. They analyzed data from English Wikipedia and found that Wikipedia’s transition from rise to decline was accompanied by increasing rates of newcomer rejection as well as the growth of bots and algorithmic quality control tools. They also showed that newcomers whose contributions were rejected were less likely to continue editing and that community policies and norms became more difficult to change over time, especially for newer editors.

Our paper, just published in the CHI 2018 proceedings, replicates most of RAD’s analysis on a dataset of 769 of the  largest wikis from Wikia that were active between 2002 to 2010.  We find that RAD’s findings generalize to this large and diverse sample of communities.

We can walk you through some of the key findings. First, the growth trajectory of the average wiki in our sample is similar to that of English Wikipedia. As shown in the figure below, an initial period of growth stabilizes and leads to decline several years later.

Rise and Decline on Wikia The average Wikia wikia also experience a period of growth followed by stabilization and decline (from TeBlunthuis, Shaw, and Hill 2018).

We also found that newcomers on Wikia wikis were reverted more and continued editing less. As on Wikipedia, the two processes were related. Similar to RAD, we also found that newer editors were more likely to have their contributions to the “project namespace” (where policy pages are located) undone as wikis got older. Indeed, the specific estimates from our statistical models are very similar to RAD’s for most of these findings!

There were some parts of the RAD analysis that we couldn’t reproduce in our context. For example, there are not enough bots or algorithmic editing tools in Wikia to support statistical claims about their effects on newcomers.

At the same time, we were able to do some things that the RAD authors could not.  Most importantly, our findings discount some Wikipedia-specific explanations for a rise and decline. For example, English Wikipedia’s decline coincided with the rise of Facebook, smartphones, and other social media platforms. In theory, any of these factors could have caused the decline. Because the wikis in our sample experienced rises and declines at similar points in their life-cycle but at different points in time, the rise and decline findings we report seem unlikely to be caused by underlying temporal trends.

The big communities we study seem to have consistent “life cycles” where stabilization and/or decay follows an initial period of growth. The fact that the same kinds of patterns happen on English Wikipedia and other online groups implies a more general set of social dynamics at work that we do not think existing research (including ours) explains in a satisfying way. What drives the rise and decline of communities more generally? Our findings make it clear that this is a big, important question that deserves more attention.

We hope you’ll read the paper and get in touch by commenting on this post or emailing Nate if you’d like to learn or talk more. The paper is available online and has been published under an open access license. If you really want to get into the weeds of the analysis, we will soon publish all the data and code necessary to reproduce our work in a repository on the Harvard Dataverse.

Nate TeBlunthuis will be presenting the project this week at CHI in Montréal on Thursday April 26 at 9am in room 517D.  For those of you not familiar with CHI, it is the top venue for Human-Computer Interaction. All CHI submissions go through double-blind peer review and the papers that make it into the proceedings are considered published (same as journal articles in most other scientific fields). Please feel free to cite our paper and send it around to your friends!

This blog post, and the open access paper that it describes, is a collaborative project with Aaron Shaw, that was led by Nate TeBlunthuis. A version of this blog post was originally posted on the Community Data Science Collective blog. Financial support came from the US National Science Foundation (grants IIS-1617129,  IIS-1617468, and GRFP-2016220885 ), Northwestern University, the Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences at Stanford University, and the University of Washington. This project was completed using the Hyak high performance computing cluster at the University of Washington.

Krebs on SecurityTranscription Service Leaked Medical Records

MEDantex, a Kansas-based company that provides medical transcription services for hospitals, clinics and private physicians, took down its customer Web portal last week after being notified by KrebsOnSecurity that it was leaking sensitive patient medical records — apparently for thousands of physicians.

On Friday, KrebsOnSecurity learned that the portion of MEDantex’s site which was supposed to be a password-protected portal physicians could use to upload audio-recorded notes about their patients was instead completely open to the Internet.

What’s more, numerous online tools intended for use by MEDantex employees were exposed to anyone with a Web browser, including pages that allowed visitors to add or delete users, and to search for patient records by physician or patient name. No authentication was required to access any of these pages.

This exposed administrative page from MEDantex’s site granted anyone complete access to physician files, as well as the ability to add and delete authorized users.

Several MEDantex portal pages left exposed to the Web suggest that the company recently was the victim of WhiteRose, a strain of ransomware that encrypts a victim’s files unless and until a ransom demand is paid — usually in the form of some virtual currency such as bitcoin.

Contacted by KrebsOnSecurity, MEDantex founder and chief executive Sreeram Pydah confirmed that the Wichita, Kansas based transcription firm recently rebuilt its online servers after suffering a ransomware infestation. Pydah said the MEDantex portal was taken down for nearly two weeks, and that it appears the glitch exposing patient records to the Web was somehow incorporated into that rebuild.

“There was some ransomware injection [into the site], and we rebuilt it,” Pydah said, just minutes before disabling the portal (which remains down as of this publication). “I don’t know how they left the documents in the open like that. We’re going to take the site down and try to figure out how this happened.”

It’s unclear exactly how many patient records were left exposed on MEDantex’s site. But one of the main exposed directories was named “/documents/userdoc,” and it included more than 2,300 physicians listed alphabetically by first initial and last name. Drilling down into each of these directories revealed a varying number of patient records — displayed and downloadable as Microsoft Word documents and/or raw audio files.

Although many of the exposed documents appear to be quite recent, some of the records dated as far back as 2007. It’s also unclear how long the data was accessible, but this Google cache of the MEDantex physician portal seems to indicate it was wide open on April 10, 2018.

Among the clients listed on MEDantex’s site include New York University Medical Center; San Francisco Multi-Specialty Medical Group; Jackson Hospital in Montgomery Ala.; Allen County Hospital in Iola, Kan; Green Clinic Surgical Hospital in Ruston, La.; Trillium Specialty Hospital in Mesa and Sun City, Ariz.; Cooper University Hospital in Camden, N.J.; Sunrise Medical Group in Miami; the Wichita Clinic in Wichita, Kan.; the Kansas Spine Center; the Kansas Orthopedic Center; and Foundation Surgical Hospitals nationwide. MEDantex’s site states these are just some of the healthcare organizations partnering with the company for transcription services.

Unfortunately, the incident at MEDantex is far from an anomaly. A study of data breaches released this month by Verizon Enterprise found that nearly a quarter of all breaches documented by the company in 2017 involved healthcare organizations.

Verizon says ransomware attacks account for 85 percent of all malware in healthcare breaches last year, and that healthcare is the only industry in which the threat from the inside is greater than that from outside.

“Human error is a major contributor to those stats,” the report concluded.

Source: Verizon Business 2018 Data Breach Investigations Report.

According to a story at BleepingComputer, a security news and help forum that specializes in covering ransomware outbreaks, WhiteRose was first spotted about a month ago. BleepingComputer founder Lawrence Abrams says it’s not clear how this ransomware is being distributed, but that reports indicate it is being manually installed by hacking into Remote Desktop services.

Fortunately for WhiteRose victims, this particular strain of ransomware is decryptable without the need to pay the ransom.

“The good news is this ransomware appears to be decryptable by Michael Gillespie,” Abrams wrote. “So if you become infected with WhiteRose, do not pay the ransom, and instead post a request for help in our WhiteRose Support & Help topic.”

Ransomware victims may also be able to find assistance in unlocking data without paying from

KrebsOnSecurity would like to thank India-based cybersecurity startup Banbreach for the heads up about this incident.

Google AdsenseLet’s talk about Policy! Partnership with Industry Associations, and Better Ads Standards

Thanks to your feedback around wanting more discussion of AdSense policies, we have created some new content on our AdSense YouTube channel in a series called “Let’s talk about Policy!”.

This month, we're talking about the Coalition for Better Ads, Better Ads Standards.

These standards were created by the Coalition for Better Ads to improve ad experiences for users across the web. Google is a member of the Coalition alongside other stakeholders within the industry. The Better Ads Standards were created with extensive consumer research to minimize annoying ad experiences across devices. The Standards are currently in place for users within North America and Europe, but we are advising all our publishers to abide by the standards to provide a quality user experience for your visitors and minimize the need to make changes in the future.

Check out our video discussing the Standards to learn more:

Be sure to subscribe to the channel to ensure you don’t miss an episode.

CryptogramRussia is Banning Telegram

Russia has banned the secure messaging app Telegram. It's making an absolute mess of the ban -- blocking 16 million IP addresses, many belonging to the Amazon and Google clouds -- and it's not even clear that it's working. But, more importantly, I'm not convinced Telegram is secure in the first place.

Such a weird story. If you want secure messaging, use Signal. If you're concerned that having Signal on your phone will itself arouse suspicion, use WhatsApp.

CryptogramYet Another Biometric: Ear Shape

This acoustic technology identifies individuals by their ear shapes. No information about either false positives or false negatives.

Worse Than FailureRepresentative Line: The Truth About Comparisons

We often point to dates as one of the example data types which is so complicated that most developers can’t understand them. This is unfair, as pretty much every data type has weird quirks and edge cases which make for unexpected behaviors. Floating point rounding, integer overflows and underflows, various types of string representation…

But file-not-founds excepted, people have to understand Booleans, right?

Of course not. We’ve all seen code like:

if (booleanFunction() == true) …


if (booleanValue == true) {
    return true;
} else {
    return false;

Someone doesn’t understand what booleans are for, or perhaps what the return statement is for. But Paul T sends us a representative line which constitutes a new twist on an old chestnut.

if ( Boolean.TRUE.equals(functionReturningBooleat(pa, isUpdateNetRevenue)) ) …

This is the second most Peak Java Way to test if a value is true. The Peak Java version, of course, would be to use an AbstractComparatorFactoryFactory<Boolean> to construct a Comparator instance with an injected EqualityComparison object. But this is pretty close- take the Boolean.TRUE constant, use the inherited equals method on all objects, which means transparently boxing the boolean returned from the function into an object type, and then executing the comparison.

The if (boolean == true) return true; pattern is my personal nails-on-the-chalkboard code block. It’s not awful, it just makes me cringe. Paul’s submission is like an angle-grinder on a chalkboard.

[Advertisement] Continuously monitor your servers for configuration changes, and report when there's configuration drift. Get started with Otter today!

Planet DebianVincent Bernat: A more privacy-friendly blog

When I started this blog, I embraced some free services, like Disqus or Google Analytics. These services are quite invasive for users’ privacy. Over the years, I have tried to correct this to reach a point where I do not rely on any “privacy-hostile” services.


Google Analytics is an ubiquitous solution to get a powerful analytics solution for free. It’s also a great way to provide data about your visitors to Google—also for free. There are self-hosted solutions like Matomo—previously Piwik.

I opted for a simpler solution: no analytics. It also enables me to think that my blog attracts thousands of visitors every day.


Google Fonts is a very popular font library and hosting service, which relies on the generic Google Privacy Policy. The google-webfonts-helper service makes it easy to self-host any font from Google Fonts. Moreover, with help from pyftsubset, I include only the characters used in this blog. The font files are lighter and more complete: no problem spelling “Antonín Dvořák”.


  • Before: YouTube
  • After: self-hosted

Some articles are supported by a video (like “OPL2LPT: an AdLib sound card for the parallel port“). In the past, I was using YouTube, mostly because it was the only free platform with an option to disable ads. Streaming on-demand videos is usually deemed quite difficult. For example, if you just use the <video> tag, you may push a too big video for people with a slow connection. However, it is not that hard, thanks to hls.js, which enables to deliver video sliced in segments available at different bitrates. Users with Java­Script disabled are still delivered with a progressive version of medium quality.

In “Self-hosted videos with HLS”, I explain this approach in more details.


Disqus is a popular comment solution for static websites. They were recently acquired by Zeta Global, a marketing company and their business model is supported only by advertisements. On the technical side, Disqus also loads several hundred kilobytes of resources. Therefore, many websites load Disqus on demand. That’s what I did. This doesn’t solve the privacy problem and I had the sentiment people were less eager to leave a comment if they had to execute an additional action.

For some time, I thought about implementing my own comment system around Atom feeds. Each page would get its own feed of comments. A piece of Java­Script would turn these feeds into HTML and comments could still be read without Java­Script, thanks to the default rendering provided by browsers. People could also subscribe to these feeds: no need for mail notifications! The feeds would be served as static files and updated on new comments by a small piece of server-side code. Again, this could work without Javascript.

Day Planner by Fowl Language Comics
Fowl Language Comics: Day Planner or the real reason why I didn't code a new comment system.

I still think this is a great idea. But I didn’t feel like developing and maintaining a new comment system. There are several self-hosted alternatives, notably Isso and Commento. Isso is a bit more featureful, with notably an imperfect import from Disqus. Both are struggling with maintenance and are trying to become sustainable with a paid hosted version.1 Commento is more privacy-friendly as it doesn’t use cookies at all. However, cookies from Isso are not essential and can be filtered with nginx:

proxy_hide_header Set-Cookie;
proxy_hide_header X-Set-Cookie;
proxy_ignore_headers Set-Cookie;

In Isso, there is currently no mail notifications, but I have added an Atom feed for each comment thread.

Another option would have been to not provide comments anymore. However, I had some great contributions as comments in the past and I also think they can work as some kind of peer review for blog articles: they are a weak guarantee that the content is not totally wrong.

Search engine🔗

A way to provide a search engine for a personal blog is to provide a form for a public search engine, like Google. That’s what I did. I also slapped some Java­Script on top of that to make it look like not Google.

The solution here is easy: switch to DuckDuckGo, which lets you customize a bit the search experience:

<form id="lf-search" action="">
  <input type="hidden" name="kf" value="-1">
  <input type="hidden" name="kaf" value="1">
  <input type="hidden" name="k1" value="-1">
  <input type="hidden" name="sites" value="">
  <input type="submit" value="">
  <input type="text" name="q" value="" autocomplete="off" aria-label="Search">

The Java­Script part is also removed as DuckDuckGo doesn’t provide an API. As it is unlikely that more than three people will use the search engine in a year, this seems a good idea to not spend too much time on this non-essential feature.


  • Before: RSS feed
  • After: still RSS feed but also a MailChimp newsletter

Nowadays, RSS feeds are far less popular they were before. I am still baffled as why a technical audience wouldn’t use RSS, but some readers prefer to receive updates by mail.

MailChimp is a common solution to send newsletters. It provides a simple integration with RSS feeds to trigger a mail each time new items are added to the feed. From a privacy point of view, MailChimp seems a good citizen: data collection is mainly limited to the amount needed to operate the service. Privacy-conscious users can still avoid this service and use the RSS feed.

Less Java­Script🔗

  • Before: third-party Java­Script code
  • After: self-hosted Java­Script code

Many privacy-conscious people are disabling Java­Script or using extensions like uMatrix or NoScript. Except for comments, I was using Java­Script only for non-essential stuff:

For mathematical formulae, I have switched from MathJax to KaTeX. The later is faster but also enables server-side rendering: it produces the same output regardless of browser. Therefore, client-side Java­Script is not needed anymore.

For sidenotes, I have turned the Java­Script code doing the transformation into Python code, with pyquery. No more client-side Java­Script for this aspect either.

The remaining code is still here but is self-hosted.

Memento: CSP🔗

The HTTP Content-Security-Policy header controls the resources that a user agent is allowed to load for a given page. It is a safeguard and a memento for the external resources a site will use. Mine is moderately complex and shows what to expect from a privacy point of view:3

  default-src 'self' blob:;
  script-src  'self' blob:;
  object-src  'self';
  img-src     'self' data:;
  style-src   'self' 'unsafe-inline';
  font-src    'self' about: data:;
  worker-src  blob:;
  media-src   'self' blob:;
  connect-src 'self';
  frame-ancestors 'none';

I am quite happy having been able to reach this result. 😊

  1. For Isso, look at For Commento, look at↩︎

  2. You may have noticed I am a footnote sicko and use them all the time for pointless stuff. ↩︎

  3. I don’t have issue with using a CDN like CloudFront: it is a paid service and Amazon AWS is not in the business of tracking users. ↩︎

Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: pyconau 2018 call for proposals now open


The pyconau call for proposals is now open, and runs until 28 May. I took my teenagers to pyconau last year and they greatly enjoyed it. I hadn’t been to a pyconau in ages, and ended up really enjoying thinking about things from topic areas I don’t normally need to think about. I think expanding one’s horizons is generally a good idea.

Should I propose something for this year? I am unsure. Some random ideas that immediately spring to mind:

  • something about privsep: I think a generalised way to make privileged calls in unprivileged code is quite interesting, especially in a language which is often used for systems management and integration tasks. That said, perhaps its too OpenStacky given how disinterested in OpenStack talks most python people seem to be.
  • nova-warts: for a long time my hobby has been cleaning up historical mistakes made in OpenStack Nova that wont ever rate as a major feature change. What lessons can other projects learn from a well funded and heavily staffed project that still thought that exec() was a great way to do important work? There’s definitely an overlap with the privsep talk above, but this would be more general.
  • a talk about how I had to manage some code which only worked in python2, and some other code that only worked in python3 and in the end gave up on venvs and decided that Docker containers are like the ultimate venvs. That said, I suspect this is old hat and was obvious to everyone except me.
  • something else I haven’t though of.

Anyways, I’m undecided. Comments welcome.

Also, here’s an image for this post. Its the stone henge we found at Guerilla Bay last weekend. I assume its in frequent use for tiny tiny druids.



Harald Welteosmo-fl2k - Using USB-VGA dongles as SDR transmitter

Yesterday, during OsmoDevCon 2018, Steve Markgraf released osmo-fl2k, a new Osmocom member project which enables the use of FL2000 USB-VGA adapters as ultra-low-cost SDR transmitters.

How does it work?

A major part of any VGA card has always been a rather fast DAC which generates the 8-bit analog values for (each) red, green and blue at the pixel clock. Given that fast DACs were very rare/expensive (and still are to some extent), the idea of (ab)using the VGA DAC to transmit radio has been followed by many earlier, mostly proof-of-concept projects, such as Tempest for Eliza in 2001.

However, with osmo-fl2k, for the first time it was possible to completely disable the horizontal and vertical blanking, resulting in a continuous stream of pixels (samples). Furthermore, as the supported devices have no frame buffer memory, the samples are streamed directly from host RAM.

As most USB-VGA adapters appear to have no low-pass filters on their DAC outputs, it is possible to use any of the harmonics to transmit signals at much higher frequencies than normally possible within the baseband of the (max) 157 Mega-Samples per seconds that can be achieved.

osmo-fl2k and rtl-sdr

Steve is the creator of the earlier, complementary rtl-sdr software, which since 2012 transforms USB DVB adapters into general-purpose SDR receivers.

Today, six years later, it is hard to think of where SDR would be without rtl-sdr. Reducing the entry cost of SDR receivers nearly down to zero has done a lot for democratization of SDR technology.

There is hence a big chance that his osmo-fl2k project will attain a similar popularity. Having a SDR transmitter for as little as USD 5 is an amazing proposition.

free riders

Please keep in mind that Steve has done rtl-sdr just for fun, to scratch his own itch and for the "hack value". He chose to share his work with the wider public, in source code, under a free software license. He's a very humble person, he doesn't need to stand in the limelight.

Many other people since have built a business around rtl-sdr. They have grabbed domains with his project name, etc. They are now earning money based on what he has done and shared selflessly, without ever contributing back to the pioneering developers who brought this to all of us in the first place.

So, do we want to bet if history repeats itself? How long will it take for vendors showing up online advertising the USB VGA dongles as "SDR transmitter", possibly even with a surcharge? How long will it take for them to include Steve's software without giving proper attribution? How long until they will violate the GNU GPL by not providing the complete corresponding source code to derivative versions they create?

If you want to thank Steve for his amazing work

  • reach out to him personally
  • contribute to his work, e.g.
  • help to maintain it
  • package it for distributions
  • send patches (via osmocom-sdr mailing list)
  • register an account and update the wiki with more information

And last, but not least, carry on the spirit of "hack value" and democratization of software defined radio.

Thank you, Steve! After rtl-sdr and osmo-fl2k, it's hard to guess what will come next :)

Planet DebianJoachim Breitner: Verifying local definitions in Coq

TL;DR: We can give top-level names to local definitions, so that we can state and prove stuff about them without having to rewrite the programs.

When a Haskeller writes Coq

Imagine you teach Coq to a Haskell programmer, and give them the task of pairing each element in a list with its index. The Haskell programmer might have

addIndex :: [a] -> [(Integer, a)]
addIndex xs = go 0 xs
  where go n [] = []
        go n (x:xs) = (n,x) : go (n+1) xs

in mind and write this Gallina function (Gallina is the programming language of Coq):

Require Import Coq.Lists.List.
Import ListNotations.

Definition addIndex {a} (xs : list a) : list (nat * a) :=
  let fix go n xs := match xs with
                     | []    => []
                     | x::xs => (n, x) :: go (S n) xs
  in go 0 xs.

Alternatively, imagine you are using hs-to-coq to mechanically convert the Haskell definition into Coq.

When a Coq user tries to verify that

Now your task is to prove something about this function, for example

Theorem addIndex_spec:
  forall {a} n (xs : list a),
  nth n (map fst (addIndex xs)) n = n.

If you just have learned Coq, you will think “I can do this, this surely holds by induction on xs.” But if you have a bit more experience, you will already see a problem with this (if you do not see the problem yet, I encourage you to stop reading, copy the few lines above, and try to prove it).

The problem is that – as so often – you have to generalize the statement for the induction to go through. The theorem as stated says something about addIndex or, in other words, about go 0. But in the inductive case, you will need some information about go 1. In fact, you need a lemma like this:

Lemma go_spec:
  forall {a} n m k (xs : list a), k = n + m ->
  nth n (map fst (go m xs)) k = k.

But go is not a (top-level) function! How can we fix that?

  • We can try to awkwardly work-around not having a name for go in our proofs, and essentially prove go_spec inside the proof of addIndex_spec. Might work in this small case, but does not scale up to larger proofs.
  • We can ask the programmer to avoid using local functions, and first define go as a top-level fixed point. But maybe we don’t want to bother them because of that. (Or, more likely, we are using hs-to-coq and that tool stubbornly tries to make the output as similar to the given Haskell code as possible.)
  • We can copy’n’paste the definition of go and make a separate, after-the-fact top-level definition. But this is not nice from a maintenance point of view: If the code changes, we have to update this copy.
  • Or we apply this one weird trick...

The weird trick

We can define go after-the-fact, but instead of copy’n’pasting the definition, we can use Coq’s tactics to define it. Here it goes:

Definition go {a} := ltac:(
  let e := eval cbv beta delta [addIndex] in (@addIndex a []) in
  (* idtac e; *)
  lazymatch e with | let x := ?def in _ =>
    exact def

Let us take it apart:

  1. We define go, and give the parameters that go depends upon. Note that of the two parameters of addIndex, the definition of go only depends on (“captures”) a, but not xs.
  2. We do not give a type to go. We could, but that would again just be copying information that is already there.
  3. We define go via an ltac expression: Instead of a term we give a tactic that calculates the term.
  4. This tactic first binds e to the body of addIndex. To do so, it needs to pass enough arguments to addIndex. The concrete value of the list argument does not matter, so we pass []. The term @addIndex a [] is now evaluated with the evaluation flags eval cbv beta delta [addIndex], which says “unfold addIndex and do beta reduction, but nothing else”. In particularly, we do not do zeta reduction, which would reduce the let go := … definition. (The user manual very briefly describes these flags.)
  5. The idtac e line can be used to peek at e, for example when the next tactic fails. We can use this to check that e really is of the form let fix go := … in ….
  6. The lazymatch line matches e against the pattern let x := ?def in _, and binds the definition of go to the name def.
  7. And the exact def tactic tells Coq to use def as the definition of go.

We now have defined go, of type go : forall {a}, nat -> list a -> list (nat * a), and can state and prove the auxiliary lemma:

Lemma go_spec:
  forall {a} n m k (xs : list a), k = n + m ->
  nth n (map fst (go m xs)) k = k.
  intros ?????.
  revert n m k.
  induction xs; intros; destruct n; subst; simpl.
  apply IHxs; lia.

When we come to the theorem about addIndex, we can play a little trick with fold to make the proof goal pretty:

Theorem addIndex_spec:
  forall {a} n (xs : list a),
  nth n (map fst (addIndex xs)) n = n.
  unfold addIndex.
  fold (@go a).
  (* goal here: nth n (map fst (go 0 xs)) n = n *)
  apply go_spec; lia.

Multiple local definitions

The trick extends to multiple local definitions, but needs some extra considerations to ensure that terms are closed. A bit contrived, but let us assume that we have this function definition:

Definition addIndex' {a} (xs : list a) : list (nat * a) :=
  let inc := length xs in
  let fix go n xs := match xs with
                     | []    => []
                     | x::xs => (n, x) :: go (inc + n) xs
                     end in
  go 0 xs.

We now want to give names to inc and to go. I like to use a section to collect the common parameters, but that is not essential here. The trick above works flawlessly for `inc':

Section addIndex'.
Context {a} (xs : list a).

Definition inc := ltac:(
  let e := eval cbv beta delta [addIndex'] in (@addIndex' a xs) in
  lazymatch e with | let x := ?def in _ =>
    exact def

But if we try it for go', like such:

Definition go' := ltac:(
  let e := eval cbv beta delta [addIndex'] in (@addIndex' a xs) in
  lazymatch e with | let x := _ in let y := ?def in _ =>
    exact def

we get “Ltac variable def depends on pattern variable name x which is not bound in current context”. To fix this, we use higher-order pattern matchin (@?def) to substitute “our” inc for the local inc:

Definition go' := ltac:(
  let e := eval cbv beta delta [addIndex'] in (@addIndex' a xs) in
  lazymatch e with | let x := _ in let y := @?def x in _ =>
    let def' := eval cbv beta in (def inc) in
    exact def'

instead. We have now defined both inc and go' and can use them in proofs about addIndex':

Theorem addIndex_spec':
  forall n, nth n (map fst (addIndex' xs)) n = n * length xs.
  unfold addIndex'.
  fold inc go'. (* order matters! *)
  (* goal here: nth n (map fst (go' 0 xs)) n = n * inc *)

Reaching into a match

This trick also works when the local definition we care about is inside a match statement. Consider:

Definition addIndex_weird {a} (oxs : option (list a))
  := match oxs with
     | None => []
     | Some xs =>
       let fix go n xs := match xs with
                          | []    => []
                          | x::xs => (n, x) :: go (S n) xs
                          end in
       go 0 xs

Definition go_weird {a} := ltac:(
  let e := eval cbv beta match delta [addIndex_weird]
           in (@addIndex_weird a (Some [])) in
  idtac e;
  lazymatch e with | let x := ?def in _ =>
    exact def

Note the addition of match to the list of evaluation flags passed to cbv.


While local definitions are idiomatic in Haskell (in particular thanks to the where syntax), they are usually avoided in Coq, because they get in the way of verification. If, for some reason, one is stuck with such definitions, then this trick presents a reasonable way out.

Planet DebianSam Hartman: Shaving the DJ Software Yak

I'm getting married this June. (For the Debian folks, the Ghillie shirt and vest just arrived to go with the kilt. My thanks go out to the lunch table at Debconf that made that suggestion. formal Scottish dress would not have fit, but I wanted something to go with the kilt.)
Music and dance have been an important part of my spiritual journey. Dance has also been an import part of the best weddings I attended. So I wanted dance to be a special part of our celebration. I put together a play list for my 40th birthday; it was special and helped set the mood for the event. Unfortunately, as I started looking at what I wanted to play for the wedding, I realized I needed to do better. Some of the songs were too long. Some of them really felt like they needed a transition. I wanted a continuous mix not a play list.
I'm blind. I certainly could use two turn tables and a mixer--or at least I could learn how to do so. However, I'm a kid of the electronic generation, and that's not my style. So, I started looking at DJ software. With one exception, everything I found was too visual for me to use.
I've used Nama before to put together a mashup. It seemed like Nama offered almost everything I needed. Unfortunately, there were a couple of problems. Nama would not be a great fit for a live mix: you cannot add tracks or effects into the chain without restarting the engine. I didn't strictly need live production for this project, but I wanted to look at that long-term. At the time of my analysis, I thought that Nama didn't support tempo-scaling tracks. For that reason, I decided I was going to have to write my own software. Later I learned that you can adjust the sample rate on a track import, which is more or less good enough for tempo scaling. By that point I already had working code.
I wanted a command line interface. I wanted BPM and key detection; it looked like Mixxx was open-source software with good support for that. Based on my previous work, I chose Csound as the realtime sound backend.

Where I got

I'm proud of what I came up with. I managed to stay focused on my art rather than falling into the trap of focusing too much on the software. I got something that allows me to quickly explore the music I want to mix, but also managed to accomplish my goal and come up with a mix that I'm really happy with. As a result, at the current time, my software is probably only useful to me. However, it is available under the GPL V3. If anyone else would be interested in hacking on it, I'd be happy to spend some time documenting and working with them.
Here's a basic description of the approach.

  • You are editing a timeline that stores the transformations necessary to turn the input tracks into the output mix.
  • There are 10 mixer stereo channels that will be mixed down into a master output.
  • there are a unlimited number of input tracks. Each track is associated with a given mixer channel. Tracks are placed on the timeline at a given start point (starting from a given cue point in the track) and run for a given length. During this time, the track is mixed into the mixer channel. Associated with each track is a gain (volume) that controls how the track is mixed into the mixer channel. Volumes are constant per track.
  • Between the mixer channel and the master is a volume fader and an effect chain.
  • Effects are written in Csound code. Being able to easily write Csound effects is one of the things that made me more interested in writing my own than in looking at adding better tempo scaling/BPM detection to Nama.
  • Associated with each effect are three sliders that give inputs to the effect. Changing the number of mixer channels and effect sliders is an easy code change. However it'd be somewhat tricky to be able to change that dynamically during a performance. Effects also get an arbitrary number of constant parameters.
  • Sliders and volume faders can be manipulated on the timeline. You can ask for a linear change from the current value to a target over a given duration starting at some point. So I can ask for the amplitude to move from 0 to 127 at the point where I want to mix in a track say across 2 seconds. You express slider manipulation in terms of the global timeline. However it is stored relative to the start of the track. That is, if you have a track fade out at a particular musical phrase, the fade out will stay with that phrase even if you move the cue point of the track or move where the track starts on the timeline. This is not what you want all the time, but my experience with Nama (which does it using global time) suggests that I at least save a lot of time with this approach.
  • There is a global effect chain between the output of the final mixer and the master output. This allows you to apply distortion, equalization or compression to the mix as a whole. The sliders for effects on this effect chain are against global time not a specific track.
  • There's a hard-coded compressor on the final output. I'm lazy and I needed it before I had effect chains.

There's some preliminary support for a MIDI controller I was given, but I realized that coding that wasn't actually going to save me time, so I left it. This was a really fun project. I managed to tell a story for my wedding that is really important for me to tell. I learned a lot about what goes into putting together a mix. It's amazing how many decisions go into even simple things like a pan slider. It was also great that there is free software for me to build on top of. I got to focus on the part of the problem I wanted to solve. I was able to reuse components for the realtime sound work and for analysis like BPM detection.

Planet DebianWouter Verhelst: host detection in bash

There are many tools to implement this, and yeah, this is not the fastest. But the advantage is that you don't need extra tools beyond "bash" and "ping"...

for i in $(seq 1 254); do
  if ping -W 1 -c 1 192.168.0.$i; then
echo ${!HOST[@]}

will give you the host addresses for the machines that are live on a given network...

Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: Caliban’s War


This is the second book in the Leviathan Wakes series by James SA Corey. Just as good as the first, this is a story about how much a father loves his daughter, moral choices, and politics — just as much as it is the continuation of the story arc around the alien visitor. I haven’t seen this far in the Netflix series, but I sure hope they get this right, because its a very good story so far.

Caliban's War Book Cover Caliban's War
James S. A. Corey
Orbit Books
April 30, 2013

For someone who didn't intend to wreck the solar system's fragile balance of power, Jim Holden did a pretty good job of it. While Earth and Mars have stopped shooting each other, the core alliance is shattered. The outer planets and the Belt are uncertain in their new - possibly temporary - autonomy. Then, on one of Jupiter's moons, a single super-soldier attacks, slaughtering soldiers of Earth and Mars indiscriminately and reigniting the war. The race is on to discover whether this is the vanguard of an alien army, or if the danger lies closer to home.


Planet DebianNorbert Preining: Specification and Verification of Software with CafeOBJ – Part 2 – Basics of CafeOBJ

This blog continues Part 1 of our series on software specification and verification with CafeOBJ.

Availability of CafeOBJ

CafeOBJ can be obtained from the website The site provides binary packages built from Linux, MacOS, and Windows, as well as the source code for those who want to build the interpreter themselves. Other services provided are tutorial pages, all kind of documentation (reference manual, wiki, user manual).

What is CafeOBJ

Let us recall some of the items mentioned in the previous blog. CafeOBJ is an algebraic specification language, as well as a verification and programming language. This means, that specifications written in CafeOBJ can be verified right within the system without the need to regress to external utilities.

As algebraic specification language it is built upon the logical foundation formed by the following items: (i) order sorted algebras, (ii) co-algebras (or hidden algebras), and (iii) rewriting logic. As verification and programming language it provides the user with an executable semantics of the equational theory, a rewrite engine that supports conditional, order-sorted, AC (associative and commutative) rewriting, a sofisticated module system including parametrization and inheritance, and last but not least a completely free syntax.

The algebraic semantics can be represented by the CafeOBJ cube exhibiting the various extensions starting more many sorted algebras:

For the algebraically inclined audience we just mention that all the systems and morphisms are formalized as institutions and institution morphisms.

Let us now go through some the the logical foundations of CafeOBJ:

Term rewriting

Term rewriting is concerned with systems of rules to replace certain parts of an expression with another expression. A very simple example of a rewrite system is:

  append(nil, ys)    → ys
  append(x : xs, ys) → x : append(xs, ys)

Here the first rule says that you can rewrite an expression append(nil, ys) where ys can be any list, with ys itself. And the second rule states how to rewrite an expression when the first element is not the empty list.

A typical reduction sequence – that is application of these rules – would be:

append(1 ∶ 2 ∶ 3 ∶ nil, 4 ∶ 5 ∶ nil) → 1 ∶ append(2 ∶ 3 ∶ nil, 4 ∶ 5 ∶ nil)
                                     → 1 ∶ 2 ∶ append(3 ∶ nil, 4 ∶ 5 ∶ nil)
                                     → 1 ∶ 2 ∶ 3 ∶ append(nil, 4 ∶ 5 ∶ nil)
                                     → 1 ∶ 2 ∶ 3 ∶ 4 ∶ 5 ∶ nil

Term rewriting is used in two different ways in CafeOBJ: First as execution engine that considers equations as directed rules and uses them to reduce expressions. And at the same time rewriting logic is included into the language specification allowing for reasoning about transitions.

Order sorted algebras

Most algebras we learn in school or even at the university are single sorted, that is all objects in the algebra are of the same type (e.g., integers, reals, function space). In this case an operation is determined by its arity, that is the number of arguments.

In the many sorted and order sorted case the simple number of arguments of a function is not enough, we need to know for each argument its type and also the type of the value the function returns. Thus, we assume a signature (S,F) given, such that S is a set of sorts, or simply sort names, and F is a set of operations f: s1, s2, ..., sk → s where all the s are sorts.

As an example assume we have two sorts, String and Int, one possible function would be

  substr: String, Int, Int → String

which would tell us that the function substr takes three arguments, the first of sort String, the others of sort Int, and it returns again a value of sort String.

In case the sorts are (partially ordered), we call the corresponding algebra order sorted algebra.

Using order sorted algebras has several advantages compared to other algebraic systems:

  • polymorphism (parametric, subsort) and overloading are natural consequences of ordered sorts;
  • error definition and handling via subsorts;
  • multiple inheritance;
  • rigorous model-theoretic semantics based on institutions;
  • operational semantics that executes equations as rewrite rules (executable specifications).

We want to close this blog post with a short history of CafeOBJ and a short sample list of specifications that have been carried out with CafeOBJ.

History, background, relatives, and examples

CafeOBJ, as an algebraic specification language based on equational theory, has its roots in CLEAR (Burgstall and Goguen, early 70s) and the OBJ language (Goguen et al, 70-80s SRI and UC San Diego). The successor OBJ2 was developed by Futatsugi, Goguen, Jouannaud, and Meseguer at UC San Diego in 1984, based on Horn logic, sub-sorts, and parametrized modules.

The developer then moved on to different languages or extensions: Meseguer started to develop Maude, Jouannaud moved on to develop Coq, an unrelated language, and Futatsugi built upon the OBJ3 language by Kirchner et al to create CafeOBJ.

Example specifications carried out in CafeOBJ are authentication protocols (NSLPK, STS, Otway-Rees), key secrecy PACE protocol (German passport), e-commerce protocols (SET), real time algorithms (Fischer’s mutual exclusion protocol), UML semantics, formal fault tree analysis.

In the next blog post we will make first steps with the CafeOBJ interpreter and see how to define modules, the basic building blocks, and carry out simple computations.


Planet DebianBenjamin Mako Hill: Mako Hate

I recently discovered a prolific and sustained community of meme-makers on Tumblr dedicated to expressing their strong dislike for “Mako.”

Two tags with examples are #mako hate and #anti mako but there are many others.

I’ve also discovered Tumblrs entirely dedicated to the topic!

For example, Let’s Roast Mako describes itself “A place to beat up Mako. In peace. It’s an inspiration to everyone!

The second is the Fuck Mako Blog which describes itself with series of tag-lines including “Mako can fuck right off and we’re really not sorry about that,” “Welcome aboard the SS Fuck-Mako;” and “Because Mako is unnecessary.” Sub-pages of the site include:

I’ll admit I’m a little disquieted.

Planet Linux AustraliaPia Waugh: Exploring change and how to scale it

Over the past decade I have been involved in several efforts trying to make governments better. A key challenge I repeatedly see is people trying to change things without an idea of what they are trying to change to, trying to fix individual problems (a deficit view) rather than recognising and fixing the systems that created the problems in the first place. So you end up getting a lot of symptomatic relief and iterative improvements of antiquated paradigms without necessarily getting transformation of the systems that generated the problems. A lot of the effort is put into applying traditional models of working which often result in the same old results, so we also need to consider new ways to work, not just what needs to be done.

With life getting faster and (arguably) exponentially more complicated, we need to take a whole of system view if we are to improve ‘the system’ for people. People sometimes balk when I say this thinking it too hard, too big or too embedded. But we made this, we can remake it, and if it isn’t working for us, we need to adapt like we always have.

I also see a lot of slogans used without the nuanced discussion they invite. Such (often ideological) assumptions can subtly play out without evidence, discussion or agreement on common purpose. For instance, whenever people say smaller or bigger government I try to ask what they think the role of government is, to have a discussion. Size is assumed to correlate to services, productivity, or waste depending on your view, but shouldn’t we talk about what the public service should do, and then the size is whatever is appropriate to do what is needed? People don’t talk about a bigger or smaller jacket or shoes, they get the right one for their needs and the size can change over time as the need changes. Indeed, perhaps the public service of the future could be a dramatically different workforce comprised of a smaller group of professional public servants complimented with and a large demographically representative group of part time citizens doing their self nominated and paid “civic duty year of service” as a form of participatory democracy, which would bring new skills and perspectives into governance, policy and programs.

We need urgently to think about the big picture, to collectively talk about the 50 or 100 year view for society, and only then can we confidently plan and transform the structures, roles, programs and approaches around us. This doesn’t mean we have to all agree to all things, but we do need to identify the common scaffolding upon which we can all build.

This blog posts challenges you to think systemically, critically and practically about five things:

    • What future do you want? Not what could be a bit better, or what the next few years might hold, or how that shiny new toy you have could solve the world’s problems (policy innovation, data, blockchain, genomics or any tool or method). What is the future you want to work towards, and what does good look like? Forget about your particular passion or area of interest for a moment. What does your better life look like for all people, not just people like you?
    • What do we need to get there? What concepts, cultural values, paradigm, assumptions should we take with us and what should we leave behind? What new tools do we need and how do we collectively design where we are going?
    • What is the role of gov, academia, other sectors and people in that future? If we could create a better collective understanding of our roles in society and some of the future ideals we are heading towards, then we would see a natural convergence of effort, goals and strategy across the community.
    • What will you do today? Seriously. Are you differentiating between symptomatic relief and causal factors? Are you perpetuating the status quo or challenging it? Are you being critically aware of your bias, of the system around you, of the people affected by your work? Are you reaching out to collaborate with others outside your team, outside your organisation and outside your comfort zone? Are you finding natural partners in what you are doing, and are you differentiating between activities worthy of collaboration versus activities only of value to you (the former being ripe for collaboration and the latter less so).
    • How do we scale change? I believe we need to consider how to best scale “innovation” and “transformation”. Scaling innovation is about scaling how we do things differently, such as the ability to take a more agile, experimental, evidence based, creative and collaborative approach to the design, delivery and continuous improvement of stuff, be it policy, legislation or services. Scaling transformation is about how we create systemic and structural change that naturally drives and motivates better societal outcomes. Each without the other is not sustainable or practical.

How to scale innovation and transformation?

I’ll focus the rest of this post on the question of scaling. I wrote this in the context of scaling innovation and transformation in government, but it applies to any large system. I also believe that empowering people is the greatest way to scale anything.

  • I’ll firstly say that openness is key to scaling everything. It is how we influence the system, how we inspire and enable people to individually engage with and take responsibility for better outcomes and innovate at a grassroots level. It is how we ensure our work is evidence based, better informed and better tested, through public peer review. Being open not only influences the entire public service, but the rest of the economy and society. It is how we build trust, improve collaboration, send indicators to vendors and influence academics. Working openly, open sourcing our research and code, being public about projects that would benefit from collaboration, and sharing most of what we do (because most of the work of the public service is not secretive by any stretch) is one of the greatest tools in try to scale our work, our influence and our impact. Openness is also the best way to ensure both a better supply chain as well as a better demand for things that are demonstrable better.

A quick side note to those who argue that transparency isn’t an answer because all people don’t have to tools to understand data/information/etc to hold others accountable, it doesn’t mean you don’t do transparency at all. There will always be groups or people naturally motivated to hold you to account, whether it is your competitors, clients, the media, citizens or even your own staff. Transparency is partly about accountability and partly about reinforcing a natural motivation to do the right thing.

Scaling innovation – some ideas:

  • The necessity of neutral, safe, well resourced and collaborative sandpits is critical for agencies to quickly test and experiment outside the limitations of their agencies (technical, structural, political, functional and procurement). Such places should be engaged with the sectors around them. Neutral spaces that take a systems view also start to normalise a systems view across agencies in their other work, which has huge ramifications for transformation as well as innovation.
  • Seeking and sharing – sharing knowledge, reusable systems/code, research, infrastructure and basically making it easier for people to build on the shoulders of each other rather than every single team starting from scratch every single time. We already have some communities of practice but we need to prioritise sharing things people can actually use and apply in their work. We also need to extend this approach across sectors to raise all boats. Imagine if there was a broad commons across all society to share and benefit from each others efforts. We’ve seen the success and benefits of Open Source Software, of Wikipedia, of the Data Commons project in New Zealand, and yet we keep building sector or organisational silos for things that could be public assets for public good.
  • Require user research in budget bids – this would require agencies to do user research before bidding for money, which would create an incentive to build things people actually need which would drive both a user centred approach to programs and would also drive innovation as necessary to shift from current practices :) Treasury would require user research experts and a user research hub to contrast and compare over time.
  • Staff mobility – people should be supported to move around departments and business units to get different experiences and to share and learn. Not everyone will want to, but when people stay in the same job for 20 years, it can be harder to engage in new thinking. Exchange programs are good but again, if the outcomes and lessons are not broadly shared, then they are linear in impact (individuals) rather than scalable (beyond the individuals).
  • Support operational leadership – not everyone wants to be a leader, disruptor, maker, innovator or intrapreneur. We need to have a program to support such people in the context of operational leadership that isn’t reliant upon their managers putting them forward or approving. Even just recognising leadership as something that doesn’t happen exclusively in senior management would be a huge cultural shift. Many managers will naturally want to keep great people to themselves which can become stifling and eventually we lose them. When people can work on meaningful great stuff, they stay in the public service.
  • A public ‘Innovation Hub’ – if we had a simple public platform for people to register projects that they want to collaborate on, from any sector, we could stimulate and support innovation across the public sector (things for which collaboration could help would be surfaced, publicly visible, and inviting of others to engage in) so it would support and encourage innovation across government, but also provides a good pipeline for investment as well as a way to stimulate and support real collaboration across sectors, which is substantially lacking at the moment.
  • Emerging tech and big vision guidance - we need a team, I suggest cross agency and cross sector, of operational people who keep their fingers on the pulse of technology to create ongoing guidance for New Zealand on emerging technologies, trends and ideas that anyone can draw from. For government, this would help agencies engage constructively with new opportunities rather than no one ever having time or motivation until emerging technologies come crashing down as urgent change programs. This could be captured on a constantly updating toolkit with distributed authorship to keep it real.

Scaling transformation – some ideas:

  • Convergence of effort across sectors – right now in many countries every organisation and to a lesser degree, many sectors, are diverging on their purpose and efforts because there is no shared vision to converge on. We have myriad strategies, papers, guidance, but no overarching vision. If there were an overarching vision for New Zealand Aotearoa for instance, co-developed with all sectors and the community, one that looks at what sort of society we want into the future and what role different entities have in achieving that ends, then we would have the possibility of natural convergence on effort and strategy.
    • Obviously when you have a cohesive vision, then you can align all your organisational and other strategies to that vision, so our (government) guidance and practices would need to align over time. For the public sector the Digital Service Standard would be a critical thing to get right, as is how we implement the Higher Living Standards Framework, both of which would drive some significant transformation in culture, behaviours, incentives and approaches across government.
  • Funding “Digital Public Infrastructure” – technology is currently funded as projects with start and end dates, and almost all tech projects across government are bespoke to particular agency requirements or motivations, so we build loads of technologies but very little infrastructure that others can rely upon. If we took all the models we have for funding other forms of public infrastructure (roads, health, education) and saw some types of digital infrastructure as public infrastructure, perhaps they could be built and funded in ways that are more beneficial to the entire economy (and society).
  • Agile budgeting – we need to fund small experiments that inform business cases, rather than starting with big business cases. Ideally we need to not have multi 100 million dollar projects at all because technology projects simply don’t cost that anymore, and anyone saying otherwise is trying to sell you something :) If we collectively took an agile budgeting process, it would create a systemic impact on motivations, on design and development, or implementation, on procurement, on myriad things. It would also put more responsibility on agencies for the outcomes of their work in short, sharp cycles, and would create the possibility of pivoting early to avoid throwing bad money after good (as it were). This is key, as no transformative project truly survives the current budgeting model.
  • Gov as a platform/API/enabler (closely related to DPI above) – obviously making all government data, content, business rules (inc but not just legislation) and transactional systems available as APIs for building upon across the economy is key. This is how we scale transformation across the public sector because agencies are naturally motivated to deliver what they need to cheaper, faster and better, so when there are genuinely useful reusable components, agencies will reuse them. Agencies are now more naturally motivated to take an API driven modular architecture which creates the bedrock for government as an API. Digital legislation (which is necessary for service delivery to be integrated across agency boundaries) would also create huge transformation in regulatory and compliance transformation, as well as for government automation and AI.
  • Exchange programs across sectors – to share knowledge but all done openly so as to not create perverse incentives or commercial capture. We need to also consider the fact that large companies can often afford to jump through hoops and provide spare capacity, but small to medium sized companies cannot, so we’d need a pool for funding exchange programs with experts in the large proportion of industry.
  • All of system service delivery evidence base – what you measure drives how you behave. Agencies are motivated to do only what they need to within their mandates and have very few all of system motivations. If we have an all of government anonymised evidence base of user research, service analytics and other service delivery indicators, it would create an accountability to all of system which would drive all of system behaviours. In New Zealand we already have the IDI (an awesome statistical evidence base) but what other evidence do we need? Shared user research, deidentified service analytics, reporting from major projects, etc. And how do we make that evidence more publicly transparent (where possible) and available beyond the walls of government to be used by other sectors?  More broadly, having an all of government evidence base beyond services would help ensure a greater evidence based approach to investment, strategic planning and behaviours.

Planet DebianJoey Hess: my haskell controlled offgrid fridge

I'm preparing for a fridge upgrade, away from the tiny propane fridge to a chest freezer conversion. My home computer will be monitoring the fridge temperature and the state of my offgrid energy system, and turning the fridge on and off using a relay and the inverter control board I built earlier.

This kind of automation is a perfect fit for Functional Reactive Programming (FRP) since it's all about time-varying behaviors and events being combined together.

Of course, I want the control code to be as robust as possible, well tested, and easy to modify without making mistakes. Pure functional Haskell code.

There are many Haskell libraries for FRP, and I have not looked at most of them in any detail. I settled on reactive-banana because it has a good reputation and amazing testimonials.

"In the programming-language world, one rule of survival is simple: dance or die. This library makes dancing easy." – Simon Banana Jones

But, it's mostly used for GUI programming, or maybe some musical live-coding. There were no libraries for using reactive-banana for the more staid task of home automation, or anything like that. Also, using it involves a whole lot of IO code, so not great for testing.

So I built reactive-banana-automation on top of it to address my needs. I think it's a pretty good library, although I don't have a deep enough grokking of FRP to say that for sure.

Anyway, it's plenty flexible for my fridge automation needs, and I also wrote a motion-controlled light automation with it to make sure it could be used for something else (and to partly tackle the problem of using real-world time events when the underlying FRP library uses its own notion of time).

The code for my fridge is a work in progress since the fridge has not arrived yet, and because the question of in which situations an offgrid fridge should optimally run and not run is really rather complicated.

Here's a simpler example, for a non-offgrid fridge.

fridge :: Automation Sensors Actuators
fridge sensors actuators = do
        -- Create a Behavior that reflects the most recently reported
        -- temperature of the fridge.
        btemperature <- sensedBehavior (fridgeTemperature sensors)
        -- Calculate when the fridge should turn on and off.
        let bpowerchange = calcpowerchange <$> btemperature
        onBehaviorChangeMaybe bpowerchange (actuators . FridgePower)
        calcpowerchange (Sensed temp)
                | temp `belowRange` allowedtemp = Just PowerOff
                | temp `aboveRange` allowedtemp = Just PowerOn
                | otherwise = Nothing
        calcpowerchange SensorUnavailable = Nothing
        allowedtemp = Range 1 4

And here the code is being tested in a reproducible fashion:

> runner <- observeAutomation fridge mkSensors
> runner $ \sensors -> fridgeTemperature sensors =: 6
[FridgePower PowerOn]
> runner $ \sensors -> fridgeTemperature sensors =: 3
> runner $ \sensors -> fridgeTemperature sensors =: 0.5
[FridgePower PowerOff]

BTW, building a 400 line library and writing reams of control code for a fridge that has not been installed yet is what we Haskell programmers call "laziness".

TEDThe world takes us exactly where we should be: 4 questions with Meagan Fallone

Cartier believes in the power of bold ideas to empower local initiatives to have global impact. To celebrate Cartier’s dedication to launching the ideas of female entrepreneurs into concrete change, TED has curated a special session of talks around the theme “Bold Alchemy” for the Cartier Women’s Initiative Awards, featuring a selection of favorite TED speakers.

Leading up to the session, TED talked with entrepreneur, designer and CEO of Barefoot College International, Meagan Fallone.

TED: Tell us who you are.
Meagan Fallone: I am an entrepreneur, a designer, a passionate mountaineer and a champion of women in the developing world and all women whose voices and potential remain unheard and unrealized. I am a mother and am grounded in the understanding that of all the things I may ever do in my life, it is the only one that truly will define me or endure. I am immovable in my intolerance to injustice in all its forms.

TED: What’s a bold move you’ve made in your career?
MF: I decided to leave the two for-profit companies I started and grow a nonprofit social enterprise.

TED: Tell us about a woman who inspires you.
MF: The women in my family who were risk-takers in their own individual ways: they are always with me and inspire me. My female friends who push me always to dig deeper within myself, to use my power and skills for ever bigger and better impact in the world. I am inspired always by every woman who has ever accepted to come to train with us at Barefoot College. They place their trust in us, leave their community and everyone they love to make an unimaginable journey on every level. It is the bravest thing I have ever seen.

TED: If you could go back in time, what would you tell your 18-year-old self?
MF: I would tell myself not to take myself so seriously. I would tell myself to trust that the world takes us exactly where we should be. It took me far too long to learn to laugh at how ridiculous I am sometimes. It took me even longer to accept that the path that was written for me was not exactly the one I envisaged for myself. Within the things I never imagined lay all the beauty and wonder of my journey so far — and the promise of what I have yet to impact.

The private TED session at Cartier takes place April 26 in Singapore. It will feature talks from a diverse range of global leaders, entrepreneurs and change-makers, exploring topics ranging from the changing global workforce to maternal health to data literacy, and it will include a performance from the only female double violinist in the world.

TEDPlaylist: 10 TEDWomen talks for Earth Day

Earlier this week, I had the privilege and honor to plant trees with the daughter and granddaughter of environmentalist Wangari Maathai. In recognition of her life’s work promoting “sustainable development, democracy and peace,” Maathai received the 2004 Nobel Peace Prize. She was a lifelong activist who founded the Green Belt Movement in 1977.

At that time, rural women in Kenya petitioned the government for help. They explained that their streams were drying up, causing their food supplies to be less secure and longer walks to fetch firewood. Maathai established the Green Belt Movement and encouraged the women of Kenya to work together to grow seedlings and plant trees to bind the soil, store rainwater, provide food and firewood, and receive a small monetary token for their work. Through her efforts, over 51 million trees have been planted in Kenya. Although Maathai died in 2011, her daughter Wanjira continues her work improving the livelihoods of the women of Kenya and striving for a “cleaner, greener world.”

This Earth Day, the work of Professor Maathai and the Green Belt Movement is an inspiration and a “testament to the power of grassroots organizing, proof that one person’s simple idea — that a community should come together to plant trees, can make a difference.”

With that in mind, here are 10 TEDWomen talks from over the years that highlight innovative ideas, cutting-edge science, and the power that each of us has to safeguard our planet and make our world better for everyone.

1. Climate change is unfair. While rich countries can fight against rising oceans and dying farm fields, poor people around the world are already having their lives upended — and their human rights threatened — by killer storms, starvation and the loss of their own lands. Mary Robinson asks us to join the movement for worldwide climate justice.

2. Ocean expert Nancy Rabalais tracks the ominously named “dead zone” in the Gulf of Mexico — where there isn’t enough oxygen in the water to support life. The Gulf has the second largest dead zone in the world; on top of killing fish and crustaceans, it’s also killing fisheries in these waters. Rabalais tells us about what’s causing it — and how we can reverse its harmful effects and restore one of America’s natural treasures.

3. Filmmaker Penelope Jagessar Chaffer was curious about the chemicals she was exposed to while pregnant: Could they affect her unborn child? So she asked scientist Tyrone Hayes to brief her on one he studied closely: atrazine, a herbicide used on corn. (Hayes, an expert on amphibians, is a critic of atrazine, which displays a disturbing effect on frog development.) Onstage together at TEDWomen, Hayes and Chaffer tell their story.

4. Deepika Kurup has been determined to solve the global water crisis since she was 14 years old, after she saw kids outside her grandparents’ house in India drinking water that looked too dirty even to touch. Her research began in her family kitchen — and eventually led to a major science prize. Hear how this teenage scientist developed a cost-effective, eco-friendly way to purify water.

5. Days before this talk, journalist Naomi Klein was on a boat in the Gulf of Mexico, looking at the catastrophic results of BP’s risky pursuit of oil. Our societies have become addicted to extreme risk in finding new energy, new financial instruments and more … and too often, we’re left to clean up a mess afterward. Klein’s question: What’s the backup plan?

6. The water hyacinth may look like a harmless, even beautiful flowering plant — but it’s actually an invasive aquatic weed that clogs waterways, stopping trade, interrupting schooling and disrupting everyday life. In this scourge, green entrepreneur Achenyo Idachaba saw opportunity. Follow her journey as she turns weeds into woven wonders.

7. A skyscraper that channels the breeze … a building that creates community around a hearth … Jeanne Gang uses architecture to build relationships. In this engaging tour of her work, Gang invites us into buildings large and small, from a surprising local community center to a landmark Chicago skyscraper. “Through architecture, we can do much more than create buildings,” she says. “We can help steady this planet we all share.”

8. Architect Kate Orff sees the oyster as an agent of urban change. Bundled into beds and sunk into city rivers, oysters slurp up pollution and make legendarily dirty waters clean — thus driving even more innovation in “oyster-tecture.” Orff shares her vision for an urban landscape that links nature and humanity for mutual benefit.

9. Beverly + Dereck Joubert live in the bush, filming and photographing lions and leopards in their natural habitat. With stunning footage (some never before seen), they discuss their personal relationships with these majestic animals — and their quest to save the big cats from human threats.

10. Artist and poet Cleo Wade shares some truths about growing up (and speaking up) and reflects on the wisdom of a life well-lived, leaving us with a simple yet enduring takeaway: be good to yourself, be good to others, be good to the earth. “The world will say to you, ‘Be a better person,'” Wade says. “Do not be afraid to say, ‘Yes.'”

TEDWomen 2018 Updates

If you’re interested in attending TEDWomen later this year in Palm Springs, California, on November 28–30, we encourage you to sign up for our email newsletter now to stay up to date. We will be adding details on venue, sessions themes, guest curators and speakers soon. Don’t miss the news!

Planet DebianLisandro Damián Nicanor Pérez Meyer: moving Qt 4 from Debian testing (aka Buster): some statistics, update II

As in my previous blogpost I'm taking a look at our Qt4 removal wiki page.

Of a total of 438 filed bugs:

  • 181 bugs (41.32%) have been already fixed by either porting the app/library to Qt 5 or a removal from the archive has happened. On most cases the code has been ported and most of the deletions are due to Qt 5 replacements already available in the archive and some due to dead upstreams (ie., no Qt5 port available).
  • 257 bugs (58.68%) still need a fix or are fixed in experimental.
  • 35 bugs (8% of the total, 13% of the remaining) of the remaining bugs are maintained inside the Qt/KDE team.
 We started filing bugs around September 9. That means roughly 32 weeks which gives us around 5.65 packages fixed per week, aka 0.85 packages per day. Obviously not as good as we started (remaining bugs tend to be more complicated), but still quite good.

So, how can you help?

If you are a maintainer of any of the packages still affected try to get upstream to make a port and package it.

If you are not a maintainer you might want to take a look at the list of packages in our wiki page and try to create a patch for them. If you can submit it directly to upstream, the better. Or maybe it's time for you to become the package's upstream or maintainer!

Planet DebianVincent Bernat: OPL2 Audio Board: an AdLib sound card for Arduino

In a previous article, I presented the OPL2LPT, a sound card for the parallel port featuring a Yamaha YM3812 chip, also known as OPL2—the chip of the AdLib sound card. The OPL2 Audio Board for Arduino is another indie sound card using this chip. However, instead of relying on a parallel port, it uses a serial interface, which can be drived from an Arduino board or a Raspberry Pi. While the OPL2LPT targets retrogamers with real hardware, the OPL2 Audio Board cannot be used in the same way. Nonetheless, it can also be operated from ScummVM and DOSBox!

OPL2 Audio Board for Arduino
The OPL2 Audio Board over a “Grim Fandango” box.


The OPL2 Audio Board can be purchased on Tindie, either as a kit or fully assembled. I have paired it with a cheap clone of the Arduino Nano. A library to drive the board is available on GitHub, along with some examples.

One of them is DemoTune.ino. It plays a short tune on three channels. It can be compiled and uploaded to the Arduino with PlatformIO—installable with pip install platformio—using the following command:1

$ platformio ci \
    --board nanoatmega328 \
    --lib ../../src \
    --project-option="targets=upload" \
    --project-option="upload_port=/dev/ttyUSB0" \
PLATFORM: Atmel AVR > Arduino Nano ATmega328
Converting DemoTune.ino
Configuring upload protocol...
AVAILABLE: arduino
CURRENT: upload_protocol = arduino
Looking for upload port...
Use manually specified: /dev/ttyUSB0
Uploading .pioenvs/nanoatmega328/firmware.hex
avrdude: 6618 bytes of flash written
===== [SUCCESS] Took 5.94 seconds =====

Immediately after the upload, the Arduino plays the tune. 🎶

The next interesting example is SerialIface.ino. It turns the audio board into a sound card over serial port. Once the code has been pushed to the Arduino, you can use the program in the same directory to play VGM files. They are a sample-accurate sound format for many sound chips. They log the exact commands sent. There are many of them on VGMRips. Be sure to choose the ones for the YM3812/OPL2! Here is a small selection:

The OPL2 Audio Board playing some VGM files. It is connected to an Arduino Nano. You can see the LEDs blinking when the Arduino receives the commands from the serial port.

Usage with DOSBox & ScummVM🔗


The support for the serial protocol used in this section has not been merged yet. In the meantime, grab SerialIface.ino from the pull request: git checkout 50e1717.

When the Arduino is flashed with SerialIface.ino, the board can be driven through a simple protocol over the serial port. By patching DOSBox and ScummVM, we can make them use this unusual sound card. Here are some examples of games:

  • 0:00, with DOSBox, the first level of Doom 🎮
  • 1:06, with DOSBox, the introduction of Loom 🎼
  • 2:38, with DOSBox, the first level of Lemmings 🐹
  • 3:32, with DOSBox, the introduction of Legend of Kyrandia 🃏
  • 6:47, with ScummVM, the introduction of Day of the Tentacle ☢️
  • 11:10, with DOSBox, the introduction of Another World2 🐅


The serial protocol is described in the SerialIface.ino file:

 * A very simple serial protocol is used.
 * - Initial 3-way handshake to overcome reset delay / serial noise issues.
 * - 5-byte binary commands to write registers.
 *   - (uint8)  OPL2 register address
 *   - (uint8)  OPL2 register data
 *   - (int16)  delay (milliseconds); negative -> pre-delay; positive -> post-delay
 *   - (uint8)  delay (microseconds / 4)
 * Example session:
 * Arduino: HLO!
 * PC:      BUF?
 * Arduino: 256 (switches to binary mode)
 * PC:      0xb80a014f02 (write OPL register and delay)
 * Arduino: k
 * A variant of this protocol is available without the delays. In this
 * case, the BUF? command should be sent as B0F? The binary protocol
 * is now using 2-byte binary commands:
 *   - (uint8)  OPL2 register address
 *   - (uint8)  OPL2 register data

Adding support for this protocol in DOSBox is relatively simple (patch). For best performance, we use the 2-byte variant (5000 ops/s). The binary commands are pipelined and a dedicated thread collects the acknowledgments. A semaphore captures the number of free slots in the receive buffer. As it is not possible to read registers, we rely on DOSBox to emulate the timers, which are mostly used to let the various games detect the OPL2.

The patch is tested only on Linux but should work on any POSIX system—not Windows. To test it, you need to build DOSBox from source:

$ sudo apt build-dep dosbox
$ git clone -b feature/opl2audioboard
$ cd dosbox
$ ./
$ ./configure && make

Replace the sblaster section of ~/.dosbox/dosbox-SVN.conf:


Then, run DOSBox with ./src/dosbox. That’s it!

You will likely get the “OPL2Arduino: too slow, consider increasing buffer” message a lot. To fix this, you need to recompile SerialIface.ino with a bigger receive buffer:

$ platformio ci \
    --board nanoatmega328 \
    --lib ../../src \
    --project-option="targets=upload" \
    --project-option="upload_port=/dev/ttyUSB0" \
    --project-option="build_flags=-DSERIAL_RX_BUFFER_SIZE=512" \


The same code can be adapted for ScummVM (patch). To test, build it from source:

$ sudo apt build-dep scummvm
$ git clone -b feature/opl2audioboard
$ cd scummvm
$ ./configure --disable-all-engines --enable-engine=scumm && make

Then, you can start ScummVM with ./scummvm. Select “AdLib Emulator” as the music device and “OPL2 Arduino” as the AdLib emulator.3 Like for DOSBox, watch the console to check if you need a larger receive buffer.

Enjoy! 😍

  1. This command is valid for an Arduino Nano. For another board, take a look at the output of platformio boards arduino↩︎

  2. Another World (also known as Out of This World), released in 1991, designed by Éric Chahi, is using sampled sounds at 5 kHz or 10 kHz. With a serial port operating at 115,200 bits/s, the 5 kHz option is just within our reach. However, I have no idea if the rendering is faithful. It doesn’t sound like a SoundBlaster, but it sounds analogous to the rendering of the OPL2LPT which sounds similar to the SoundBlaster when using the 10 kHz option. DOSBox’ AdLib emulation using Nuked OPL3—which is considered to be the best—sounds worse. ↩︎

  3. If you need to specify a serial port other than /dev/ttyUSB0, add a line opl2arduino_device= in the ~/.scummvmrc configuration file. ↩︎

Planet Linux AustraliaDavid Rowe: WaveNet and Codec 2

Yesterday my friend and fellow open source speech coder Jean-Marc Valin (of Speex and Opus fame) emailed me with some exciting news. W. Bastiaan Kleijn and friends have published a paper called “Wavenet based low rate speech coding“. Basically they take bit stream of Codec 2 running at 2400 bit/s, and replace the Codec 2 decoder with the WaveNet deep learning generative model.

What is amazing is the quality – it sounds as good an an 8000 bit/s wideband speech codec! They have generated wideband audio from the narrowband Codec model parameters. Here are the samples – compare “Parametrics WaveNet” to Codec 2!

This is a game changer for low bit rate speech coding.

I’m also happy that Codec 2 has been useful for academic research (Yay open source), and that the MOS scores in the paper show it’s close to MELP at 2400 bit/s. Last year we discovered Codec 2 is better than MELP at 600 bit/s. Not bad for an open source codec written (more or less) by one person.

Now I need to do some reading on Deep Learning!

Reading Further

Wavenet based low rate speech coding
Wavenet Speech Samples
AMBE+2 and MELPe 600 Compared to Codec 2


Planet DebianBenjamin Mako Hill: Hyak on Hyak

I recently fulfilled a yearslong dream of launching a job on Hyak* on Hyak.

Hyak on Hyak


* Hyak is the University of Washington’s supercomputer which my research group uses for most of our computation-intensive research.
M/V Hyak is a Super-class ferry operated by the Washington State Ferry System.

CryptogramFriday Squid Blogging: Squid Prices Rise as Catch Decreases

In Japan:

Last year's haul sank 15% to 53,000 tons, according to the JF Zengyoren national federation of fishing cooperatives. The squid catch has fallen by half in just two years. The previous low was plumbed in 2016.

Lighter catches have been blamed on changing sea temperatures, which impedes the spawning and growth of the squid. Critics have also pointed to overfishing by North Korean and Chinese fishing boats.

Wholesale prices of flying squid have climbed as a result. Last year's average price per kilogram came to 564 yen, a roughly 80% increase from two years earlier, according to JF Zengyoren.

As usual, you can also use this squid post to talk about the security stories in the news that I haven't covered.

Read my blog posting guidelines here.

Planet DebianJonathan Dowland: Twitter 10th anniversary

Tomorrow marks my 10th anniversary on Twitter. I have mixed feelings about the occasion. Twitter has been both a terrific success and a horrific failure. I've enjoyed it, I've discovered interesting people via Twitter and had some great interactions. I certainly prefer it to Facebook, but that's not a high benchmark.

Back in the early days I tried to engage with Twitter the way a hacker would. I worked out a scheme to archive my own tweets. I wrote a twitter bot. But Twitter became more and more hostile to that kind of interaction, so I no longer bother. Anything I put on Twitter I consider ephemeral. I've given up backing up my own tweets, conversations, or favourites. I deleted the bot. I keep a "sliding window" of recent tweets, outside of which I delete (via tweetdelete). My window started out a year wide; now it's down to three months.

Asides from the general hostility to third-parties wanting to build on the Twitter platform, they've also done a really poor job of managing bad actors. Of the the tools they do offer, they save the best for people with "verified" status: ostensibly a system for preventing fakes, now consider by some a status symbol. Twitter have done nothing to counter this, in fact they've actively encouraged it, by withdrawing it in at least one case from a notorious troll as an ad-hoc form of punishment. For the rest of us, the tools are woefully inadequate. If you find yourself on the receiving end of even a small pocket of bad attention, twitter becomes effectively unusable for hours or days on end. Finally troll-in-chief (and now President of the US) is inexplicably still permitted on Twitter despite repeatedly and egregiously violating their terms of service, demonstrating that there's different rules for some folks than the rest of us.

(By the way, I thoroughly recommend looking at Block Lists/Bots. I'm blocking thousands of accounts, although the system I've been using appears to have been abandoned. It might be worth a look at; I intend to at some point.)

To some extent Twitter is responsible for—if not the death, the mortal wounding— of blogging. Back in the dim-and-distant, we'd write blog posts for the idle thoughts (e.g.), and they've migrated quite comfortably to tweets, but it seems to have had a sapping effect on people writing even longer-form stuff. Twitter isn't the only culprit: Google sunsetting Reader in 2013 was an even bigger blow, and I've still not managed to find something to replace it. (Plenty of alternatives exist; but the habit has died.)

One of the well-meaning, spontaneous things that came from the Twitter community was the notion of "Follow Friday": on Fridays, folks would nominate other interesting folks that you might like to follow. In that spirit, and wishing to try boost the idea of blogging again, I'd like to nominate some interesting blogs that you might enjoy. (Feel free to recommend me some more blogs to read in the comments!):

  • Vicky Lai first came up on my radar via Her One Bag, documenting her nomadic lifestyle (Hello UltraNav keyboard, and Stanley travel mug!), but her main site is worth following, too. Most recently she's written up how she makes her twitter ephemeral using AWS Lambda.
  • Alex Beal, who I have already mentioned.
  • Chris Siebenmann, a UNIX systems administrator at the University of Toronto. Siebenmann's blog feels to me like it comes from a parallel Universe where I stuck it out as a sysadmin, and got institutional support to do the job justice (I didn't, and I didn't.)
  • Darren Wilkinson writes about Statistics, computing, data science, Bayes, stochastic modelling, systems biology and bioinformatics
  • Friend of the family Mina writes candidly and brilliantly about her journey beating Lymphoma as a new mum at Lymphoma, Raphi and me
  • Ashley Pomeroy writes infrequently, eclectically (and surreally) on a range of topics, from the history of the Playstation 3, running old games on modern machines, photography and Thinkpads.

A couple of blogs from non-Debian/Linux OS developers. It's always nice to see what the other grass is like.

Finally, a more pleasing decennial: this year marks 10 years since my first uploaded package for Debian.

Krebs on SecurityIs Facebook’s Anti-Abuse System Broken?

Facebook has built some of the most advanced algorithms for tracking users, but when it comes to acting on user abuse reports about Facebook groups and content that clearly violate the company’s “community standards,” the social media giant’s technology appears to be woefully inadequate.

Last week, Facebook deleted almost 120 groups totaling more than 300,000 members. The groups were mostly closed — requiring approval from group administrators before outsiders could view the day-to-day postings of group members.

However, the titles, images and postings available on each group’s front page left little doubt about their true purpose: Selling everything from stolen credit cards, identities and hacked accounts to services that help automate things like spamming, phishing and denial-of-service attacks for hire.

To its credit, Facebook deleted the groups within just a few hours of KrebsOnSecurity sharing via email a spreadsheet detailing each group, which concluded that the average length of time the groups had been active on Facebook was two years. But I suspect that the company took this extraordinary step mainly because I informed them that I intended to write about the proliferation of cybercrime-based groups on Facebook.

That story, Deleted Facebook Cybercrime Groups had 300,000 Members, ended with a statement from Facebook promising to crack down on such activity and instructing users on how to report groups that violate it its community standards.

In short order, some of the groups I reported that were removed re-established themselves within hours of Facebook’s action. I decided instead of contacting Facebook’s public relations arm directly that I would report those resurrected groups and others using Facebook’s stated process. Roughly two days later I received a series replies saying that Facebook had reviewed my reports but that none of the groups were found to have violated its standards. Here’s a snippet from those replies:

Perhaps I should give Facebook the benefit of the doubt: Maybe my multiple reports one after the other triggered some kind of anti-abuse feature that is designed to throttle those who would seek to abuse it to get otherwise legitimate groups taken offline — much in the way that pools of automated bot accounts have been known to abuse Twitter’s reporting system to successfully sideline accounts of specific targets.

Or it could be that I simply didn’t click the proper sequence of buttons when reporting these groups. The closest match I could find in Facebook’s abuse reporting system were, “Doesn’t belong on Facebook,” and “Purchase or sale of drugs, guns or regulated products.” There was/is no option for “selling hacked accounts, credit cards and identities,” or anything of that sort.

In any case, one thing seems clear: Naming and shaming these shady Facebook groups via Twitter seems to work better right now for getting them removed from Facebook than using Facebook’s own formal abuse reporting process. So that’s what I did on Thursday. Here’s an example:

Within minutes of my tweeting about this, the group was gone. I also tweeted about “Best of the Best,” which was selling accounts from many different e-commerce vendors, including Amazon and eBay:

That group, too, was nixed shortly after my tweet. And so it went for other groups I mentioned in my tweetstorm today. But in response to that flurry of tweets about abusive groups on Facebook, I heard from dozens of other Twitter users who said they’d received the same “does not violate our community standards” reply from Facebook after reporting other groups that clearly flouted the company’s standards.

Pete Voss, Facebook’s communications manager, apologized for the oversight.

“We’re sorry about this mistake,” Voss said. “Not removing this material was an error and we removed it as soon as we investigated. Our team processes millions of reports each week, and sometimes we get things wrong. We are reviewing this case specifically, including the user’s reporting options, and we are taking steps to improve the experience, which could include broadening the scope of categories to choose from.”

Facebook CEO and founder Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress last week in response to allegations that the company wasn’t doing enough to halt the abuse of its platform for things like fake news, hate speech and terrorist content. It emerged that Facebook already employs 15,000 human moderators to screen and remove offensive content, and that it plans to hire another 5,000 by the end of this year.

“But right now, those moderators can only react to posts Facebook users have flagged,” writes Will Knight, for

Zuckerberg told lawmakers that Facebook hopes expected advances in artificial intelligence or “AI” technology will soon help the social network do a better job self-policing against abusive content. But for the time being, as long as Facebook mainly acts on abuse reports only when it is publicly pressured to do so by lawmakers or people with hundreds of thousands of followers, the company will continue to be dogged by a perception that doing otherwise is simply bad for its business model.

Update, 1:32 p.m. ET: Several readers pointed my attention to a Huffington Post story just three days ago, “Facebook Didn’t Seem To Care I Was Being Sexually Harassed Until I Decided To Write About It,” about a journalist whose reports of extreme personal harassment on Facebook were met with a similar response about not violating the company’s Community Standards. That is, until she told Facebook that she planned to write about it.

CryptogramSecuring Elections

Elections serve two purposes. The first, and obvious, purpose is to accurately choose the winner. But the second is equally important: to convince the loser. To the extent that an election system is not transparently and auditably accurate, it fails in that second purpose. Our election systems are failing, and we need to fix them.

Today, we conduct our elections on computers. Our registration lists are in computer databases. We vote on computerized voting machines. And our tabulation and reporting is done on computers. We do this for a lot of good reasons, but a side effect is that elections now have all the insecurities inherent in computers. The only way to reliably protect elections from both malice and accident is to use something that is not hackable or unreliable at scale; the best way to do that is to back up as much of the system as possible with paper.

Recently, there have been two graphic demonstrations of how bad our computerized voting system is. In 2007, the states of California and Ohio conducted audits of their electronic voting machines. Expert review teams found exploitable vulnerabilities in almost every component they examined. The researchers were able to undetectably alter vote tallies, erase audit logs, and load malware on to the systems. Some of their attacks could be implemented by a single individual with no greater access than a normal poll worker; others could be done remotely.

Last year, the Defcon hackers' conference sponsored a Voting Village. Organizers collected 25 pieces of voting equipment, including voting machines and electronic poll books. By the end of the weekend, conference attendees had found ways to compromise every piece of test equipment: to load malicious software, compromise vote tallies and audit logs, or cause equipment to fail.

It's important to understand that these were not well-funded nation-state attackers. These were not even academics who had been studying the problem for weeks. These were bored hackers, with no experience with voting machines, playing around between parties one weekend.

It shouldn't be any surprise that voting equipment, including voting machines, voter registration databases, and vote tabulation systems, are that hackable. They're computers -- often ancient computers running operating systems no longer supported by the manufacturers -- and they don't have any magical security technology that the rest of the industry isn't privy to. If anything, they're less secure than the computers we generally use, because their manufacturers hide any flaws behind the proprietary nature of their equipment.

We're not just worried about altering the vote. Sometimes causing widespread failures, or even just sowing mistrust in the system, is enough. And an election whose results are not trusted or believed is a failed election.

Voting systems have another requirement that makes security even harder to achieve: the requirement for a secret ballot. Because we have to securely separate the election-roll system that determines who can vote from the system that collects and tabulates the votes, we can't use the security systems available to banking and other high-value applications.

We can securely bank online, but can't securely vote online. If we could do away with anonymity -- if everyone could check that their vote was counted correctly -- then it would be easy to secure the vote. But that would lead to other problems. Before the US had the secret ballot, voter coercion and vote-buying were widespread.

We can't, so we need to accept that our voting systems are insecure. We need an election system that is resilient to the threats. And for many parts of the system, that means paper.

Let's start with the voter rolls. We know they've already been targeted. In 2016, someone changed the party affiliation of hundreds of voters before the Republican primary. That's just one possibility. A well-executed attack that deletes, for example, one in five voters at random -- or changes their addresses -- would cause chaos on election day.

Yes, we need to shore up the security of these systems. We need better computer, network, and database security for the various state voter organizations. We also need to better secure the voter registration websites, with better design and better internet security. We need better security for the companies that build and sell all this equipment.

Multiple, unchangeable backups are essential. A record of every addition, deletion, and change needs to be stored on a separate system, on write-only media like a DVD. Copies of that DVD, or -- even better -- a paper printout of the voter rolls, should be available at every polling place on election day. We need to be ready for anything.

Next, the voting machines themselves. Security researchers agree that the gold standard is a voter-verified paper ballot. The easiest (and cheapest) way to achieve this is through optical-scan voting. Voters mark paper ballots by hand; they are fed into a machine and counted automatically. That paper ballot is saved, and serves as a final true record in a recount in case of problems. Touch-screen machines that print a paper ballot to drop in a ballot box can also work for voters with disabilities, as long as the ballot can be easily read and verified by the voter.

Finally, the tabulation and reporting systems. Here again we need more security in the process, but we must always use those paper ballots as checks on the computers. A manual, post-election, risk-limiting audit varies the number of ballots examined according to the margin of victory. Conducting this audit after every election, before the results are certified, gives us confidence that the election outcome is correct, even if the voting machines and tabulation computers have been tampered with. Additionally, we need better coordination and communications when incidents occur.

It's vital to agree on these procedures and policies before an election. Before the fact, when anyone can win and no one knows whose votes might be changed, it's easy to agree on strong security. But after the vote, someone is the presumptive winner -- and then everything changes. Half of the country wants the result to stand, and half wants it reversed. At that point, it's too late to agree on anything.

The politicians running in the election shouldn't have to argue their challenges in court. Getting elections right is in the interest of all citizens. Many countries have independent election commissions that are charged with conducting elections and ensuring their security. We don't do that in the US.

Instead, we have representatives from each of our two parties in the room, keeping an eye on each other. That provided acceptable security against 20th-century threats, but is totally inadequate to secure our elections in the 21st century. And the belief that the diversity of voting systems in the US provides a measure of security is a dangerous myth, because few districts can be decisive and there are so few voting-machine vendors.

We can do better. In 2017, the Department of Homeland Security declared elections to be critical infrastructure, allowing the department to focus on securing them. On 23 March, Congress allocated $380m to states to upgrade election security.

These are good starts, but don't go nearly far enough. The constitution delegates elections to the states but allows Congress to "make or alter such Regulations". In 1845, Congress set a nationwide election day. Today, we need it to set uniform and strict election standards.

This essay originally appeared in the Guardian.

Worse Than FailureError'd: Placeholders-a-Plenty

"On my admittedly old and cheap phone, Google Maps seems to have confused the definition of the word 'trip'," writes Ivan.


"When you're Gas Networks Ireland, and don't have anything nice to say, I guess you just say lorem ipsum," wrote Gabe.


Daniel D. writes, "Google may not know how I got 100 GB, but they seem pretty sure that it's expiring soon."


Peter S. wrote, "F1 finally did it. The quantum driver Lastname is driving a Ferrari and chasing him- or herself in Red Bull."


Hrish B. writes, "I hope my last name is not an example as well."


Peter S. wrote, "Not sure what IEEE wants me to vote for. But I would vote for hiring better coders."


"Well, at least they got my name right, half of the time," Peter S. writes.


[Advertisement] Forget logs. Next time you're struggling to replicate error, crash and performance issues in your apps - Think Raygun! Installs in minutes. Learn more.

Planet Linux AustraliaOpenSTEM: NAPLAN and vocabulary

It is the time of year when the thoughts of teachers of students in years 3, 5, 7 and 9 turn (not so) lightly to NAPLAN. I’m sure many of you are aware of the controversial review of NAPLAN by Les Perelman, a retired professor from MIT in the United States. Perelman conducted a similar […]

Planet Linux AustraliaFrancois Marier: Using a Kenwood TH-D72A with Pat on Linux and ax25

Here is how I managed to get my Kenwood TH-D72A radio working with Pat on Linux using the built-in TNC and the AX.25 mode

Installing Pat

First of all, download and install the latest Pat package from the GitHub project page.

dpkg -i pat_x.y.z_amd64.deb

Then, follow the installation instructions for the AX.25 mode and install the necessary packages:

apt install ax25-tools ax25-apps

along with the systemd script that comes with Pat:



Once the packages are installed, it's time to configure everything correctly:

  1. Power cycle the radio.
  2. Enable TNC in packet12 mode (band A*).
  3. Tune band A to VECTOR channel 420 (or 421 if you can't reach VA7EOC on simplex).
  4. Put the following in /etc/ax25/axports (replacing CALLSIGN with your own callsign):

     wl2k    CALLSIGN    9600    128    4    Winlink
  5. Set HBAUD to 1200 in /etc/default/ax25.

  6. Download and compile the tmd710_tncsetup script mentioned in a comment in /etc/default/ax25:

     gcc -o tmd710_tncsetup tmd710_tncsetup.c
  7. Add the tmd710_tncsetup script in /etc/default/ax25 and use these command line parameters (-B 0 specifies band A, use -B 1 for band B):

     tmd710_tncsetup -B 0 -S $DEV -b $HBAUD -s
  8. Start ax25 driver:

     systemctl start ax25.service

Connecting to a winlink gateway

To monitor what is being received and transmitted:

axlisten -cart

Then create aliases like these in ~/.wl2k/config.json:

  "connect_aliases": {
    "ax25-VA7EOC": "ax25://wl2k/VA7EOC-10",
    "ax25-VE7LAN": "ax25://wl2k/VE7LAN-10"

and use them to connect to your preferred Winlink gateways.


If it doesn't look like ax25 can talk to the radio (i.e. the TX light doesn't turn ON), then it's possible that the tmd710_tncsetup script isn't being run at all, in which case the TNC isn't initialized correctly.

On the other hand, if you can see the radio transmitting but are not seeing any incoming packets in axlisten then double check that the speed is set correctly:

  • HBAUD in /etc/default/ax25 should be set to 1200
  • line speed in /etc/ax25/axports should be set to 9600
  • SERIAL_SPEED in tmd710_tncsetup should be set to 9600
  • radio displays packet12 in the top-left corner, not packet96

If you can establish a connection, but it's very unreliable, make sure that you have enabled software flow control (the -s option in tmd710_tncsetup).

If you can't connect to VA7EOC-10 on UHF, you could also try the VHF BCFM repeater on Mt Seymour, VE7LAN (VECTOR channel 65).

Planet DebianGunnar Wolf: 15.010958904109589041

Gregor's post made me think...

And yes! On April 15, I passed the 15-year-mark as a Debian Developer.

So, today I am 15.010958904109589041 years old in the project, give or take some seconds.

And, quoting my dear and admired friend, I deeply feel I belong to this community. Being part of Debian has defined the way I have shaped my career, has brought me beautiful friendships I will surely keep for many many more years, has helped me decide in which direction I should push to improve the world. I feel welcome and very recognized among people I highly value and admire, and that's the best collective present I could get.

Debian has grown and matured tremendously since the time I decided to join, and I'm very proud to be a part of that process.

Thanks, and lets keep it going for the next decade.

Planet DebianKees Cook: UEFI booting and RAID1

I spent some time yesterday building out a UEFI server that didn’t have on-board hardware RAID for its system drives. In these situations, I always use Linux’s md RAID1 for the root filesystem (and/or /boot). This worked well for BIOS booting since BIOS just transfers control blindly to the MBR of whatever disk it sees (modulo finding a “bootable partition” flag, etc, etc). This means that BIOS doesn’t really care what’s on the drive, it’ll hand over control to the GRUB code in the MBR.

With UEFI, the boot firmware is actually examining the GPT partition table, looking for the partition marked with the “EFI System Partition” (ESP) UUID. Then it looks for a FAT32 filesystem there, and does more things like looking at NVRAM boot entries, or just running BOOT/EFI/BOOTX64.EFI from the FAT32. Under Linux, this .EFI code is either GRUB itself, or Shim which loads GRUB.

So, if I want RAID1 for my root filesystem, that’s fine (GRUB will read md, LVM, etc), but how do I handle /boot/efi (the UEFI ESP)? In everything I found answering this question, the answer was “oh, just manually make an ESP on each drive in your RAID and copy the files around, add a separate NVRAM entry (with efibootmgr) for each drive, and you’re fine!” I did not like this one bit since it meant things could get out of sync between the copies, etc.

The current implementation of Linux’s md RAID puts metadata at the front of a partition. This solves more problems than it creates, but it means the RAID isn’t “invisible” to something that doesn’t know about the metadata. In fact, mdadm warns about this pretty loudly:

# mdadm --create /dev/md0 --level 1 --raid-disks 2 /dev/sda1 /dev/sdb1 mdadm: Note: this array has metadata at the start and may not be suitable as a boot device. If you plan to store '/boot' on this device please ensure that your boot-loader understands md/v1.x metadata, or use --metadata=0.90

Reading from the mdadm man page:

-e, --metadata= ... 1, 1.0, 1.1, 1.2 default Use the new version-1 format superblock. This has fewer restrictions. It can easily be moved between hosts with different endian-ness, and a recovery operation can be checkpointed and restarted. The different sub-versions store the superblock at different locations on the device, either at the end (for 1.0), at the start (for 1.1) or 4K from the start (for 1.2). "1" is equivalent to "1.2" (the commonly preferred 1.x format). "default" is equivalent to "1.2".

First we toss a FAT32 on the RAID (mkfs.fat -F32 /dev/md0), and looking at the results, the first 4K is entirely zeros, and file doesn’t see a filesystem:

# dd if=/dev/sda1 bs=1K count=5 status=none | hexdump -C 00000000 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 |................| * 00001000 fc 4e 2b a9 01 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 |.N+.............| ... # file -s /dev/sda1 /dev/sda1: Linux Software RAID version 1.2 ...

So, instead, we’ll use --metadata 1.0 to put the RAID metadata at the end:

# mdadm --create /dev/md0 --level 1 --raid-disks 2 --metadata 1.0 /dev/sda1 /dev/sdb1 ... # mkfs.fat -F32 /dev/md0 # dd if=/dev/sda1 bs=1 skip=80 count=16 status=none | xxd 00000000: 2020 4641 5433 3220 2020 0e1f be77 7cac FAT32 ...w|. # file -s /dev/sda1 /dev/sda1: ... FAT (32 bit)

Now we have a visible FAT32 filesystem on the ESP. UEFI should be able to boot whatever disk hasn’t failed, and grub-install will write to the RAID mounted at /boot/efi.

However, we’re left with a new problem: on (at least) Debian and Ubuntu, grub-install attempts to run efibootmgr to record which disk UEFI should boot from. This fails, though, since it expects a single disk, not a RAID set. In fact, it returns nothing, and tries to run efibootmgr with an empty -d argument:

Installing for x86_64-efi platform. efibootmgr: option requires an argument -- 'd' ... grub-install: error: efibootmgr failed to register the boot entry: Operation not permitted. Failed: grub-install --target=x86_64-efi WARNING: Bootloader is not properly installed, system may not be bootable

Luckily my UEFI boots without NVRAM entries, and I can disable the NVRAM writing via the “Update NVRAM variables to automatically boot into Debian?” debconf prompt when running: dpkg-reconfigure -p low grub-efi-amd64

So, now my system will boot with both or either drive present, and updates from Linux to /boot/efi are visible on all RAID members at boot-time. HOWEVER there is one nasty risk with this setup: if UEFI writes anything to one of the drives (which this firmware did when it wrote out a “boot variable cache” file), it may lead to corrupted results once Linux mounts the RAID (since the member drives won’t have identical block-level copies of the FAT32 any more).

To deal with this “external write” situation, I see some solutions:

  • Make the partition read-only when not under Linux. (I don’t think this is a thing.)
  • Create higher-level knowledge of the root-filesystem RAID configuration is needed to keep a collection of filesystems manually synchronized instead of doing block-level RAID. (Seems like a lot of work and would need redesign of /boot/efi into something like /boot/efi/booted, /boot/efi/spare1, /boot/efi/spare2, etc)
  • Prefer one RAID member’s copy of /boot/efi and rebuild the RAID at every boot. If there were no external writes, there’s no issue. (Though what’s really the right way to pick the copy to prefer?)

Since mdadm has the “--update=resync” assembly option, I can actually do the latter option. This required updating /etc/mdadm/mdadm.conf to add <ignore> on the RAID’s ARRAY line to keep it from auto-starting:

ARRAY <ignore> metadata=1.0 UUID=123...

(Since it’s ignored, I’ve chosen /dev/md100 for the manual assembly below.) Then I added the noauto option to the /boot/efi entry in /etc/fstab:

/dev/md100 /boot/efi vfat noauto,defaults 0 0

And finally I added a systemd oneshot service that assembles the RAID with resync and mounts it:

[Unit] Description=Resync /boot/efi RAID DefaultDependencies=no [Service] Type=oneshot ExecStart=/sbin/mdadm -A /dev/md100 --uuid=123... --update=resync ExecStart=/bin/mount /boot/efi RemainAfterExit=yes [Install]

(And don’t forget to run “update-initramfs -u” so the initramfs has an updated copy of /dev/mdadm/mdadm.conf.)

If mdadm.conf supported an “update=” option for ARRAY lines, this would have been trivial. Looking at the source, though, that kind of change doesn’t look easy. I can dream!

And if I wanted to keep a “pristine” version of /boot/efi that UEFI couldn’t update I could rearrange things more dramatically to keep the primary RAID member as a loopback device on a file in the root filesystem (e.g. /boot/efi.img). This would make all external changes in the real ESPs disappear after resync. Something like:

# truncate --size 512M /boot/efi.img # losetup -f --show /boot/efi.img /dev/loop0 # mdadm --create /dev/md100 --level 1 --raid-disks 3 --metadata 1.0 /dev/loop0 /dev/sda1 /dev/sdb1

And at boot just rebuild it from /dev/loop0, though I’m not sure how to “prefer” that partition…

© 2018, Kees Cook. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License.
Creative Commons License


Planet DebianEnrico Zini: Detect a UEFI partition

Today I had to implement a check to see if a disk contains a UEFI ESP partition.

Here it is, it also works on disk image files instead of devices:

def get_uefi_partition(self, disk_dev):
    Return the partition device of the UEFI ESP partition for the device in

    Returns None if disk_dev contains no UEFI ESP partition.
    import parted
    pdev = parted.getDevice(disk_dev)
    pdisk = parted.newDisk(pdev)
    if pdisk.type != "gpt":
        log.error("device %s has partition table type %s instead of gpt", disk_dev, pdisk.type)
        return None
    for part in pdisk.partitions:
        if part.getFlag(18):
  "Found ESP partition in %s", part.path)
            return part.path"No ESP partition found in %s", disk_dev)
    return None

Planet DebianRhonda D'Vine: Diversity Update

I have to excuse for being silent for that long. Way too many things happened. In fact I already wrote most of this last fall, but then something happened that did impact me too much to finalize this entry. And with that I want to go a bit into details how I write my blog entries:
I start to write them in English, I like to cross-reference things, and after I'm done I go over it and write it again in German. That process helps me proof-reading the English part, but it also means that it takes a fair amount of time. And the longer the entries get the more energy the translation and proof reading part takes, too. That's mostly also the reason why I tend to write longer entries when I find the energy and time for it.

Anyway, the first thing that I want to mention here finally happened last June: I officially got changed my name and gender/sex marker in my papers! That was a very happy moment in so many ways. A week later I got my new passport, finally managed to book my flight to Debconf in my name. Yay me, I exist!

Then, Stretch was released. I have to admit I had very little to do, wasn't involved in the release process, neither from the website team nor anywhere else because ...

... because I was packing my stuff that weekend, because on June 21st, a second thing finally happened: I got the keys to my flat in the Que[e]rbau!! Yes, I'm aware that we still need to work on the website. The building company actually did make a big event out of it, called every single person onto stage and handed over the keys. And it made me happy to be able to receive my key in my name and not one I don't relate to since a long while anymore. It did hurt seeing that happening to someone else from our house, even though they knew what the Que[e]rbau is about ... And: I moved right in the same day. Gave up my old flat the following week, even though I didn't have much furniture nor a kitchen but I was waiting way too long to be able to not be there. And just watch that sunset from my balcony. <3

And I mentioned it in the last blog post already, the European Lesbian* Conference organization needed more and more work, too. The program for it started to finalize, but there were still more than enough things to do. I totally fell into this, this was the first time I really felt what intersectionality means and that it's not just a label but an internal part of this conference. The energy going on in the team on that grounds is really outstanding, and I'm totally happy to be part of this effort.

And then came along Debconf17 in Montreal. It was nice to be with a fair amount of people that grew on me like a family over the years. And interestingly I got the notice that there was a Trans March going on, so I joined that. It was a pleasure meeting Sophie LaBelle and Chase Ross there. I wasn't aware that Chase was from Montreal, so that part was a surprise. Sophie I knew, and I brought her back to Vienna in November, right before the Transgender Day of Remembrance. :)

But one of the two moving speeches at the march were from Charlie Rose titled My Gender Is Black. I managed to get a recording of this and another great speech from another Black Lives Matters activist, and hope I'll be able to put them online at some point. For the time being the link to the text should be able to help.

And then Debconf itself started. And I held the Debian Diversity Round Table. While the title might had been misleading, because this group isn't officially formed yet, it turned out to get a fair amount of interest. I started off with why I called for it, that I intentionally chose to not have it video taped for people to be able to speak more freely and after a short introduction round with names, pronouns and other things people wanted to share we had some interesting discussions on why people think this is a good idea, what direction to move. A few ideas did spring up, and then ... time ran out. So actually we scheduled a continuation BoF to further enhance the topic. At the end of that we came up with a pretty good consensual view on how to move forward. Unfortunately I didn't manage yet to follow up on that and feel quite bad about it. :/

Because, after returning, getting back into work, and needing a bit more time for EL*C I started to feel serious pain in my back and my leg which seems to be a slipped disc and was on sick leave for about two months. The pain was too much, I even had to stay at the hospital for two weeks because my stomach acted up too.

At the end of October we had a grand opening: We have a community space in our Que[e]rbau in which we built sort of a bar, with cooking facility and hi-fi equipment. And we intentionally opened it up to the public. It's name is Yella Yella! Nachbar_innentreff. We named it after Yella Hertzka who was an important feminist at the start of the 20th century. The park on the other side of the street is called Yella Hertzka park, so the pun in the name with the connection to the arabic proverb Yalla Yalla is intentional.

With the Yella Yella a fair amount of internal discussions emerged, we all only started to live together, so naturally this took a fair amount of energy and discussions. Things take time to get a feeling for all the people. There were several interviews made, and events to get organized to get it running.

And then out of the sudden it turned 2018 and I still haven't published this post. I'm sorry 'bout that, but sometimes there are other things needing time. And here I am. Time move on even if we don't look at it.

A recent project that I had the honor to be part of is my movement is limitless [trans_non-binary short]. It was interesting to think about the topic whether gender identity affects the way you dance. And to seen and hear other people's approach to it.

At the upcoming Linuxtage Graz there will be a session about Common misconceptions about names and spaces and communities because they were enforcing a realname policy – at a community event. Not only is this a huge issue for trans people but also works against privacy researchers or people from the community that noone really knows by the name in their papers. The discussions that happened on twitter or in the background were partly a fair bit disturbing. Let's hope that we'll manage to make a good panel.

Which brings us to a panel for the upcoming Debconf in Taiwan. There is a suggestion to have a Gender Forum at the Openday. I'm still not completely sure what it should cover or what is expected for it and I guess it's still open for suggestions. There will be a plan, let's see to make it diverse and great!

I won't promise to send the next update sooner, but I'll try to get back into it. Right now I'm also working on a (German language) submission for a non-binary YouTube project and it would be great to see that thing lift off. I'll be more verbose on that front.

Thanks for reading so far, and read you soon. :)

/personal | permanent link | Comments: 0 | Flattr this

Planet DebianGregor Herrmann: 10 years + 1 day

yesterday 10 years ago I became a Debian Developer.
& I still feel that I belong to this community.
& it took me one more day to write this tiny blog post about it.
so tonight I can celebrate 10 years plus 1 day :)

Planet DebianSteinar H. Gunderson: MySQL 8.0 released

(This post is not endorsed by Oracle, and I do not speak for them.)

MySQL 8.0.11 GA (General Availability) is out today—for those not used to Oracle's idiosyncratic versioning, this essentially means “MySQL 8.0 is released” (8.0.1 and so forth were various stages of alpha and beta). This marks the end of three years of development, of which I've been on board for two or so of them.

It feels a bit strange to be working on a product you don't use yourself (my personal datastore of choice firmly remains PostgreSQL), but that's how things go—back when I worked in Google, there were also products that I felt more or less deeply about, although I generally felt more connected to them and less “it's just a job”. I do pride myself on having a neutral assessment of my employer's products, though—I don't use a product just because my employer makes it (e.g., I didn't use Gmail or Google Plus personally when I worked at Google, as I don't find them very good products, but I did use Maps and Search, which I both find excellent).

Being new on the team, it's hard to dive directly in and make major contributions—MySQL is a product with a lot of legacy, despite extensive cleanups over the last few years (especially after Oracle bought Sun and the original developers left), and the amount of documentation is rather varying. So what did I do? I removed stuff. Tons of it.

I removed warnings for newer compilers (in many rounds, and so did many others). I removed tons of unneeded includes. I removed unneeded usages of Boost. I removed the abomination that was my_global.h (there used to be a single global header file that everything was supposed to #include, and in turn #included half the world). I removed home-grown atomics, since C++11 includes its own in the standard. I removed DTrace probes that nobody used. I removed bad names. I removed the custom bool type (yes, seriously, MySQL had its own type for bool, which caused rather subtle bugs). I removed PAD SPACE behavior from the default collation, which enabled a few important optimizations (and NO PAD makes so much more sense in a Unicode world). I removed lots of internal header files from the default installation. I removed the home-grown TLS system (which sped up everything by a few percent). I removed the home-grown quicksort code. I removed radixsort, which was only a win because the old home-grown quicksort code was so slow. I removed the home-grown hash table HASH which was not type-safe, slower than the C++11 unordered_map and fairly buggy. I removed the dreaded query cache! (I didn't remove the embedded server, which doubled the compile time and nobody ever used, but I pushed pretty hard for doing so.) I removed ambiguous includes. I removed unused code from binaries, shrinking the distribution by a few megabytes. I removed compiler flag ricing that doesn't help in 2018. I removed a home-grown printf that was buggy. I removed a lot of C legacy, since MySQL no longer needs to be bound to a world without C++. I removed Sql_alloc, a magical class you'd inherit from and get surprising memory-allocation behavior. I removed some waiting on the compiler. I removed MySQL's custom and weird coding style (well, at least its formatting). And I removed obsolete SQL modes (together with others), which as far as I know is the first time anyone's removed an SQL mode in MySQL.

Of course, I didn't only remove stuff; I also added things like more efficient sorting of strings, added a new microbenchmark framework, sped up the new Unicode 9.0 collations by 20x, and probably added some legacy on my own. :-) But sometimes, it's good to remove. Remove some code today!

Planet DebianJulien Danjou: Lessons from OpenStack Telemetry: Deflation

Lessons from OpenStack Telemetry: Deflation

This post is the second and final episode of Lessons from OpenStack Telemetry. If you have missed the first post, you can read it here.


At some point, the rules relaxed on new projects addition with the Big Tent initiative, allowing us to rename ourselves to the OpenStack Telemetry team and splitting Ceilometer into several subprojects: Aodh (alarm evaluation functionality) and Panko (events storage). Gnocchi was able to join the OpenStack Telemetry party for its first anniversary.

Finally being able to split Ceilometer into several independent pieces of software allowed us to tackle technical debt more rapidly. We built autonomous teams for each project and gave them the same liberty they had in Ceilometer. The cost of migrating the code base to several projects was higher than we wanted it to be, but we managed to build a clear migration path nonetheless.

Gnocchi Shamble

With Gnocchi in town, we stopped all efforts on Ceilometer storage and API and expected people to adopt Gnocchi. What we underestimated is the unwillingness of many operators to think about telemetry. They did not want to deploy anything to have telemetry features in the first place, so adding yet a new component (a timeseries database) to have proper metric features was seen a burden – and sometimes not seen at all.
Indeed, we also did not communicate enough on our vision for that transition. After two years of existence, many operators were asking what Gnocchi was and what they needed it for. They deployed Ceilometer and its bogus storage and API and were confused about needing yet another piece of software.

It took us more than two years to deprecate the Ceilometer storage and API, which is way too long.


In the meantime, people were leaving the OpenStack boat. Soon enough, we started to feel the shortage of human resources. Smartly, we never followed the OpenStack trend of imposing blueprints, specs, bug reports or any process to contributors, obeying my list of open source best practice. This flexibility allowed us to iterate more rapidly; compared to other OpenStack projects; we were going faster proportionately to the size of our contributor base.

Lessons from OpenStack Telemetry: Deflation

Nonetheless, we felt like bailing out a sinking ship. Our contributors were disappearing while we were swamped with technical debt: half-baked feature, unfinished migration, legacy choices and temporary hacks. After the big party that happened, we had to wash the dishes and sweep the floor.

Being part of OpenStack started to feel like a burden in many ways. The inertia of OpenStack being a big project was beginning to surface, so we put up a lot of efforts to dodge most of its implications. Consequently, the team was perceived as an outlier, which does not help, especially when you have to interact with a lot your neighbors.

The OpenStack Foundation never understood the organization of our team. They would refer to us as "Ceilometer" whereas we formally renamed ourselves to "Telemetry" since we were englobing four server projects and a few libraries. For example, while Gnocchi has been an OpenStack project for two years before leaving, it has never been listed on the project navigator maintained by the foundation.

That's a funny anecdote that demonstrates the peculiarity of our team, and how it has been both a strength and a weakness.


Nobody was trying to do what we were doing when we started Ceilometer. We filled the space of metering OpenStack. However, as the number of companies involved increased and the friction with it along, some people grew unhappy. The race to have a seat at the table of the feast and becoming a Project Team Leader was strong, so some people preferred to create their project rather than trying to play the contribution game. In many areas, including our, that divided the effort up to a ridiculous point where several teams where doing the exact the same thing, or were trying to step on each other toes to kill the competitors.

We spent a significant amount of time trying to bring other teams in the Telemetry scope, to unify our efforts, without much success. Some companies were not embracing open-source because of their cultural differences, while some others had no interest to join a project where they would not be seen as the leader.

That fragmentation did not help us, but also did not do much harm in the end. Most of those projects are now either dead or becoming irrelevant as the rest of the world caught up on what they were trying to do.


As of 2018, I'm the PTL for Telemetry – because nobody else ran. The official list of maintainer for the telemetry projects is five people: two are inactive, and three are part-time. During the latest development cycle (Queens), 48 people committed in Ceilometer, though only three developers made impactful contributions. The code size has been divided by two since the peak: Ceilometer is now 25k lines of code long.

Panko and Aodh have no active developer. A Red Hat colleague and I are maintaining the projects afloat to keep it working.

Gnocchi has humbly thriven since it left OpenStack. The stains from having been part of OpenStack are not yet all gone. It has a small community, but users see its real value and enjoy using it.

Those last six years have been intense, and riding the OpenStack train has been amazing. As I concluded in the first blog post of this series, most of us had a great time overall; the point of those writings is not to complain, but to reflect.

I find it fascinating to see how the evolution of a piece of software and the metamorphosis of its community are entangled. The amount of politics that a corporately-backed project of this size generates is majestic and has a prominent influence on the outcome of software development.

So, what's next? Well, as far as Ceilometer is concerned, we still have ideas and plans to keep shrinking its footprint to a minimum. We hope that one-day Ceilometer will become irrelevant – at least that's what we're trying to achieve so we don't have anything to maintain. That mainly depends on how the myriad of OpenStack projects will chose to address their metering.

We don't see any future for Panko nor Aodh.

Gnocchi, now blooming outside of OpenStack, is still young and promising. We've plenty of ideas and every new release brings new fancy features. The storage of timeseries at large scale is exciting. Users are happy, and the ecosystem is growing.

We'll see how all of that concludes, but I'm sure it'll be new lessons to learn and write about in six years!

CryptogramLifting a Fingerprint from a Photo

Police in the UK were able to read a fingerprint from a photo of a hand:

Staff from the unit's specialist imaging team were able to enhance a picture of a hand holding a number of tablets, which was taken from a mobile phone, before fingerprint experts were able to positively identify that the hand was that of Elliott Morris.


Speaking about the pioneering techniques used in the case, Dave Thomas, forensic operations manager at the Scientific Support Unit, added: "Specialist staff within the JSIU fully utilised their expert image-enhancing skills which enabled them to provide something that the unit's fingerprint identification experts could work. Despite being provided with only a very small section of the fingerprint which was visible in the photograph, the team were able to successfully identify the individual."

Planet DebianSven Hoexter: logstash 5.6.9 logstash-input-udp 3.3.1 br0ken

While the memory leak is fixed in logstash 5.6.9 the logstash-input-udp plugin is broken. A fixed plugin got released as version 3.3.2.

The code change is

The discussion is at

So instead of fiddling again with plugin updates and offline bundles we decided to just go down the ugly road of abusing ansible, and install a file copy of the udp.rb file. This is horrible but works.

- name: check for br0ken logstash udp input plugin version
  shell: /usr/share/logstash/bin/logstash-plugin list --verbose logstash-input-udp | grep -E '3\.3\.1'
  register: logstash_udp_plugin_check
  ignore_errors: True
    - "skip_ansible_lint"

- name: install fixed udp input plugin
    src: "hacks/udp.rb"
    dest: "/usr/share/logstash/vendor/bundle/jruby/1.9/gems/logstash-input-udp-3.3.1/lib/logstash/inputs/udp.rb"
    owner: "root"
    group: "root"
    mode: 0644
  when: logstash_udp_plugin_check.rc == 0
  notify: restart logstash

Kudos to Martin and Paul for handling this one swiftly.

Worse Than FailureCodeSOD: A Problematic Place

In programming, sometimes the ordering of your data matters. And sometimes the ordering doesn’t matter and it can be completely random. And sometimes… well, El Dorko found a case where it apparently matters that it doesn’t matter:

DirectoryInfo di = new DirectoryInfo(directory);
FileInfo[] files = di.GetFiles();
DirectoryInfo[] subdirs = di.GetDirectories();

// shuffle subdirs to avoid problematic places
Random rnd = new Random();
for( int i = subdirs.Length - 1; i > 0; i-- )
    int n = rnd.Next( i + 1 );
    DirectoryInfo tmp = subdirs[i];
    subdirs[i] = subdirs[n];
    subdirs[n] = tmp;

foreach (DirectoryInfo dir in subdirs)
   // process files in directory

This code does some processing on a list of directories. Apparently while coding this, the author found themself in a “problematic place”. We all have our ways of avoiding problematic places, but this programmer decided the best way was to introduce some randomness into the equation. By randomizing the order of the list, they seem to have completely mitigated… well, it’s not entirely clear what they’ve mitigated. And while their choice of shuffling algorithm is commendable, maybe next time they could leave us a comment elaborating on the problematic place they found themself in.

[Advertisement] ProGet can centralize your organization's software applications and components to provide uniform access to developers and servers. Check it out!

Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: Art with condiments


Mr 15 just made me watch this video, its pretty awesome…

You’re welcome.


Planet DebianNorbert Preining: Analysing Debian packages with Neo4j – Part 2 UDD and Graph DB Schema

In the first part of this series of articles on analyzing Debian packages with Neo4j we gave a short introduction to Debian and the life time and structure of Debian packages.

The current second part first describes the Ultimate Debian Database UDD and how to map the information presented here from the UDD into a Graph Database by developing the database scheme, that is the set of nodes and relations, together with their attributes, from the inherent properties of Debian packages.

The next part will describe how to get the data from the UDD into Neo4j, give some sample queries, and discuss further work.

The Ultimate Debian Database UDD

The Ulimate Debian Database UDD

gathers a lot of data about various aspects of Debian in the same SQL database. It allows users to easily access and combine all these data.

Data currently being imported include: Packages and Sources files, from Debian and Ubuntu, Bugs from the Debian BTS, Popularity contest, History of uploads, History of migrations to testing, Lintian, Orphaned packages, Carnivore, Debtags, Ubuntu bugs (from Launchpad), Packages in NEW queue, DDTP translations.
Debian Wiki

Collection all these information and obviously having been grown over time, the database exhibits a highly de-normalized structure with ample duplication of the same information. As a consequence, reading the SQL code fetching data from the UDD and presenting them in a coherent interface tends to be highly convoluted.

This lets us to the project of putting (parts) of the UDD into a graph database, removing all the duplication on the way and representing the connections between the entities in a natural graph way.

Developing the database schema

Recall from the first column that there are source packages and binary packages in Debian, and that the same binary package can be built in different versions from different source packages. Thus we decided to have both source and binary packages as separate entities, that is nodes of the graph, and the two being connected via a binary relation builds.

Considering dependencies between Debian packages we recall the fact that there are versioned and unversioned dependencies. We thus decide to have again different entities for versioned source and binary packages, and unversioned source and binary packages.

The above considerations leads to the following sets of nodes and relations:

vsp -[:is_instance_of]-> sp
vbp -[:is_instance_of]-> bp
sp -[:builds]-> bp
vbp -[:next]-> vbp
vsp -[:next]-> vsp

where vsp stands for versioned source package, sp for (unversioned) source package, and analog for binary packages. The versioned variants carry besides the name attribute also a version attribute in the node.

The relations are is_instance_of between versioned and unversioned packages, builds between versioned source and versioned binary packages, and next that defines an order on the versions.

An example of a simple graph for the binary package luasseq which has was originally built from the source package luasseq but was then taken over into the TeX Live packages and built from a different source.

Next we want to register suites, that is associating which package has been included in which release of Debian. Thus we add a new node type suite and a new relation contains which connects suites and versioned binary packages vbp:

suite -[:contains]-> vbp

Nodes of type suite only contain one attribute name. We could add release dates etc, but refrained from it for now. Adding the suites to the above diagram we obtain the following:

Next we add maintainers. The new node type mnt has two attributes: name and email. Here it would be nice to add alternative email addresses as well as alternative spellings of the name, something that is quite common. We add a relation maintains to versioned source and binary packages only since, as we have seen, the maintainership can change over the history of a package:

mnt -[:maintains]-> vbp
mnt -[:maintains]-> vsp

This leads us to the following graph:

This concludes the first (easy) part with basic node types and relations. We now turn to the more complicated part to represent dependencies between packages in the graph.

Representing dependencies

For simple dependencies (versioned or unversioned, but no alternatives) we represent the dependency relation with two attributes reltype and relversion specifying the relation type (<<, <=, ==, >=, >>) and the version as string. For unversioned relations we use the reltype=none and relversion=1:

vbp -[:depends reltype: TYPE, relversion: VERS]-> bp

Adding all the dependencies to the above graph, we obtain the following graph:

Our last step is dealing with alternative dependencies. Recall from the first blog that a relation between two Debian packages can have alternative targets like in

Depends: musixtex (>= 1:0.98-1) | texlive-music
which means that either musixtex or texlive-music needs to be installed to satisfy this dependency.

We treat these kind of dependencies by introducing a new node type altdep and a new relation is_satisfied_by between altdep nodes and versioned or unversioned binary packages (vbp, bp).

The following slice of our graph shows binary packages pmx which has alternative dependencies as above:

Summary of nodes, relations, and attributes

Let us summarize the node types, relations types, and respective attributes we have deduced from the requirements and data in the Debian packages:

Nodes and attributes

  • mnt: name, email
  • bp, sp, suite, altdeps: name
  • vbp, vsp: name, version

Relations and attributes

  • breaks, build_conflicts, build_conflicts_indep, build_depends, build_depends_indep, conflicts, depends, enhances, is_satisfied_by, pre_depends, provides, recommends, replaces, suggests
    Attributes: reltype, relversion
  • builds, contains, is_instance_of, maintains, next: no attributes

Next is …

Now that we have the graph database schema set up, we need to pull data from the UDD and put them into the Graph database. This will be discussed in the next entry of this series.

Planet DebianHideki Yamane: Improve debootstrap time a bit, without local mirror

I've introduced two features to improve debootstrap time, auto proxy detection via squid-deb-proxy-client (by Michael Vogt) and cache directory support. It reduces time to create chroot environment without huge local mirror.

Let's create chroot environment without any new features.
$ time sudo debootstrap sid sid-chroot
I: Target architecture can be executed     
I: Retrieving InRelease                     
I: Checking Release signature           
I: Valid Release signature (key id 126C0D24BD8A2942CC7DF8AC7638D0442B90D010)
I: Retrieving Packages             
I: Validating Packages             
I: Base system installed successfully. 
real    8m27.624s
user    1m52.732s
sys     0m10.786s

Then, use --cache-dir option.
$ time sudo debootstrap --cache-dir=/home/henrich/tmp/cache sid sid-chroot
E: /home/henrich/tmp/cache: No such directory

Yes, we should cache directory first.
$ mkdir ~/tmp/cache
Let's go.
$ time sudo debootstrap --cache-dir=/home/henrich/tmp/cache sid sid-chroot
I: Target architecture can be executed
I: Retrieving InRelease             
I: Checking Release signature         
I: Valid Release signature (key id 126C0D24BD8A2942CC7DF8AC7638D0442B90D010)
I: Retrieving Packages                 
I: Validating Packages                   
I: Base system installed successfully. 
real    2m10.180s
user    1m47.428s
sys     0m8.196s
It cuts about 6 minutes! (of course, it depends on the mirror you choose). Then, try to use proxy feature.
$ sudo apt install squid-deb-proxy-client
$ time sudo debootstrap sid sid-chroot
Using auto-detected proxy:
I: Target architecture can be executed     
I: Retrieving InRelease                     
I: Checking Release signature           
I: Valid Release signature (key id 126C0D24BD8A2942CC7DF8AC7638D0442B90D010)
I: Retrieving Packages             
I: Validating Packages             
I: Configuring systemd...
I: Base system installed successfully.
Can you see the words "Using auto-detected proxy:"? It detects package proxy and use it. And its result is
real    2m15.995s
user    1m49.737s
sys     0m8.778s

Conclusion: If you already run squid-deb-proxy on some machine in local network, then install squid-deb-proxy-client and debootstrap automatically use it, or you can use --cache-dir option for speed up creating chroot environment via debootstrap. Especiall if you don't have good network conectivity, both features will help without effort.

Oh, and one more thing... Thomas Lange has proposed patches to improve debootstrap and it makes debootstrap much faster. If you're interested, please look into it.

Planet DebianSteve Kemp: A filesystem for known_hosts

The other day I had an idea that wouldn't go away, a filesystem that exported the contents of ~/.ssh/known_hosts.

I can't think of a single useful use for it, beyond simple shell-scripting, and yet I couldn't resist.

 $ go get -u
 $ go install

Now make it work:

 $ mkdir ~/knownfs
 $ knownfs ~/knownfs

Beneat out mount-point we can expect one directory for each known-host. So we'll see entries:

 ~/knownfs $ ls | grep \.vpn

 ~/knownfs $ ls | grep steve

The host-specified entries will each contain a single file fingerprint, with the fingerprint of the remote host:

 ~/knownfs $ cd
 ~/knownfs/ $ ls
 frodo ~/knownfs/ $ cat fingerprint

I've used it in a few shell-loops to run commands against hosts matching a pattern, but beyond that I'm struggling to think of a use for it.

If you like the idea I guess have a play:

It was perhaps more useful and productive than my other recent work - which involves porting an existing network-testing program from Ruby to golang, and in the process making it much more uniform and self-consistent.

The resulting network tester is pretty good, and can now notify via MQ to provide better decoupling too. The downside is of course that nobody changes network-testing solutions on a whim, and so these things are basically always in-house only.

Planet DebianShirish Agarwal: getting libleveldb1v5 fixed

Please treat this as a child’s fantasy till the information is not approved or corrected by a DD/DM who obviously have much more info and experience in dealing with below.

It had been quite a few years since I last played Minetest, a voxel-based game similar and yet different to its more famous brethren minecraft .

I wanted to install and play it but found that one of the libraries it needs is libleveldb1v5, a fast key-value storage library which according to #877773 has been marked as grave bug report because of no info. on the soname bump.

I saw that somebody had also reported it upstream and the bug has been fixed and has some more optimizations done to the library as well. From the description of the library it reminded me so much of sqlite which has almost the same feature-set (used by mozilla for bookmarks and pwd management if I’m not mistaken).

I was thinking as to if this has been fixed quite some back then why the maintainer didn’t put the fixed version on sid and then testing. I realized it might be because the new version has a soname bump which means it would need to be transitioned probably with proper breaks and everything.

A quick check via

$ apt-rdepends -r libleveldb1v5 | wc -l
Reading package lists... Done
Building dependency tree
Reading state information... Done

revealed that almost 190 packages directly or indirectly will be affected by the transition change. I then tried to find where the VCS is located by doing –

$ apt-cache showsrc libleveldb1v5 | grep Vcs-Git
Vcs-Git: git://
Vcs-Git: git://

Then I cloned the repo to my system to see if the maintainer had done any recent changes and saw :-

b$ git log --graph --pretty=format:'%Cred%h%Creset -%C(yellow)%d%Creset %s %Cgreen(%cr)' --abbrev-commit | head -15
* 7465515 - (HEAD -> master, tag: debian/1.20-2, origin/master, origin/HEAD) Packaging cleanup (4 months ago)
* f85b876 - Remove libleveldb-dbg package and use the auto-generated one (4 months ago)
* acac71f - Update Standards-Version to 4.1.2 (4 months ago)
* e281654 - Update debhelper level to 11 (4 months ago)
* df015eb - Don't run self-test parallel (4 months ago)
* ba81cc9 - (tag: debian/1.20-1) Update debhelper level to 10 (7 months ago)
* cb84f26 - Update Standards-Version to 4.1.0 (7 months ago)
* be0ef22 - Convert markdown documentation to HTML (7 months ago)
* ab8faa7 - Start 1.20-1 changelog (7 months ago)
* 03641f7 - Updated version 1.20 from 'upstream/1.20' (7 months ago)
| * 59c75ca - (tag: upstream/1.20, origin/upstream) New upstream version 1.20 (7 months ago)
* | a21bcbc - (tag: debian/1.19-2) Add the missing ReadMemoryBarrier and WriteMemoryBarrier functions for mips* (1 year, 5 months ago)
* | 70c6e38 - Add myself to debian/copyright (1 year, 5 months ago)
* | 1ba7231 - Update source URL (1 year, 5 months ago)

There is probably a much simpler way to get the same output but for now that would have to suffice.

Anyways, there are many variations of the code I used using git log --pretty and git log --decorate etc. Maybe one of those could give the same output, would need the time diff as shared above.

Trivia – I am usually more interested in commit messages and time when the commits are done and know a bit of git to find out the author of a particular commit even if abbreviated commit is there and want to thank her(im) for the work done on that package or a particular commit which address some annoying bug that I had. /Trivia

Although the best I have hankered for is to have some sort of visualization tool about projects that I like

something like Andrews plot or the C-Chart for visualization purposes but till date haven’t found anything which would render it into those visuals straightway. Maybe a feature for a future git version, who knows 🙂

I know that in itself is a Pandora’s box as some people might just like to have visualization of only when releases were made of an upstream project while there will be others like who would enjoy and be fascinated to see amount of time between each commit on a project. I have seen quite a few projects rise, wane and have a rise again but having such visualizations may possibly help out in getting people more involved with a project/library whatever.

Andrews plot example - Wikipedia - CC-0

All the commits for the said library are done by the maintainer Laszlo Boszormenyi so it seems that the maintainer is interested in maintaining it. At least all the last 10-12 messages going almost 1.5 years shows that he is/was active till at least 4 months back, which brings me to another one of my pet issues.

There aren’t any ways to figure out how recently a DD or DM committed on Debian somewhere. People usually try the MIA team (Missing in Action) and many a times you feel you are taking the team’s time especially when it turns out to be a false positive. If users had more tools than probably MIA’s workload would be much lesser than before.

The only the other way is to look at all the packages a particular DD/DM is maintaining and if you are lucky then s(he) has made a release of a package or something that you can look into and know for certain that the person is active.

The other longer way is to download all the VCS repositories of a DD/DM, cycle through all of them using something like above to see when was the last commit done on all her(is) repos. and then come to conclusion one way or the other. If s(he) is really MIA then tell them to MIA team so they can try to connect with the person concerned, and if s(he) doesn’t respond in a reasonable time-frame then orphan the packages.

If a DD/DM has not committed for more than a year or two for any of her(is) projects I guess it’s reasonable to expect that the person concerned is MIA.

Anyways, it would be nice if the present maintainer is able to get the new release out so the other 190 packages which are probably installable could also work. When I was churning this on my head, I thought why couldn’t the DD’s have some sort of CI infrastructure which may automate things a bit and make life somewhat easier.

I have seen the Debian travis ci instance but know that’s limited to upstream projects hosted on github.

For those who might not know Travis CI is one of many such solutions. They are continuous integration software and they are quite a few of them.

What they do is they try to build the project/application/library etc. after each and every commit taking into account any parameters told/programmed into it. There may be times when upstream make an incompatible change or make some mistake while committing, because it’s autobuilds the application or whatever automatically, if it fails to build it forces the developer to see where they messed up. At the end you have a slightly better application at the end as at least obvious bugs are ironed out.

I do remember reading about gitlab-ci somewhere, maybe in the thread where DD’s were discussing about various alternatives to alioth or somewhere else. I dunno if would be just a matter of turning it on or that part is still not open-sourced yet, no idea.

If that happens, it would probably save the DD’s/DM some computational time apart from being able to know if things are going well or not.

I know gitlab had shared (paraphrasing here) they may make some of the things more open-source if Debian were to adopt the product, now that Debian has, I and guess most of the community would be hoping as lot of hard work, tears have gone into getting things ported from alioth to salsa especially in the last one month or so.

I do know that we have the autobuilder network but from what I understand, it’s for a slightly different use-case. This is more to see if the package builds on all the 10-11 official architectures and maybe some of the unofficial architectures.

While I was reading it, I was unable to find if just like people all around the world are doing mirrors (full or partial depending on the resources they have and the kind of pickup they are seeing) can people be part of autobuilder network to give additional computational power to the network. The name does say ‘autobuilder network’ so maybe that possibility exists, maybe it does not.

I did consult the documentation on the topic and it seems it’s a bit of work, see the workflow shared in wiki for transitions.

After reading that, you really wonder the patience of the people who slog through all this.

I did try to connect with him on the bug mentioned but he hasn’t got back, perhaps he’s busy IRL.

Till later.

Note – I have not talked about */debian/control or */debian/changelog.Debian, */debian/changelog or any of the files because once those are made, they are probably just need to be fiddled around a bit. The control file will probably list newer version of dependencies and may or may not have newer build dependencies. Changelog.Debian would document the changes the DD/DM had to do in order for the binary to be built successfully and in the archive and changelog will just document the time till where upstream’s work was taken.


Planet DebianVincent Bernat: Self-hosted videos with HLS


This article was first published on Exoscale blog with some minor modifications.

Hosting videos on YouTube is convenient for several reasons: pretty good player, free bandwidth, mobile-friendly, network effect and, at your discretion, no ads.1 On the other hand, this is one of the less privacy-friendly solution. Most other providers share the same characteristics—except the ability to disable ads for free.

With the <video> tag, self-hosting a video is simple:2

<video controls>
  <source src="../videos/big_buck_bunny.webm" type="video/webm">
  <source src="../videos/big_buck_bunny.mp4" type="video/mp4">

However, while it is possible to provide a different videos depending on the screen width, adapting the video to the available bandwidth is trickier. There are two solutions:

They are both adaptive bitrate streaming protocols: the video is sliced in small segments and made available at a variety of different bitrates. Depending on current network conditions, the player automatically selects the appropriate bitrate to download the next segment.

HLS was initially implemented by Apple but is now also supported natively by Microsoft Edge and Chrome on Android. hls.js is a JavaScript library bringing HLS support to other browsers. MPEG-DASH is technically superior (codec-agnostic) but only works through a JavaScript library, like dash.js. In both cases, support of the Media Source Extensions is needed when native support is absent. Safari on iOS doesn’t have this feature and cannot use MPEG-DASH. Consequently, the most compatible solution is currently HLS.


To serve HLS videos, you need three kinds of files:

  • the media segments (encoded with different bitrates/resolutions),
  • a media playlist for each variant, listing the media segments, and
  • a master playlist, listing the media playlists.

Media segments can come in two formats:

  • MPEG-2 Transport Streams (TS), or
  • Fragmented MP4.

Fragmented MP4 media segments are supported since iOS 10. They are a bit more efficient and can be reused to serve the same content as MPEG-DASH (only the playlists are different). Also, they can be served from the same file with range requests. However, if you want to target older versions of iOS, you need to stick with MPEG-2 TS.3

FFmpeg is able to convert a video to media segments and generate the associated media playlists. Peer5’s documentation explains the suitable commands. I have put together an handy (Python 3.6) script, video2hls, stitching together all the steps. After executing it on your target video, you get a directory containing:

  • media segments for each resolution (1080p_1_001.ts, 720p_2_001.ts, …)
  • media playlists for each resolution (1080p_1.m3u8, 720p_2.m3u8, …)
  • master playlist (index.m3u8)
  • progressive (streamable) MP4 version of your video (progressive.mp4)
  • poster (poster.jpg)

The script accepts a lot of options for customization. Use the --help flag to discover them. Run it with --debug to get the ffmpeg commands executed with an explanation for each flag. For example, the poster is built with this command:

ffmpeg \
  `# seek to the given position (5%)` \
   -ss 4 \
  `# load input file` \
   -i ../2018-self-hosted-videos.mp4 \
  `# take only one frame` \
   -frames:v 1 \
  `# filter to select an I-frame and scale` \
   -vf 'select=eq(pict_type\,I),scale=1280:720' \
  `# request a JPEG quality ~ 10` \
   -qscale:v 28 \
  `# output file` \


So, we got a bunch of static files we can upload anywhere. Yet two details are important:

  • When serving from another domain, CORS needs to be configured to allow GET requests. Adding Access-Control-Allow-Origin: * to response headers is enough.4
  • Some clients may be picky about the MIME types. Ensure files are served with the ones in the table below.
Kind Extension MIME type
Playlists .m3u8 application/
MPEG2-TS segments .ts video/mp2t
fMP4 segments .mp4 video/mp4
Progressive MP4 .mp4 video/mp4
Poster .jpg image/jpeg

Let’s host our files on Exoscale’s Object Storage which is compatible with S3 and located in Switzerland. As an example, the Caminandes 3: Llamigos video is about 213 MiB (five sizes for HLS and one progressive MP4). It would cost us less than 0.01 € per month for storage and 1.42 € for bandwidth if 1000 people watch the 1080p version from beginning to end—unlikely.5

We use s3cmd to upload files. First, you need to recover your API credentials from the portal and put them in ~/.s3cfg:

host_base =
host_bucket = %(bucket)
access_key = EXO.....
secret_key = ....
use_https = True
bucket_location = ch-dk-2

The second step is to create a bucket:

$ s3cmd mb s3://hls-videos
Bucket 's3://hls-videos/' created

You need to configure the CORS policy for this bucket. First, define the policy in a cors.xml file (you may want to restrict the allowed origin):


Then, apply it to the bucket:

$ s3cmd setcors cors.xml s3://hls-videos

The last step is to copy the static files. Playlists are served compressed to save a bit of bandwidth. For each video, inside the directory containing all the generated files, use the following command:

while read extension mime gz; do
  [ -z "$gz" ] || {
    # gzip compression (if not already done)
    for f in *.${extension}; do
      ! gunzip -t $f 2> /dev/null || continue
      gzip $f
      mv $f.gz $f
  s3cmd --no-preserve -F -P \
        ${gz:+--add-header=Content-Encoding:gzip} \
        --mime-type=${mime} \
        --encoding=UTF-8 \
        --exclude=* --include=*.${extension} \
        --delete-removed \
    sync . s3://hls-videos/video1/
done <<EOF
m3u8  application/ true
jpg   image/jpeg
mp4   video/mp4
ts    video/mp2t

The files are now available at


We can insert our video in a document with the following markup:

<video poster=""
       controls preload="none">
  <source src=""
  <source src=""
          type='video/mp4; codecs="avc1.4d401f, mp4a.40.2"'>

Browsers with native support use the HLS version while others would fall back to the progressive MP4 version. However, with the help of hls.js, we can ensure most browsers benefit from the HLS version too:

<script src=""></script>
    if(Hls.isSupported()) {
        var selector = "video source[type='application/']",
            videoSources = document.querySelectorAll(selector);
        videoSources.forEach(function(videoSource) {
            var once = false;

            // Clone the video to remove any source
            var oldVideo = videoSource.parentNode,
                newVideo = oldVideo.cloneNode(false);

            // Replace video tag with our clone.
            oldVideo.parentNode.replaceChild(newVideo, oldVideo);

            // On play, initialize hls.js, once.
            newVideo.addEventListener('play',function() {
                if (!once) return;
                once = true;

                var hls = new Hls({ capLevelToPlayerSize: true });
                hls.on(Hls.Events.MANIFEST_PARSED, function() {
            }, false);

Here is the result, featuring Caminandes 3: Llamigos, a video created by Pablo Vasquez, produced by the Blender Foundation and released under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 license:

Most JavaScript attributes, methods and events work just like with a plain <video> element. For example, you can seek to an arbitrary position, like 1:00 or 2:00—but you would need to enable JavaScript to test.

The player is different from one browser to another but provides the basic needs. You can upgrade to a more advanced player, like video.js or MediaElements.js. They also handle HLS videos through hls.js.

Hosting your videos on YouTube is not unavoidable: serving them yourself while offering quality delivery is technically affordable. If bandwidth requirements are modest and the network effect not important, self-hosting makes it possible to regain control of the published content and not to turn over readers to Google. In the same spirit, PeerTube offers a video sharing platform. Decentralized and federated, it relies on BitTorrent to reduce bandwidth requirements.



In the above example, preload="none" was used for two reasons:

  • Most readers won’t play the video as it is an addon to the main content. Therefore, bandwidth is not wasted by downloading a few segments of video, at the expense of slightly increased latency on play.
  • We do not want non-native HLS clients to start downloading the non-HLS version while hls.js is loading and taking over the video. This could also be done by declaring the progressive MP4 fallback from JavaScript, but this would make the video unplayable for users without JavaScript. If preloading is important, you can remove the preload attribute from JavaScript—and not wait for the play event to initialize hls.js.


Setting up CSP correctly can be quite a pain. For browsers with native HLS support, you need the following policy, in addition to your existing policy:

  • image-src for the posters,
  • media-src for the playlists and media segments.

With hls.js, things are more complex. Ideally, the following policy should also be applied:

  • worker-src blob: for the transmuxing web worker,
  • media-src blob: for the transmuxed segments,
  • connect-src to fetch playlists and media segments from JavaScript.

However, worker-src is quite recent. The expected fallbacks are child-src (deprecated), script-src (but not everywhere) and then default-src. Therefore, for broader compatibility, you also need to append blob: to default-src as well as to script-src and child-src if you already have them. Here is an example policy—assuming the original policy was just default-src 'self' and media, XHR and workers were not needed:

HTTP/1.0 200 OK
  default-src 'self' blob:;
  image-src 'self';
  media-src blob:;
  worker-src blob:;

  1. YouTube gives you the choice to not display ads on your videos. In advanced settings, you can unselect “Allow advertisements to be displayed alongside my videos.” Alternatively, you can also monetize your videos. ↩︎

  2. Nowadays, everything supports MP4/H.264. It usually also brings hardware acceleration, which improves battery life on mobile devices. WebM/VP9 provides a better quality at the same bitrate. ↩︎

  3. You could generate both formats and use them as variants in the master playlist. However, a limitation in hls.js prevents this option. ↩︎

  4. Use instead of the wildcard character to restrict access to your own domain. ↩︎

  5. There is no need to host those files behind a (costly) CDN. Latency doesn’t matter much as long as you can sustain the appropriate bandwidth. ↩︎

Planet DebianChris Lamb: Re-elected as Debian Project Leader

I have been extremely proud to have served as the Debian Project Leader since my election in early 2017. During this time I've learned a great deal about the inner workings of the Project as well as about myself. I have grown as a person thanks to all manner of new interactions and fresh experiences.

I believe is a privilege simply to be a Debian Developer, let alone to be selected as their representative. It was therefore an even greater honour to learn that I have been re-elected by the community for another year. I profoundly and wholeheartedly thank everyone for placing their trust in me for another term.

Being the "DPL" is a hard job. It is even difficult to even communicate exactly how and any statistics somehow fail to capture it. However, I now understand the look in previous Leaders' eyes when they congratulated me on my appointment and future candidates should not nominate themselves lightly.

Indeed, I was unsure whether I would stand for re-appointment and I might not have done had it not been for some touching and encouraging words from some close confidants. They underlined to me that a year is not a long time, further counselling that I should consider myself just getting started and only now prepared to start to take on the bigger picture.

Debian itself will always face challenges but I sincerely believe that the Project remains as healthy as ever. We are uniquely cherished and remain remarkably poised to improve the free software ecosystem as a whole. Moreover, our stellar reputation for technical excellence, stability and software freedom remains highly respected and without peer. It is truly an achievement to be proud of.

I thank everyone who had the original confidence, belief and faith in me, but I offer my further sincere and humble thanks to all those who have felt they could extend this to a second term, especially with such a high turnout. I am truly excited and looking forward to the year ahead.

Sociological ImagesThe Sociology Behind the X-Files

Originally Posted at TSP Clippings

Photo Credit: Val Astraverkhau, Flickr CC

Throughout history, human beings have been enthralled by the idea of the paranormal. While we might think that UFOs and ghosts belong to a distant and obscure dimension, social circumstances help to shape how we envision the supernatural. In a recent interview with New York Magazine, sociologist Joseph O. Baker describes the social aspects of Americans’ beliefs about UFOs.

Baker argues that pop culture shapes our understandings of aliens. In the 1950s and 1960s, pop culture imagined aliens in humanoid form, typically as very attractive Swedish blonde types with shining eyes. By the 1970s and 1980s, the abductor narrative took hold and extraterrestrials were represented as the now iconic image of the little gray abductor — small, grey-skinned life-forms with huge hairless heads and large black eyes. Baker posits that one of the main causes of UFOs’ heightened popularity during this time was the extreme distrust of the government following incidents such as Watergate. Baker elaborates,

“I think there is something to be said for a lack of faith in government and institutions in that era, and that coincided with UFOs’ rise in popularity. The lack of trust in the government, and the idea that the government knows something about this — those two things went together, and you can see it in the public reaction post-Vietnam, to Watergate, all that stuff.”

While the individual characteristics of “believers” are hard to determine, survey evidence suggests that men and people from low-income backgrounds are more likely to believe in the existence of alien life. Baker says that believing is also dependent upon religious participation rather than education or income. In his words,

“One of the other strongest predictors is not participating as strongly in forms of organized religion. In some sense, there’s a bit of a clue there about what’s going on with belief — it’s providing an alternative belief system. If you look at religious-service attendance, there will be a strong negative effect there for belief in UFOs.”

Baker’s research on the paranormal indicates that social circumstances influence belief in extraterrestrial beings. In short, these social factors help to shape whether you are a Mulder or a Scully. Believing in UFOs goes beyond abductions and encounters of the Third Kind. In the absence of trust in government and religious institutions, UFOs represent an appealing and mysterious alternative belief system.

Isabel Arriagada (@arriagadaisabeis a Ph.D. student in the sociology department at the University of Minnesota. Her research focuses on the development of prison policies in South America and the U.S. and how technology shapes new experiences of imprisonment. 

(View original at

Planet DebianSven Hoexter: logstash 5.6.9 released with logstash-filter-grok 4.0.3

In case you're using logstash 5.6.x from elastic, version 5.6.9 is released with logstash-filter-grok 4.0.3. This one fixes a bad memory leak that was a cause for frequent logstash crashes since logstash 5.5.6. Reference:

I hope this is now again a decent logstash 5.x release. I've heard some rumours that the 6.x versions is also a bit plagued by memory leaks. :-/

Krebs on SecurityA Sobering Look at Fake Online Reviews

In 2016, KrebsOnSecurity exposed a network of phony Web sites and fake online reviews that funneled those seeking help for drug and alcohol addiction toward rehab centers that were secretly affiliated with the Church of Scientology. Not long after the story ran, that network of bogus reviews disappeared from the Web. Over the past few months, however, the same prolific purveyor of these phantom sites and reviews appears to be back at it again, enlisting the help of Internet users and paying people $25-$35 for each fake listing.

Sometime in March 2018, ads began appearing on Craigslist promoting part-time “social media assistant” jobs, in which interested applicants are directed to sign up for positions at seorehabs[dot]com. This site promotes itself as “leaders in addiction recovery consulting,” explaining that assistants can earn a minimum of $25 just for creating individual Google for Business listings tied to a few dozen generic-sounding addiction recovery center names, such as “Integra Addiction Center,” and “First Exit Recovery.”

The listing on advertising jobs for creating fake online businesses tied to addiction rehabilitation centers.

Applicants who sign up are given detailed instructions on how to step through Google’s anti-abuse process for creating listings, which include receiving a postcard via snail mail from Google that contains a PIN which needs to be entered at Google’s site before a listing can be created.

Assistants are cautioned not to create more than two listings per street address, but otherwise to use any U.S.-based street address and to leave blank the phone number and Web site for the new business listing.

A screen shot from Seorehabs’ instructions for those hired to create rehab center listings.

In my story Scientology Seeks Captive Converts Via Google Maps, Drug Rehab Centers, I showed how a labyrinthine network of fake online reviews that steered Internet searches toward rehab centers funded by Scientology adherents was set up by TopSeek Inc., which bills itself as a collection of “local marketing experts.” According to LinkedIn, TopSeek is owned by John Harvey, an individual (or alias) who lists his address variously as Sacramento, Calif. and Hawaii.

Although the current Web site registration records from registrar giant Godaddy obscure the information for the current owner of seorehabs[dot]com, a historic WHOIS search via DomainTools shows the site was also registered by John Harvey and TopSeek in 2015. Mr. Harvey did not respond to requests for comment. [Full disclosure: DomainTools previously was an advertiser on KrebsOnSecurity].

TopSeek’s Web site says it works with several clients, but most especially Narconon International — an organization that promotes the rather unorthodox theories of Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard regarding substance abuse treatment and addiction.

As described in Narconon’s Wikipedia entry, Narconon facilities are known not only for attempting to win over new converts to Scientology, but also for treating all substance abuse addictions with a rather bizarre cocktail consisting mainly of vitamins and long hours in extremely hot saunas. Their Wiki entry documents multiple cases of accidental deaths at Narconon facilities, where some addicts reportedly died from overdoses of vitamins or neglect.


Bryan Seely, a security expert who has written extensively about the use of fake search listings to conduct online bait-and-switch scams, said the purpose of sites like those that Seorehabs pays people to create is to funnel calls to a handful of switchboards that then sell the leads to rehab centers that have agreed to pay for them. Many rehab facilities will pay hundreds of dollars for leads that may ultimately lead to a new patient. After all, Seely said, some facilities can then turn around and bill insurance providers for thousands of dollars per patient.

Perhaps best known for a stunt in which he used fake Google Maps listings to intercept calls destined for the FBI and U.S. Secret Service, Seely has learned a thing or two about this industry: Until 2011, he worked for an SEO firm that helped to develop and spread some of the same fake online reviews that he is now helping to clean up.

“Mr. Harvey and TopSeek are crowdsourcing the data input for these fake rehab centers,” Seely said. “The phone numbers all go to just a few dedicated call centers, and it’s not hard to see why. The money is good in this game. He sells a call for $50-$100 at a minimum, and the call center then tries to sell that lead to a treatment facility that has agreed to buy leads. Each lead can be worth $5,000 to $10,000 for a patient who has good health insurance and signs up.”

This graph illustrates what happens when someone calls one of these Seorehabs listings. Source: Bryan Seely.

Many of the listings created by Seorehab assistants are tied to fake Google Maps entries that include phony reviews for bogus treatment centers. In the event those listings get suspended by Google, Seorehab offers detailed instructions on how assistants can delete and re-submit listings.

Assistants also can earn extra money writing fake, glowing reviews of the treatment centers:

Below are some of the plainly bogus reviews and listings created in the last month that pimp the various treatment center names and Web sites provided by Seorehabs. It is not difficult to find dozens of other examples of people who claim to have been at multiple Seorehab-promoted centers scattered across the country. For example, “Gloria Gonzalez” supposedly has been treated at no fewer than seven Seorehab-marketed detox locations in five states, penning each review just in the last month:

A reviewer using the name “Tedi Spicer” also promoted at least seven separate rehab centers across the United States in the past month. Getting treated at so many far-flung facilities in just the few months that the domains for these supposed rehab centers have been online would be an impressive feat:

Bring up any of the Web sites for these supposed rehab listings and you’ll notice they all include the same boilerplate text and graphic design. Aside from combing listings created by the reviewers paid to promote the sites, we can find other Seorehab listings just by searching the Web for chunks of text on the sites. Doing so reveals a long list (this is likely far from comprehensive) of domain names registered in the past few months that were all created with hidden registration details and registered via Godaddy.

Seely said he spent a few hours this week calling dozens of phone numbers tied to these rehab centers promoted by TopSeek, and created a spreadsheet documenting his work and results here (Google Sheets).

Seely said while he would never advocate such activity, TopSeek’s fake listings could end up costing Mr. Harvey plenty of money if someone figured out a way to either mass-report the listings as fraudulent or automate calls to the handful of hotlines tied to the listings.

“It would kill his business until he changes all the phone numbers tied to these fake listings, but if he had to do that he’d have to pay people to rebuild all the directories that link to these sites,” he said.


Before doing business with a company you found online, don’t just pick the company that comes up at the top of search results on Google or any other search engine. Unfortunately, that generally guarantees little more than the company is good at marketing.

Take the time to research the companies you wish to hire before booking them for jobs or services — especially when it comes to big, expensive, and potentially risky services like drug rehab or moving companies. By the way, if you’re looking for a legitimate rehab facility, you could do worse than to start at, a legitimate rehab search engine.

It’s a good idea to get in the habit of verifying that the organization’s physical address, phone number and Web address shown in the search result match that of the landing page. If the phone numbers are different, use the contact number listed on the linked site.

Take the time to learn about the organization’s reputation online and in social media; if it has none (other than a Google Maps listing with all glowing, 5-star reviews), it’s probably fake. Search the Web for any public records tied to the business’ listed physical address, including articles of incorporation from the local secretary of state office online.

A search of the company’s domain name registration records can give you an idea of how long its Web site has been in business, as well as additional details about the the organization (although the ability to do this may soon be a thing of the past).

Seely said one surefire way to avoid these marketing shell games is to ask a simple question of the person who answers the phone in the online listing.

“Ask anyone on the phone what company they’re with,” Seely said. “Have them tell you, take their information and then call them back. If they aren’t forthcoming about who they are, they’re most likely a scam.”

In 2016, Seely published a book on Amazon about the thriving and insanely lucrative underground business of fake online reviews. He’s agreed to let KrebsOnSecurity republish the entire e-book, which is available for free at this link (PDF).

“This is literally the worst book ever written about Google Maps fraud,” Seely said. “It’s also the best. Is it still a niche if I’m the only one here? The more people who read it, the better.”

Planet DebianJonathan Dowland: simple

Every now and then, for one reason or another, I am sat in front of a Linux-powered computer with the graphical user interface disabled, instead using an old-school text-only mode.

shell prompt

There's a strange, peaceful quality about these environments.

When I first started using computers in the 90s, the Text Mode was the inferior, non-multitasking system that you generally avoided unless you were trying to do something specific (like run Doom without any other programs eating up your RAM).

On a modern Linux (or BSD) machine, unless you are specifically trying to do something graphical, the power and utility of the machine is hardly diminished at all in this mode. The surface looks calm: there's nothing much visibly going on, just the steady blink of the command prompt, as if the whole machine is completely dedicated to you, and is waiting poised to do whatever you ask of it next. Yet most of the same background tasks are running as normal, doing whatever they do.

One difference, however, is the distractions. Rather like when you drive out of a city to the countryside and suddenly notice the absence of background noise, background light, etc., working at a text terminal — relative to a regular graphical desktop — can be a very calming experience.

So I decided to take a fresh look at my desktop and see whether there were unwelcome distractions. For some time now I've been using a flat background colour to avoid visual clutter. After some thought I realised that most of the time I didn't need to see what was in GNOME3's taskbar. I found and installed this hide-top-bar extension and now it's tucked away unless I mouse up to the top. Now that it's out of the way by default, I actually put more information into it: the full date in the time display; and (via another extension, TopIcons Plus) the various noisy icons that apps like Dropbox, OpenBox, VLC, etc. provide.

GNOME 3 Desktop

There's still some work to do, notably in my browser (Firefox), but I think this is a good start.

TEDWhat can your phone do in the next mobile economy? A workshop with Samsung

An attendee plays with an interface for exploring the possibilities of the mobile phone at the Samsung Social Space during TED2018: The Age of Amazement, in Vancouver. Photo: Lawrence Sumulong / TED

What do you imagine your phone doing for you in the future? Sure, you can take calls, send texts, use apps and surf the internet. But according to Samsung, the next corner for mobile engagement could turn your cell phone into a superhero (of sorts) in industries like public safety and healthcare. 5G technology will not only improve a company’s ability to deliver faster, higher quality services, but the “greater connectivity paves the way for data-intensive solutions like self-driving vehicles, Hi-Res streaming VR, and rich real-time communications.” Imagine a world where your Facetime or Skype call doesn’t drop mid-conversation, you never have to wait for a video to buffer, and connecting to Wi-Fi becomes the slower option compared to staying on data.

At their afternoon worksop during TED2018, Samsung provided a short list of real-world issues to guide thoughtful discussion among workshop groups on how the mobile economy can be a part of the big solutions. Scenarios included: data security in the an evolving retail world; hurricane preparedness; urban traffic management; and overburdened emergency rooms.

These breakout out sessions lead to fascinating conversation between those with different perspectives, background and skill sets. Architects and scientists weighed in with writers and business development professionals to dream up a vision of the future where everything works seamlessly and interacts like a well-conducted symphony.

After intense discussion, swapping ideas and possibilities, groups were encouraged to synthesize the conversation and share to the larger room. They didn’t just offer solutions, but posed fascinating questions on how we may unlock answers to the endless possibilities the next mobile economy will bring in the age of amazement.

A view of Samsung’s social space at TED2018, which featured mobile phone activities for exploring the next mobile economy (as well as delicious coffee). Photo: Lawrence Sumulong / TED

CryptogramOblivious DNS

Interesting idea:

...we present Oblivious DNS (ODNS), which is a new design of the DNS ecosystem that allows current DNS servers to remain unchanged and increases privacy for data in motion and at rest. In the ODNS system, both the client is modified with a local resolver, and there is a new authoritative name server for .odns. To prevent an eavesdropper from learning information, the DNS query must be encrypted; the client generates a request for, generates a session key k, encrypts the requested domain, and appends the TLD domain .odns, resulting in {}k.odns. The client forwards this, with the session key encrypted under the .odns authoritative server's public key ({k}PK) in the "Additional Information" record of the DNS query to the recursive resolver, which then forwards it to the authoritative name server for .odns. The authoritative server decrypts the session key with his private key, and then subsequently decrypts the requested domain with the session key. The authoritative server then forwards the DNS request to the appropriate name server, acting as a recursive resolver. While the name servers see incoming DNS requests, they do not know which clients they are coming from; additionally, an eavesdropper cannot connect a client with her corresponding DNS queries.

News article.

Worse Than FailureThe Proprietary Format

Have you ever secured something with a lock? The intent is that at some point in the future, you'll use the requisite key to regain access to it. Of course, the underlying assumption is that you actually have the key. How do you open a lock once you've lost the key? That's when you need to get creative. Lock picks. Bolt cutters. Blow torch. GAU-8...

In 2004, Ben S. went on a solo bicycle tour, and for reasons of weight, his only computer was a Handspring Visor Deluxe PDA running Palm OS. He had an external, folding keyboard that he would use to type his notes from each day of the trip. To keep these notes organized by day, he stored them in the Datebook (calendar) app as all-day events. The PDA would sync with a desktop computer using a Handspring-branded fork of the Palm Desktop software. The whole Datebook could then be exported as a text file from there. As such, Ben figured his notes were safe. After the trip ended, he bought a Windows PC that he had until 2010, but he never quite got around to exporting the text file. After he switched to using a Mac, he copied the files to the Mac and gave away the PC.

Handspring Treo 90

Ten years later, he decided to go through all of the old notes, but he couldn't open the files!

Uh oh.

The Handspring company had gone out of business, and the software wouldn't run on the Mac. His parents had the Palm-branded version of the software on one of their older Macs, but Handspring used a different data file format that the Palm software couldn't open. His in-laws had an old Windows PC, and he was able to install the Handspring software, but it wouldn't even open without a physical device to sync with, so the file just couldn't be opened. Ben reluctantly gave up on ever accessing the notes again.

Have you ever looked at something and then turned your head sideways, only to see it in a whole new light?

One day, Ben was going through some old clutter and found a backup DVD-R he had made of the Windows PC before he had wiped its hard disk. He found the datebook.dat file and opened it in SublimeText. There he saw rows and rows of hexadecimal code arranged into tidy columns. However, in this case, the columns between the codes were not just on-screen formatting for readability, they were actual space characters! It was not a data file after all, it was a text file.

The Handspring data file format was a text file containing hexadecimal code with spaces in it! He copied and pasted the entire file into an online hex-to-text converter (which ignored the spaces and line breaks), and voilà , Ben had his notes back!

[Advertisement] Forget logs. Next time you're struggling to replicate error, crash and performance issues in your apps - Think Raygun! Installs in minutes. Learn more.

Planet DebianLaura Arjona Reina: Kubb 2018 season has just begun

Since last year I play kubb with my son. It’s a sport/game of marksmanship and patience. It’s a quite inclusive game and it’s played outside, in a grass or sand field.

It happens that the Spanish association of Kubb is in the town where I live (even, in my neighbourhood!) so several family gatherings with tournaments happen in the parks near my house. Last year we attended for first time and learned how to play, and since then, we participated in 2 or 3 events more.

As kubb is played in open air, season starts in March/April, when the weather is good enough to have a nice morning in the park. I got surprised that being a so minority game, about 50-100 people gather in each local tournament, grouped in teams of any kind: individuals, couples or up to 6 persons-teams, mothers and daughters, only kids-teams, teams formed by people of 3 different generations… as strenght or speed (or even experience) are not relevant to win this game, almost anybody can play with anybody.


Enjoying playing kubb makes me also think about how communities around a non-mainstream topic are formed and maintained, and how to foster diversity and good relationships among participants. I’ve noted down some ideas that I think the kubb association does well:

  •  No matter how big or small you are, always take into account the possible newcomers: setting a slot at the start of the event to welcome them and explain “how the day will work” makes those newcomers feel less stressed.
  • Designing events where the whole family can participate (or at least “be together”, not only “events with childcare”) but it’s not mandatory that all of them participate, helps people to get involved more long-term.
  • The format of the event has to be kept simple to avoid organisers to get burned out. If the organisers are so overwhelmed taking care of things that they cannot taste the result of their work, that means that the organisation team should grow and balance the load.
  • Having a “break” during the year so everybody can rest and do other things also helps people get more motivated when the next season/event starts.

Thinking about kubb, particularly together/versus with the other sport that my kid plays (football), I find similarities and contrasts with another “couple” of activities that we also experience in our family: the “free software way of life” versus the “mainstream use” of computers/devices nowadays. It’s good to know both (not to be “apart of the world in our warm bubble”), and it’s good to have the humble, but creative and more human-focused and good-values-loaded one as big reference for the type of future that we want to live and we build everyday with our small actions.


You can comment on this post using this thread.

Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: City2Surf 2018


I registered for city2surf this morning, which will be the third time I’ve run in the event. In 2016 my employer sponsored a bunch of us to enter, and I ran the course in 86 minutes and 54 seconds. 2017 was a bit more exciting, because in hindsight I did the final part of my training and the race itself with a torn achilles tendon. Regardless, I finished the course in 79 minutes and 39 seconds — a 7 minute and 16 second improvement despite the injury.

This year I’ve done a few things differently — I’ve started training much earlier, mostly as a side effect to recovering from the achilles injury; and secondly I’ve decided to try and raise some money for charity during the run.

Specifically, I’m raising money for the Black Dog Institute. They were selected because I’ve struggled with depression on and off over my adult life, and that’s especially true for the last twelve months or so. I figure that raising money for a resource that I’ve found personally useful makes a lot of sense.

I’d love for you to donate to the Black Dog Institute, but I understand that’s not always possible. Either way, thanks for reading this far!


Planet DebianNorbert Preining: TeX Live 2018 for Debian

TeX Live 2018 has hit Debian/unstable today. The packages are based on what will be (most likely, baring any late desasters) on the TeX Live DVD which is going to press this week. This brings the newest and shiniest version of TeX Live to Debian. There have

The packages that have been uploaded are:

The changes listed in the TeX Live documentation and which are relevant for Debian are:

  • Kpathsea: Case-insensitive filename matching now done by default in non-system directories; set texmf.cnf or environment variable texmf_casefold_search to 0 to disable. Full details in the Kpathsea manual.
  • epTEX, eupTEX: New primitive \epTeXversion.
  • LuaTEX: Preparation for moving to Lua 5.3 in 2019: a binary luatex53 is available on most platforms, but must be renamed to luatex to be effective. Or use the ConTEXt Garden files; more information there.
  • MetaPost: Fixes for wrong path directions, TFM and PNG output.
  • pdfTEX: Allow encoding vectors for bitmap fonts; current directory not hashed into PDF ID; bug fixes for \pdfprimitive and related.
  • XeTEX: Support /Rotate in PDF image inclusion; exit nonzero if the output driver fails; various obscure UTF-8 and other primitive fixes.
  • tlmgr: new front-ends tlshell (Tcl/Tk) and tlcockpit (Java); JSON output; uninstall now a synonym for remove; new action/option print-platform-info.

And above all, the most important change: We switched to CMSS, a font designed by DEK, for our logo and banners 😉



Planet Linux AustraliaDavid Rowe: Lithium Cell Amp Hour Tester and Electric Sailing

I recently electrocuted my little sail boat. I built the battery pack using some second hand Lithium cells donated by my EV. However after 8 years of abuse from my kids and I those cells are of varying quality. So I set about developing an Amp-Hour tester to determine the capacity of the cells.

The system has a relay that switches a low value power resistor (OK some coat hanger wire) across the 3.2V cell terminals, loading it up at about 27A, roughly the cruise current for my e-boat. It’s about 0.12 ohms once it heats up. This gets too hot to touch but not red hot, it’s only 86W being dissipated along about 1m of wire. When I built my EV I used the coat hanger wire load trick to test 3kW loads, that was a bit more exciting!

The empty beer can in the background makes a useful insulated stand off. Might need to make more of those.

When I first installed Lithium cells in my EV I developed a charge controller for my EV. I borrowed a small part of that circuit; a two transistor flip flop and a Battery Management System (BMS) module:

Across the cell under test is a CM090 BMS module from EV Power. That’s the good looking red PCB in the photos, onto which I have tacked the circuit above. These modules have a switch than opens when the cell voltage drops beneath 2.5V.

Taking the base of either transistor to ground switches on the other transistor. In logic terms, it’s a “not set” and “not reset” operation. When power is applied, the BMS module switch is closed. The 10uF capacitor is discharged, so provides a momentary short to ground, turning Q1 off, and Q2 on. Current flows through the automotive relay, switching on the load to the battery.

After a few hours the cell discharges beneath 2.5V, the BMS switch opens and Q2 is switched off. The collector voltage on Q2 rises, switching on Q1. Due to the latching operation of the flip flip – it stays in this state. This is important, as when the relay opens, the cell will be unloaded and it’s voltage will rise again and the BMS module switch will close. In the initial design without a flip flop, this caused the relay to buzz as the cell voltage oscillated about 2.5V as the relay opened and closed! I need the test to stop and stay stopped – it will be operating unattended so I don’t want to damage the cell by completely discharging it.

The LED was inserted to ensure the base voltage on Q1 was low enough to switch Q1 off when Q2 was on (Vce of Q2 is not zero), and has the neat side effect of lighting the LED when the test is complete!

In operation, I point a cell phone taking time lapse video of the LED and some multi-meters, and start the test:

I wander back after 3 hours and jog-shuttle the time lapse video to determine the time when the LED came on:

The time lapse feature on this phone runs in 1/10 of real time. For example Cell #9 discharged in 12:12 on the time lapse video. So we convert that time to seconds, multiply by 10 to get “seconds of real time”, then divide by 3600 to get the run time in hours. Multiplying by the discharge current of 27(ish) Amps we get the cell capacity:

  12:12 time lapse, 27*(12*60+12)*10/3600 = 55AH

So this cells a bit low, and won’t be finding it’s way onto my boat!

Another alternative is a logging multimeter, one could even measure and integrate the discharge current over time. or I could have just bought or borrowed a proper discharge tester, but where’s the fun in that?


It was fun to develop, a few Saturday afternoons of sitting in the driveway soldering, occasional burns from 86W of hot wire, and a little head scratching while I figured out how to take the design from an expensive buzzer to a working circuit. Nice to do some soldering after months of software based DSP. I’m also happy that I could develop a transistor circuit from first principles.

I’ve now tested 12 cells (I have 40 to work through), and measured capacities of 50 to 75AH (they are rated at 100AH new). Some cells have odd behavior under load; dipping beneath 3V right at the start of the test rather than holding 3.2V for a few hours – indicating high internal resistance.

My beloved sail e-boat is already doing better. Last weekend, using the best cells I had tested at that point, I e-motored all day on varying power levels.

One neat trick, explained to me by Matt, is motor-sailing. Using a little bit of outboard power, the boat overcomes hydrodynamic friction (it gets moving in the water) and the sail is moved out of stall (like an airplane wing moving to just above stall speed). This means to boat moves a lot faster than under motor or sail alone in light winds. For example the motor was registering just 80W, but we were doing 3 knots in light winds. This same trick can be done with a stink-motor and dinosaur juice, but the e-motor is completely silent, we forgot it was on for hours at a time!

Reading Further

Electric Car BMS Controller
New Lithium Battery Pack for my EV
Engage the Silent Drive
EV Bugs

Planet DebianAlexander Wirt: alioth deprecation - next steps

As you should be aware, will be decommissioned with the EOL of wheezy, which is at the end of May. The replacement for the main part of alioth, git, is alive and out of beta, you know it as If you did not move your git repository yet, hurry up, time is running out.

The other important service from the alioth set, lists, moved to a new host and is now live at with the lists which opted into migration. All public list archives moved over too and will continue to exist under the old URL.

decommissioning timeline

2018-05-01 DISABLE registration of new users on alioth. Until an improved SSO (GSOC Project) is ready, new user registrations needed for SSO services will be handled manually. More details on this will follow in a seperate announcement.
2018-05-10 - 2018-05-13 darcs, bzr and mercurial repositories will be exported as tarballs and made available readonly from a new archive host, details on that will follow.
2018-05-17 - 2018-05-18 During the Mini-DebConf Hamburg any existing cron jobs will be turned off, websites still on alioth will be disabled.
2018-05-31 All remaining repositories (cvs, svn and git) will be archived similar to the ones above. The host moszumanska, the home of alioth, will go offline!

CryptogramHijacking Emergency Sirens

Turns out it's easy to hijack emergency sirens with a radio transmitter.

Planet Linux AustraliaLinux Users of Victoria (LUV) Announce: LUV April 2018 Workshop: Linux and Drupal mentoring and troubleshooting

Apr 21 2018 12:00
Apr 21 2018 16:00
Apr 21 2018 12:00
Apr 21 2018 16:00
Room B2:11, State Library of Victoria, 328 Swanston St, Melbourne

As our usual venue at Infoxchange is not available this month due to construction work, we'll be joining forces with DrupalMelbourne at the State Library of Victoria.

Linux Users of Victoria is a subcommittee of Linux Australia.

April 21, 2018 - 12:00

Worse Than FailureCodeSOD: Breaking Changes

We talk a lot about the sort of wheels one shouldn’t reinvent. Loads of bad code stumbles down that path. Today, Mary sends us some code from their home-grown unit testing framework.

Mary doesn’t have much to say about whatever case of Not Invented Here Syndrome brought things to this point. It’s especially notable that this is Python, which comes, out of the box, with a perfectly serviceable unittest module built in. Apparently not serviceable enough for their team, however, as Burt, the Lead Developer, wrote his own.

His was Object Oriented. Each test case received a TestStepOutcome object as a parameter, and was expected to return that object. This meant you didn’t have to use those pesky, readable, and easily comprehensible assert… methods. Instead, you just did your test steps and called something like:




Now, no one particularly liked the calling convention of setPassed(False), so after some complaints, Burt added a setFailed method. Developers started using it, and everyone’s tests passed. Everyone was happy.

At least, everyone was happy up until Mary wrote a test she expected to see fail. There was a production bug, and she could replicate it, step by step, at the Python REPL. So that she could “catch” the bug and “prove” it was dead, she wanted a unit test.

The unit test passed.

The bug was still there, and she continued to be able to replicate it manually.

She tried outcome.setFailed() and outcome.setFailed(True) and outcome.setFailed("OH FFS THIS SHOULD FAIL"), but the test passed. outcome.setPassed(False), however… worked just like it was supposed to.

Mary checked the implementation of the TestStepOutcome class, and found this:

class TestStepOutcome(object):
  def setPassed(self, flag=True):
    self.result = flag

  def setFailed(self, flag=True):
    self.result = flag

Yes, in Burt’s reluctance to have a setFailed message, he just copy/pasted the setPassed, thinking, “They basically do the same thing.” No one checked his work or reviewed the code. They all just started using setFailed, saw their tests pass, which is what they wanted to see, and moved on about their lives.

Fixing Burt’s bug was no small task- changing the setFailed behavior broke a few hundred unit tests, proving that every change breaks someone’s workflow.

[Advertisement] Forget logs. Next time you're struggling to replicate error, crash and performance issues in your apps - Think Raygun! Installs in minutes. Learn more.

Planet DebianReproducible builds folks: Reproducible Builds: Weekly report #155

Here's what happened in the Reproducible Builds effort between Sunday April 8 and Saturday April 14 2018:

Patches filed

In addition, 38 build failure bugs were reported by Adrian Bunk.

strip-nondeterminism development

Version 0.041-1 was uploaded to unstable by Chris Lamb: development

Mattia Rizzolo made a large number of changes to our Jenkins-based testing framework, including:


This week's edition was written by Bernhard M. Wiedemann, Chris Lamb and Holger Levsen & reviewed by a bunch of Reproducible Builds folks on IRC & the mailing lists.

Planet DebianReproducible builds folks: Reproducible Builds: Weekly report #155

Here’s what happened in the Reproducible Builds effort between Sunday April 8 and Saturday April 14 2018:

Patches filed

In addition, 38 build failure bugs were reported by Adrian Bunk.

strip-nondeterminism development

Version 0.041-1 was uploaded to unstable by Chris Lamb: development

Mattia Rizzolo made a large number of changes to our Jenkins-based testing framework, including:


This week’s edition was written by Bernhard M. Wiedemann, Chris Lamb and Holger Levsen & reviewed by a bunch of Reproducible Builds folks on IRC & the mailing lists.

Planet Linux AustraliaGary Pendergast: Introducing: Click Sync

Chrome’s syncing is pretty magical: you can see your browsing history from your phone, tablet, and computers, all in one place. When you install Chrome on a new computer, it automatically downloads your extensions. You can see your bookmarks everywhere, it even lets you open a tab from another device.

There’s one thing that’s always bugged me, however. When you click a link, it turns purple, as all visited links should. But it doesn’t turn purple on your other devices. Google have had this bug on their radar for ages, but it hasn’t made much progress. There’s already an extension that kind of fixes this, but it works by hashing every URL you visit and sending them to a server run by the extension author: not something I’m particularly comfortable with.

And so, I wrote Click Sync!

When you click a link, it’ll use Chrome’s inbuilt sync service to tell all your other computers to mark it as visited. If you like watching videos of links turn purple without being clicked, I have just the thing for you:

While you’re thinking about how Chrome syncs between all your devices, it’s good to setup a Chrome Passphrase, if you haven’t already. This encrypts your personal data before it passes through Google’s servers.

Unfortunately, Chrome mobile doesn’t support extensions, so this is only good for syncing between computers. If you run into any bugs, head on over the Click Sync repository, and let me know!

Don MartiGDPR and client-side tools

Lots of GDPR advice out there. As far as I can tell it pretty much falls into three categories.

But what if there is another way?

  1. Start with the clean version. (Here's that link again: How to: GDPR, consent and data processing).

  2. Add microformats to label consent forms as consent forms, and appropriate links to the data usage policy to which the user is being asked to agree.

  3. Release a browser extension that will do the right thing with the consent forms, and submit automatically if the user is fine with the data usage request and policy, and appears to trust the site. Lots of options here, since the extension can keep track of known data usage policies and which sites the user appears to trust, based on their activity.

  4. Publish user research results from the browser extension. At this point the browsers can compete to do their own versions of step 3, in order to give their users a more trustworthy and less annoying experience.

Browsers need to differentiate in order to attract new users and keep existing users. Right now a good way to do that is in creating a safer-feeling, more trustworthy environment. The big opportunity is in seeing the overlap between that goal for the browser and the needs of brands to build reputation and the needs of high-reputation publishers to shift web advertising from a hacking game that adtech/adfraud wins now, to a reputation game where trusted sites can win.

TEDTEDFilms: Four new short films premiered at TED2018

For the TED conference this year, we wanted to entertain attendees between talks — and support and encourage up-and-coming filmmakers. Meet TEDFilms, a new program for promoting the creation of original short films.

Executive-produced by Sinéad McDevitt and led up by TED’s director of Production and Video Operations, Mina Sabet, the short films acted as a creative palate-cleanser during the speaker program, a short blast of humor, beauty and awe.

Each film is less than two minutes, and genres range from experimental art and documentary to PSA and dark comedy. Enjoy!




As light passes through defective glass, beams split into color spectra, causing ‘diffraction grating’. For the first time ever in film, we get up close and personal with this visual phenomenon in a series of beautiful chromatic abstractions.

Director: Shane Griffin

Music: Gavin Little

With special thanks to:
Ed Bruce at Screenscene
Los York




Illusions for a Better Society
Could visual illusions be a cure for polarization?

Aaron Duffy
Lake Buckley
Jack Foster

Director of Photography: William Atherton

Production Design: Adam Pruitt

Creative Partner: SpecialGuest

Production Company: 1stAveMachine

Dave Kornfield
Andrew Geller
Matt Snetzko

Music: Bryn Bliska




It’s Not Amazing Enough
The pressures of having to make an amazing film sent this deadpan deep-voiced award winning filmmaker into a crippling spiral of self-doubt and comic indecision.

Director, Writer & Producer: Duncan Cowles





A.I. Therapy
After 100 years of progress, AI bots have finally become too human for their own good.

Mother London

Directors: Emerald Fennell & Chris Vernon

Director of Photography: Ben Kracun

Production Design: Jessica Sutton

VFX: Coffee & TV

Planet DebianNorbert Preining: Specification and Verification of Software with CafeOBJ – Part 1 – Introducing CafeOBJ

Software bugs are everywhere – the feared Blue Screen of Death, the mobile phone rebooting at the most inconvenient moment, games crashing. Most of these bugs are not serious problems, but there are other cases that are far more serious:

While bugs will always remain, the question is how to deal with these kinds of bug. There is unsurmountable amount of literature on this topic, but it general falls into one of the following categories:

  • program testing: subject the program to be checked to a large set of tests trying to exhaust all possible code paths
  • post coding formal verification – model checking: given program code, model the behavior of the program in temporal logic and prove necessary properties
  • pre coding specification and verification: start with a formal specification what the program should do, and verify that the specification is correct, that is, that it satisfies desirable properties

The first two items above are extremely successful and well developed. In this blog series we want to discuss the third item, specification and their verification.

Overview on the blog series

This blog will introduce some general concepts about software and specifications, as well as introduce CafeOBJ as an algebraic specification language that is executable and thus can be used to verify the specification at the same time.

Further blog entries will introduce the CafeOBJ language in bit more detail, go through a simple example of cloud synchronization specification, and discuss more involved techniques and automated theorem proving using CafeOBJ.

Why should we verify specifications?

The value of formal specifications of software has been recognized since the early 80ies, and formal systems have been in development since then (Z, Larch and OBJ all originate at that time). On the other hand, actual use of these techniques did remain mostly in the academic surrounding – engineers and developers where mostly reluctant to learn highly mathematical languages to write specifications instead of writing code.

With the growth of interactivity, explosion of number of communication protocols (from low level TCP to high level SSL) with handshakes and data exchange sequences, the need for formal verification of these protocols, especially if they guard crucial data, has been increasing steadily.

The CafeOBJ approach

CafeOBJ is a member of the OBJ family and thus uses algebraic methods to describe specifications. This is in contrast to the Z system which uses set theory and lambda calculus.

Our aims in developing the language (as well as the system) CafeOBJ can be summarized as follows:

  • provide a reasonable blend of user and machine capabilities
  • allow intuitive modeling while preserving a rigorous formal background
  • allow for various levels of modelling – from high-level to hard-core
  • do not try to fully automate everything – understanding of design and problems is necessary

We believe that we achieve this through the combination of a rigid formal background, the incorporation of order-sorted equational theory, an executable semantics via rewriting, high-level programming facilities (inheritance, templates and instantiations, …), and last but not least a completely freedom to redefine the language of the specification (postfix, infix, mixfix, syntax overloading, …).

More specifically, the logical foundations are formed by the following four elements:

  • Order sorted algebras: partial order of sorts
  • Hidden algebras: co-algebraic methods, infinite objects
  • Rewriting logic: transitions as first class objects
  • Order sorted rewriting: executable semantics

Our vision

Our vision for safety aware software development can be summarized as follows:

  • Step 1: Model and describe a system in order-sorted algebraic specification
    The domain/design engineers construct proof scores hand-in-hand with formal specification;
  • Step 2: Construct proof score and verify the specification by rewriting
    The proof scores (CafeOBJ code) are executable instructions, which, when evaluated provide proofs of desirable properties of the specification.

This concludes the first part of this series on CafeOBJ. We will dive into the language of CafeOBJ in the next blog.


Krebs on SecurityDeleted Facebook Cybercrime Groups Had 300,000 Members

Hours after being alerted by KrebsOnSecurity, Facebook last week deleted almost 120 private discussion groups totaling more than 300,000 members who flagrantly promoted a host of illicit activities on the social media network’s platform. The scam groups facilitated a broad spectrum of shady activities, including spamming, wire fraud, account takeovers, phony tax refunds, 419 scams, denial-of-service attack-for-hire services and botnet creation tools. The average age of these groups on Facebook’s platform was two years.

On Thursday, April 12, KrebsOnSecurity spent roughly two hours combing Facebook for groups whose sole purpose appeared to be flouting the company’s terms of service agreement about what types of content it will or will not tolerate on its platform.

One of nearly 120 different closed cybercrime groups operating on Facebook that were deleted late last week. In total, there were more than 300,000 members of these groups. The average age of these groups was two years, but some had existed for up to nine years on Facebook

My research centered on groups whose singular focus was promoting all manner of cyber fraud, but most especially those engaged in identity theft, spamming, account takeovers and credit card fraud. Virtually all of these groups advertised their intent by stating well-known terms of fraud in their group names, such as “botnet helpdesk,” “spamming,” “carding” (referring to credit card fraud), “DDoS” (distributed denial-of-service attacks), “tax refund fraud,” and account takeovers.

Each of these closed groups solicited new members to engage in a variety of shady activities. Some had existed on Facebook for up to nine years; approximately ten percent of them had plied their trade on the social network for more than four years.

Here is a spreadsheet (PDF) listing all of the offending groups reported, including: Their stated group names; the length of time they were present on Facebook; the number of members; whether the group was promoting a third-party site on the dark or clear Web; and a link to the offending group. A copy of the same spreadsheet in .csv format is available here.

The biggest collection of groups banned last week were those promoting the sale and use of stolen credit and debit card accounts. The next largest collection of groups included those facilitating account takeovers — methods for mass-hacking emails and passwords for countless online accounts such Amazon, Google, Netflix, PayPal, as well as a host of online banking services.

This rather active Facebook group, which specialized in identity theft and selling stolen bank account logins, was active for roughly three years and had approximately 2,500 members.

In a statement to KrebsOnSecurity, Facebook pledged to be more proactive about policing its network for these types of groups.

“We thank Mr. Krebs for bringing these groups to our attention, we removed them as soon as we investigated,” said Pete Voss, Facebook’s communications director. “We investigated these groups as soon as we were aware of the report, and once we confirmed that they violated our Community Standards, we disabled them and removed the group admins. We encourage our community to report anything they see that they don’t think should be in Facebook, so we can take swift action.”

KrebsOnSecurity’s research was far from exhaustive: For the most part, I only looked at groups that promoted fraudulent activities in the English language. Also, I ignored groups that had fewer than 25 members. As such, there may well be hundreds or thousands of other groups who openly promote fraud as their purpose of membership but which achieve greater stealth by masking their intent with variations on or mispellings of different cyber fraud slang terms.

Facebook said its community standards policy does not allow the promotion or sale of illegal goods or services including credit card numbers or CVV numbers (stolen card details marketed for use in online fraud), and that once a violation is reported, its teams review a report and remove the offending post or group if it violates those policies.

The company added that Facebook users can report suspected violations by loading a group’s page, clicking “…” in the top right and selecting “Report Group”. Users who wish to learn more about reporting abusive groups can visit

“As technology improves, we will continue to look carefully at other ways to use automation,” Facebook’s statement concludes, responding to questions from KrebsOnSecurity about what steps it might take to more proactively scour its networks for abusive groups. “Of course, a lot of the work we do is very contextual, such as determining whether a particular comment is hateful or bullying. That’s why we have real people looking at those reports and making the decisions.”

Facebook’s stated newfound interest in cleaning up its platform comes as the social networking giant finds itself reeling from a scandal in which Cambridge Analytica, a political data firm, was found to have acquired access to private data on more than 50 million Facebook profiles — most of them scraped without user permission.

Google AdsenseHelping publishers recover lost revenue from ad blocking

Today, the majority of the internet is supported by digital advertising. But bad ad experiences—the ones that blare music unexpectedly, or force you to wait 10 seconds before you get to the page—are hurting publishers who make the content, apps and services we use everyday. When people encounter annoying ads, and then decide to block all ads, it cuts off revenue for the sites you actually find useful. Many of these people don't intend to defund the sites they love when they install an ad blocker, but when they do, they block all ads on every site they visit. 

Last year we announced Funding Choices to help publishers with good ad experiences recover lost revenue due to ad blocking. While Funding Choices is still in beta, millions of ad blocking users every month are now choosing to see ads on publisher websites, or “whitelisting” that site, after seeing a Funding Choices message. In fact, in the last month over 4.5 million visitors who were asked to allow ads said yes, creating over 90 million additional paying page views for those sites.

Over the coming weeks, we’re expanding Funding Choices to 31 additional countries, giving publishers the ability to ask visitors from those countries to choose between allowing ads on a site, or purchasing an ad removal pass through Google Contributor. Also, we’ve started a test that allows publishers to use their own proprietary subscription services within Funding Choices.

How Funding Choices works

Funding Choice gives publishers a way to have a conversation with their site visitors through custom messages they can use to express how ad blocking impacts their business and content. When a visitor arrives at a site using an ad blocker, Funding Choices allows the site to display one of three message types to that user:

A dismissible message that doesn’t restrict access to content: 

A dismissible message that counts and limits the number of page views that person is allowed per month, as determined by the site owner, before the content is blocked.

Or, a message that blocks access to content until the visitor chooses to allow ads on the site, or to pay to access the content with either the site’s proprietary subscription service or a pass that removes all ads on that site through Google Contributor.

On average, publishers using Funding Choices are seeing 16 percent of visitors allow ads on their sites with some seeing rates as high as 37 percent.

Ad blockers designed to remove all ads from all sites are making it difficult for publishers with good ad experiences to maintain sustainable businesses. Our goal for Funding Choices is to help publishers get paid for their work by reducing the impact of ad blocking on them, and we look forward to continuing to expand the product availability.

Planet DebianRaphaël Hertzog: Freexian’s report about Debian Long Term Support, March 2018

A Debian LTS logoLike each month, here comes a report about the work of paid contributors to Debian LTS.

Individual reports

In March, about 214 work hours have been dispatched among 13 paid contributors. Their reports are available:

Evolution of the situation

The number of sponsored hours did not change.

The security tracker currently lists 31 packages with a known CVE and the dla-needed.txt file 26. Thanks to a few extra hours dispatched this month (accumulated backlog of a contributor), the number of open issues came back to a more usual value.

Thanks to our sponsors

New sponsors are in bold.

No comment | Liked this article? Click here. | My blog is Flattr-enabled.

TEDWow. Just wow. Notes from Session 7 of TED2018

Renzo Piano makes the case for beauty in architecture during TED2018: The Age of Amazement, April 12, 2018, in Vancouver. Photo: Bret Hartman / TED

What we need sometimes is a little awe, a little wonder. This session of TED Talks was designed to provoke an exquisite human emotion: the sense that the world is bigger and stranger than you’d known. Without further ado, wow.

A blueprint for how humans and machines can coexist. American researchers are leading AI discoveries, Chinese engineers are leading AI implementations like speech recognition and machine translation, and taken together, they will bring about a technological revolution that will pose major challenges to society. All types of jobs will be replaced by AI in the near-future, from radiologists to truckers. “But what’s more serious than the loss of jobs is the loss of meaning,” says investor Kai-Fu Lee, “because the work ethic in the Industrial Age has brainwashed us into thinking work is the reason we exist, that work defines the meaning of our lives.” Lee confesses that for many years, he was guilty of being a workaholic — nearly missing the birth of his daughter to give a presentation to Apple’s CEO– until he was diagnosed with Stage IV lymphoma five years ago. The experience made him realize that his priorities were completely out of order, but it also gave him a new view about what AI should mean for humanity. “AI is taking away a lot of routine jobs, but routine jobs are not what we’re about. Why we exist is love,” he says. He explains how we might harness human compassion – along with human creativity — to work with AI in a way that may help solve both the loss of jobs and the loss of meaning.

Personalized music composition through AI. Wouldn’t it be nice to finally have the perfect soundtrack for your life? Perhaps that pensive, melancholic song when you’re feeling down, or an upbeat tune when you’ve just received great news. Well, engineer and musician Pierre Barreau is making your personalized playlist a reality through AI. Barreau created an AI technology called AIVA, or Artificial Intelligence Visual Artist. He taught AIVA the art of music composition by inputting 30,000 scores from history’s greatest composers. “Using deep neural networks, AIVA looks for patterns in these scores.” he says. “From a couple of bars of existing music from an existing score, [AIVA] infers what should come next in those tracks. Once AIVA gets good at these predictions, it can actually build a set of mathematical rules for that style of music in order to create its own original compositions.” To make music unique to each person, he also taught AIVA to understand what makes a musical score emotionally unique by matching scores to different categories, including mood and note density. While personalized AI-generated music has clear applications for immersive media storytelling, like video games, it also has the power to better tell our life narratives. “This moment here together at TED is now a part of our life story. So it only felt fitting that AIVA would compose music for this moment.” Barreau concludes by playing a brief, mesmerizing song by AIVA, fittingly titled, “The Age of Amazement.”

A retrospective in the pursuit of beauty. “Architecture is the art of making shelter for human beings,” says architect Renzo Piano. Throughout his prolific career, Piano has designed some of the most recognizable buildings across the world; notables include the Centre Georges Pompidou in Paris, The Shard in London and the Whitney Museum of Art in New York City, part of an impressive body of work spanning decades. When he sets out to create these buildings, he looks for them to the flirt with the surrounding world — with water, wind, and even light — and communicate with humanity’s most universal language: beauty. Real beauty, he believes, is when the invisible joins the visible. And this doesn’t just apply to art or nature, it can relate to science and human curiosity as well. “This universal beauty is one of the few thing that can change the world,” he says. “Believe me this beauty will change the world, one person at a time.”

Hope for the organ transplant shortage — inside a baby pig. Every day, thousands of people wait for a desperately needed organ replacement — and by the end of today, 20 people will have died waiting. For almost half a century it’s been thought to be theoretically possible to transplant organs from pigs into humans, because pigs are similar enough to humans biologically and about the same size. But as scientist Luhan Yang puts it, there was one major problem: “The pig genome has a dangerous virus that does not express in pigs, but can be transmitted to humans.” If the virus, PERV, migrated to humans through a transplanted organ, it could spark a deadly HIV-like epidemic. So research had stalled, but Yang decided to dig in. Using CRISPR, a technique for editing genes, she and her lab have been working to create a pig without PERV in its genome. Difficulty: PERV expresses in 62 places on the pig genome. She shows a picture of Laika, one of the more than 30 PERV-free pigs her lab has bred. They may represent an exciting first step toward solving the organ transplantation crisis. After the talk, co-host Chris Anderson asks Yang for a timeline; she demurs at first but then says “We hope that it happens within one decade.”

CSI: Fingerprints. TV crime dramas are credited with luring people, particularly young women, into the field of forensic science; they’re drawn by the combination of conducting serious lab work and helping catch the bad guys. Seeing a talk from Sheffield Hallam University analytical chemist Simona Francese about her fascinating research might have that same impact. An expert in fingerprint analysis, Francese says: “Molecules are the storytellers of who are we and what we’ve been up to. We just need to have the right technology to make them talk.” Through her work, she is revealing the tales to be found in the microscopic remnants that we all leave behind. A person’s prints can contain three types of molecules: ordinary sweat molecules; molecules of substances that we’ve introduced into our bodies and sweat out; and molecules of stuff that’s adhered to our hands. Francese and her team achieve their breathtakingly detailed analyses by using UV lasers — which release the molecules in fingerprints — and mass spectrometry imaging technology, which then measures the mass of those molecules, pinpointing what they are. They’ve been able to detect thousands of different molecules in a single print. They can also visualize the distribution of each molecule on the fingerprint — which allows them to separate prints when they’re overlapping, something that tends to stymie the police. Their work can also fill in faint prints by improving ridge pattern continuity and clarity. In 2017, law enforcement in the UK and in other parts of Europe began using Francese’s technology in their criminal investigations.

Sometimes it’s awesome to be sad. “I love depressing songs,” says Luke Sital-Singh, “songs of sorrow, of grief, of longing … because they speak to a very real part of being human.” Accompanied only by a piano on a dark stage, the singer-songwriter performed two gorgeous and melancholic ballads, “Afterneath” and “Killing Me,” leaving many in the audience in tears, including our co-host.

Conquering physical and mental mountains. Not many people would consider being stuck between a rock and … another rock … nearly 3,000 feet off the ground without a rope to be one of the best moments of their life. But for Alex Honnold, it was the cumulation of a nearly two-decade-long dream. On June 3, 2017, at the age of 31, Honnold became the only person to summit El Capitan, a nearly 3,000-foot climb in Yosemite National Park, without a rope. This is a style of climbing known as free soloing, and one that Honnold is recognized for internationally. During his talk, Honnold shared how preparing for El Capitan required as much mental exercise as it did physical. He spent a year rehearsing not only every physical move, but every thought and doubt he could have on the wall. “Doubt is the precursor to fear, and I knew that I couldn’t experience my perfect moment if I was afraid.” In the end, he had his perfect moment, soaring up the wall that takes the average climber three days to summit in a mere three hours and fifty-six minutes. Honnold’s talk ended with a standing ovation and a final note from Chris Anderson: “Don’t share this talk with your children, please.” — Michaela Eames

TEDIn Case You Missed It: Finding space to dream at day 3 at TED2018

In Case You Missed It TED2018TED2018 hit its stride on day 3, with talks from explorers of space and oceans, builders of cities and bridges, engineers of the future and many more.

Here are some of the themes we heard echoing through the opening day, as well as some highlights from around the conference venue in Vancouver.

Are we alone in the cosmos? The universe is 13.8 billion years old and contains billions of galaxies — in fact, there are probably a trillion planets in our galaxy alone. People have long thought a civilization like ours must exist or should have existed somewhere out there, but British astronomer Stephen Webb sees another possibility: we’re alone. Thinkers have speculated about all the barriers that a planet would need to house an alien civilization: it would need to be habitable; life would have to develop there; such life forms would need a certain technological intelligence to reach out; and they’d have to be able to communicate across space. Rather than viewing the situation with sorrow and the cosmos as a lonely place, “the silence of the universe is shouting: we’re the creatures who got lucky,” says Webb. One cosmic visitor we just recently met can confirm something else is definitely out there — ‘Oumuamua, the first known interstellar object to pass through the Solar System. University of Hawaii astrobiologist Karen Meech introduces us to the mysterious object, which she says is a package from the nearest star system 4.4 light years away, having traveled on a journey of more than 50,000 years. She believes it could be a chunk of rocky debris from a new star system; other researchers believe it may be something else altogether — evidence of extraterrestrial civilizations, or material cast off in the death throes of a star. “This unexpected gift has generated more questions than answers,” says Meech, “but we were the first to say hello to this visitor from our distant past.”

Penny Chisholm explains how an ancient, ocean-dwelling cyanobacterium — Prochlorococcus — could inspire us to break our dependency on fossil fuels. (Photo: Bret Hartman / TED)

Ocean explorers. Prochlorococcus is an ancient ocean-dwelling cyanobacterium that Penny Chisholm, a biological oceanographer at MIT, discovered in the mid-1980s. It’s the most abundant photosynthetic cell on the planet and Chisholm believes that it could hold clues for sustainable energy in its genetic architecture. With a gene pool four times the size of the human genome but 1/100th the width of a human hair, this engineering masterpiece might inspire solutions to break our dependency on fossil fuel. If we hope to unlock the wonders of Prochlorococcus in the Age of Amazement, we’re going to need to protect the world’s waters first. Enric Sala, a marine ecologist and National Geographic Explorer-in-Residence, proposes the creation of a giant high seas reserve. Falling outside of any single country’s jurisdiction, the high seas are the “Wild West” of the ocean and until recently, it was difficult to know who was fishing (and how much). Satellite technology and machine learning now enable the tracking of boats and revenue, revealing that practically the entire high seas fishing proposition is misguided. In response, Sala advocates for creating a reserve that would include two-thirds of the ocean, protecting the ecological, economic and social benefits of our waters.

Bridges reveal something about creativity, ingenuity; they even hint at our identity, says engineer Ian Firth. (Photo: Bret Hartman / TED)

How we’re shaping (and reshaping) the built environment. TED is known for its fair share of tech wizardry, where innovation happens at the scale of microns. But our built environment is in need of some love in the Age of Amazement as well. Architect and Columbia University professor Vishaan Chakrabarti highlights the creeping sameness in many urban buildings and streetscapes throughout the world. This physical homogeneity — stemming from regulations, automobiles, accessibility and safety issues, and cost considerations, among other factors — has resulted in a social and mental one as well. Let’s strive to create cities of difference, magnetic places that embody an area’s cultural and local proclivities, exhorts Chakrabarti. One great way to beautify a city: an elegant, distinctive bridge! Ian Firth, an engineer who has designed spans all over the world, including the 3.3 kilometer-long suspension bridge over the Messina Strait in Italy, talks about the connectivity that makes them special pieces of infrastructure. “They reveal something about creativity, ingenuity; they even hint at our identity,” he explains. Although they fall into only a few types, depending on the nature of their structural support, bridges hold great potential for innovation and variety is tremendous. “Bridges need to be elegant, they need to be beautiful,” Firth says.

Angel Hsu shows us that real change is afoot in China’s, as the country’s energy initiatives have unexpectedly placed it at the vanguard of the fight against pollution and climate change. (Photo: Bret Hartman / TED)

Pollution problems — and solutions. Iconic images of skylines buried in clouds of smog ensured China’s notoriety as one of the world’s biggest polluters. But Angel Hsu shows us that real change is afoot in China’s, as the country’s energy initiatives have unexpectedly placed it at the vanguard of the fight against pollution and climate change. In 2011, when Hsu began conducting her research, China’s own environmental data — specifically for fine particulate matter, or PM2.5 — was kept secret. But thanks to citizen activism, pollution’s hazardous impacts on human health skyrocketed into China’s consciousness. The emerging zeitgeist grabbed the government’s attention. Recognizing China’s toxic reliance on fossil fuels, they pulled the plug on more than 300,000 coal plants, and began feverishly developing alternative energy. Although China must still address its coal problem abroad, its efforts at home (although uncertain) could impact global pollution — and China’s massive carbon footprint — in a major way. While cutting down on pollution is good, removing harmful greenhouse gases from the atmosphere would be even better. The concentration of CO2 in today’s atmosphere is a staggering 400ppm, but we’re still not cutting emissions as fast as we need to, according to chemical engineer Jennifer Wilcox. So we need to pull CO2 back out of the atmosphere — a strategy known as negative emissions. The technology to do this already exists: a device known as an air contactor uses CO2-grabbing chemicals in solid materials or dissolved in water to pull the gas out of the air, sort of like a synthetic forest. What makes this process tricky, though, is that it’s energy-intensive, which drives costs up or, depending on the type of energy used, ends up emitting more CO2 than is captured. Several companies are working on making the process more cost-effective using a variety of techniques, as well as solving other problems of carbon capture like how and where we should build these “synthetic forests.” And in a truly mind-blowing talk, applied engineer Aaswath Raman explains how the next great renewable resource might be … the cold of space. “What keeps me up at night is that the energy use for cooling is expected to grow six-fold by the year 2050,” he says. “The warmer the world gets, the more we are going to need cooling systems.” He’s exploring a potential solution that leverages a cool fact about infrared light and deep space.

Untraditional storytellers. Three TED speakers evoked storytelling in their talks — perhaps that’s not so unexpected, but what was surprising was there wasn’t a writer, musician or filmmaker among them. Game designer David Cage entreated the audience to think of videogames as more than pixelated shooting ranges or mindless time-fillers. “I’ve always been fascinated with the idea of recreating the notion of choice in fiction,” he says. “My dream is to put the audience in the shoes of the protagonist, let them make their own decisions, and by doing so, let them tell their own stories.” While playing, gamers also get the chance to enjoy two tremendously liberating qualities not usually found when reading a book: personal autonomy and flexibility. Veteran architect and Pritzker winner Renzo Piano — who is responsible for such indelible buildings such as Paris’s Centre George Pompidou, the New York Times building, and London’s The Shard — took audience members through his life’s work and his thinking. He too views himself as a storyteller. But while Cage concentrated on the narrative aspects of that role, Piano extolled the love, happiness and other emotional reactions that beautiful structures evoke in all of us. And the most surprising of today’s storytellers? Your fingerprints — or, more specifically, the molecules in your fingerprints, according to analytical chemist Simona Francese: “Molecules are the storytellers of who are we and what we’ve been up to. We just need to have the right technology to make them talk.” Francese and a team at her lab at the UK’s Sheffield Hallam University have spent nearly a decade perfecting the process to identify as much as 1,000 molecules in a single fingerprint — and this technology is now being used by the police in Europe to catch criminals.

Nora Atkinson invites us on a trip to Burning Man, to see the wonderful art that’s constructed and burned — and never sold — there each year. (Photo: Lawrence Sumulong / TED)

Love, actually. In 2017, Smithsonian American Art Museum craft curator Nora Atkinson went to Burning Man in Nevada for the first time, and what she found was an artistic experience like no other. Every August, more than 70,000 people trek to the desert and engage with 300+ installations, sculptures and structures. None of the pieces are for sale (all are burned or taken away at week’s end), and anyone can make art. As a result, creativity there is driven by passion, not profit. Burning Man art is “authentic and optimistic in a way we rarely see anywhere else,” and it encourages, even demands, interaction and investigation. “What is art for,” Atkinson asks, “if not this?” Love was also on the mind of speaker Kai-Fu Lee. The longtime technology investor and executive admits love was absent from his career-minded trajectory until he was diagnosed with cancer (but shares he is now in remission). He feels it’s been similarly overlooked in discussions about technology and the future. “Love is what differentiates us from AI,” he says. “Despite what science fiction movies may portray, I can tell you responsibly that AI programs cannot love.” Lee urges people to think of how human love, compassion and technological brilliance can co-exist and help us create better, more connected lives. Musician Luke Sital-Singh brought down the house — and made TED curator Chris Anderson wipe his eyes — by playing and singing a beautiful composition called “Killing Me.” He wrote the song from the point of view of his grandmother, who has had to figure out how to live without her soulmate, Sital-Singh’s late grandfather, even as she experiences the joys of her family and their new members and accomplishments. He sang, “Oh you won’t believe, the wonders I can see/This world is changing me, but I’ll love you faithfully.” And while soft-spoken climber Alex Honnold, the day’s final speaker, didn’t use the L-word, it came through loud and clear as he talked about his record-setting, free-solo climb of El Capitan in 2017. He spoke about his intense mental preparation for the feat — he took months to memorize every handhold and foot placement, so the climb would come naturally and automatically to him. Of that day, he recalled, “With six hundred feet to go, it felt like the mountain was offering me a victory lap. I climbed with a smooth precision and enjoyed the sounds of the birds swooping around the cliff. It all felt like a celebration.”

Workshops aplenty. TEDsters had 19 workshops to choose from on day 3. Adam Savage had attendees create armor helmets out of laser cut corrugated cardboard. Angelica Dass guided attendees through painting self portraits, asking people to revisit their childhood art class — specifically the moment they learned about the connections between the colors of their skin and their race. And OK Go led attendees to build an orchestra out of random objects around the room … like suitcases, wine bottles, cans and PVC pipes.

TEDAltair at TED2018: In the “Age of Amazement,” simulation drives innovation

Altair’s exhibit gallery at TED2018 features a vintage car with 3D-printed insides, a helmet designed to reduce football-related head injuries and a Wilson golf driver challenge, among much more. (Photo: Jason Redmond / TED)

In a corner of the Vancouver Convention Center — set against a beautiful backdrop of Vancouver Harbour and the mountains of the North Shore, and right between a comfy simulcast lounge and a pop-up coffee and espresso shop — it’s hard to miss an eye-catching vintage red car. It’s the anchor of Altair’s exhibit gallery, showing off the possibilities of simulation-driven innovation.

Altair is a leading provider of enterprise-class engineering software enabling innovation from concept design to operation. Their simulation-driven approach is powered by a suite of software that optimizes performance while providing data analytics and true-to-life visualization and rendering. Altair products range from biomimicry software that unlocks the potential of industrial 3D-printing to personalized healthcare with machine learning enabled by the Internet of Things. At TED2018, they invited TEDsters to explore the intersection of human creativity and technology — and the extraordinary impact it has on shaping the world around us.

On display at their gallery: an IoT-enabled bodysuit from BioSerenity that records seizures to help diagnose epilepsy; a helmet designed to reduce football-related head injuries created in partnership VICIS, which is set to be used by Notre Dame in NCAA games this coming season; an advanced arm prosthetic … and a vintage car made up of a vintage frame with aluminum 3D-printed insides, created by Altair, APWORKS, csi entwicklungstechnik, EOS, GERG and Heraeus.

Altair is also hosting an interactive design experience where attendees can use their simulation software to design a custom Wilson golf driver. The person with the leading design — the one that hits the ball furthest (and yes, thanks to machine learning and Altair HyperWorks’ Virtual Wind Tunnel, there is a right answer to this) by the end of TED2018 will receive a golf driver as a prize. In the “Age of Amazement” — TED’s theme in 2018 — simulation and machine learning will drive innovation.

TEDIn Case You Missed It: Bold visions for humanity at day 4 of TED2018

In Case You Missed It TED2018Three sessions of memorable TED Talks covering life, death and the future of humanity made the penultimate day of TED2018 a remarkable space for tech breakthroughs and dispatches from the edges of culture.

Here are some of the themes we heard echoing through the opening day, as well as some highlights from around the conference venue in Vancouver.

The future built on genetic code. DNA is built on four letters: G, C, A, T. These letters determine the sequences of the 20 amino acids in our cells that build the proteins that make life possible. But what if that “alphabet” got bigger? Synthetic biologist and chemist Floyd Romesberg suggests that the four letters of the genetic alphabet are not all that unique. He and his colleagues constructed the first “semi-synthetic” life forms based on a 6-letter DNA. With these extra building blocks, cells can construct hitherto unseen proteins. Someday, we could tailor these cells to fulfill all sorts of functions — building new, hyper-targeted medicines, seeking out and destroying cancer, or “eating” toxic materials. And maybe soon, we’ll be able to use that expanded DNA alphabet to teleport. That’s right, you read it here first: teleportation is real. Biologist and engineer Dan Gibson reports from the front lines of science fact that we are now able to transmit the most fundamental parts of who we are: our DNA. It’s called biological teleportation, and the idea is that biological entities including viruses and living cells can be reconstructed in a distant location if we can read and write the sequence of that DNA code. The machines that perform this fantastic feat, the BioXP and the DBC, stitch together both long and short forms of genetic code that can be downloaded from the internet. That means that in the future, with an at-home version of these machines (or even one worlds away, say like, Mars), we may be able to download and print personalized therapeutic medications, prescriptions and even vaccines.

“If we want to create meaningful technology to counter radicalization, we have to start with the human journey at its core,” says technologist Yasmin Green at Session 8 at TED2018: The Age of Amazement, April 13, Vancouver. (Photo: Jason Redmond / TED)

Dispatches from the fight against hate online. At Jigsaw (a division of Alphabet), Yasmin Green and her colleagues were given the mandate to build technology that could help make the world safer from extremism and persecution. In 2016, Green collaborated with Moonshot CVE to pilot a new approach, the “Redirect Method.” She and a team interviewed dozens of former members of violent extremist groups, and used what they learned to create targeted advertising aimed at people susceptible to ISIS’s recruiting — and counter those messages. In English and Arabic, the eight-week pilot program reached more than 300,000 people. “If technology has any hope of overcoming today’s challenges,” Green says, “we must throw our entire selves into understanding these issues and create solutions that are as human as the problems they aim to solve.” Dylan Marron is taking a different approach to the problem of hate on the internet. His video series, such as “Sitting in Bathrooms With Trans People,” have racked up millions of views, and they’ve also sent a slew of internet poison in his direction. He developed a coping mechanism: he calls up the people who leave hateful remarks, opening their chats with a simple question: “Why did you write that?” These exchanges have been captured on Marron’s podcast “Conversations With People Who Hate Me.” While it hasn’t led to world peace, he says it’s caused him to develop empathy for his bullies. “Empathizing with someone I profoundly disagree with doesn’t suddenly erase my deeply held beliefs and endorse theirs,” he cautions. “I simply am acknowledging the humanity of a person who has been taught to think a certain way, someone who thinks very differently than me.”

Is artificial intelligence actually intelligence? Not yet, says Kevin Frans. Earlier in his teen years (he’s now just 18) he joined the OpenAI lab to think about the fascinating problem of making AI that has true intelligence. Right now, he says, a lot of what we call intelligence is just trial-and-error on a massive scale — a machine can try every possible solution, even ones too absurd for a human to imagine, until it finds the thing that works best to solve a single discrete problem. Which really isn’t general intelligence. So Frans is conceptualizing instead a way to think about AI from a skills perspective — specifically, the ability to learn simple skills and assemble them to accomplish tasks. It’s early days for this approach, and for Kevin himself, who is part of the first generation to grow up as AI natives. Picking up on the thread of pitfalls of current AI, artist and technology critic James Bridle describes how automated copycats on YouTube mimic trusted videos by using algorithmic tricks to create “fake news” for kids. End result: children exploring YouTube videos from their favorite cartoon characters are sent down autoplaying rabbit holes, where they can find eerie, disturbing videos filled with very real violence and very real trauma. Algorithms are touted as the fix, but as Bridle says, machine learning is really just what we call software that does things we don’t understand … and we have enough of that already, no?

Chetna Gala Sinha tells us about a bank in India that meets the needs of rural poor women who want to save and borrow. (Photo: Jason Redmond / TED)

Listen and learn. Takemia MizLadi Smith spoke up for the front-desk staffer, the checkout clerk, and everyone who’s ever been told they need to start collecting information from customers, whether it be an email, zip code or data about their race and gender. Smith makes the case to empower every front desk employee who collects data — by telling them exactly how that data will be used. Chetna Gala Sinha, meanwhile, started a bank in India that meets the needs of rural poor women who want to save and borrow — and whom traditional banks would not touch. How does the bank improve their service? As Chetna says: simply by listening. Meanwhile, sex educator Emily Nagoski talked about a syndrome called emotional nonconcordance, where what your body seems to want runs counter to what you actually want. In an intimate situation, ahem, it can be hard to figure out which one to listen to, head or body. Nagoski gives us full permission and encouragement to listen to your head, and to the words coming out of the mouth of your partner. And Harvard Business School prof Frances Frei gave a crash course in trust — building it, keeping it, and the hardest, rebuilding it. She shares lessons from her stint as an embed at Uber, where far from listening to in meetings, staffers would actually text each other during meetings — about the meeting. True listening, the kind that builds trust, starts with putting away your phone.

Bionic man Hugh Herr envisions humanity soaring out of the 21st century. (Photo: Ryan Lash / TED)

A new way to heal our bodies … and build new ones. Optical engineer Mary Lou Jepsen shares an exciting new tool for reading what’s inside our bodies. It exploits the properties of red light, which behaves differently in different body materials. Our bones and flesh scatter red light (as she demonstrates on a piece of raw chicken breast), while our red blood absorbs it and doesn’t let it pass through. By measuring how light scatters, or doesn’t, inside our bodies, and using a technique called holography to study the resulting patterns as the light comes through the other side, Jepsen believe we can gain a new way to spot tumors and other anomalies, and eventually to create a smaller, more efficient replacement for the bulky MRI. MIT professor Hugh Herr is working on a different way to heal — and augment — our bodies. He’s working toward a goal that’s long been thought of as science fiction: for synthetic limbs to be integrated into the human nervous system. He calls it neural embodied design, a methodology to create cyborg function where the lines between the natural and synthetic world are blurred. This future will provide humanity with new bodies and end disability, Herr says — and it’s already happening. He introduces us to Jim Ewing, a friend who lost a foot in a climbing accident. Using the Agonist-antagonist Myoneural Interface, or AAMI, a method Herr and his team developed at MIT to connect nerves to a prosthetic, Jim’s bones and muscles were integrated with a synthetic limb, re-establishing the neural connection between his ankle and foot muscles and his brain. What might be next? Maybe, the ability to fly.

Announcements! Back in 2014, space scientist Will Marshall introduced us to his company, Planet, and their proposed fleet of tiny satellites. The goal: to image the planet every day, showing us how Earth changes in near-real time. In 2018, that vision has come good: every day, a fleet of about 200 small satellites pictures every inch of the planet, taking 1.5 million 29-megapixel images every day (about 6T of data daily), gathering data on changes both natural and human-made. This week at TED, Marshall announced a consumer version of Planet, called Planet Stories, to let ordinary people play with these images. Start playing now here. Another announcement comes from futurist Ray Kurzweil: a new way to query the text inside books using something called semantic search — which is a search on ideas and concepts, rather than specific words. Called TalkToBooks, the beta-stage product uses an experimental AI to query a database of 120,000 books in about a half a second. (As Kurzweil jokes: “It takes me hours to read a hundred thousand books.”) Jump in and play with TalkToBooks here. Also announced today: “TED Talks India: Nayi Soch” — the wildly popular Hindi-language TV series, created in partnership with StarTV and hosted by Shah Rukh Khan — will be back for three more seasons.

Planet DebianHolger Levsen: 20180416-LTS-march

My LTS work in March

So in March I resumed contributing to LTS again, after 2 years of taking a break, due to being overwhelmed with work on Reproducible Builds... Reproducible Builds is still eating a lot of my time, but as we currently are unfunded I had to pick up some other sources of funding.

And then, due to Reproducible Builds still requiring a lot of my attention (both actual work as well as work on getting funded again) and other stuff happening in my life, I was also mostly unable to find time to really dive into LTS again, so while I managed to renew my knowledge of the procedures etc, I only managed to find 1.5h work to be done :/ Which in turn made me feel quite bad, so that I also postponed writing about this until now.

So, in March I only managed to mark libcdio as no-DSA and upload samba to fix CVE-2018-1050.

On the plus side and despite the above, I'm very happy to be able to work on LTS again, because a.) I consider it interesting (to fix bugs in old packages, yes!) and b.) because I use LTS myself and c.) because the LTS crowd is actually a nice and helpful one.

And now let's see how much LTS work I'll manage in April...!

CryptogramThe DMCA and its Chilling Effects on Research

The Center for Democracy and Technology has a good summary of the current state of the DMCA's chilling effects on security research.

To underline the nature of chilling effects on hacking and security research, CDT has worked to describe how tinkerers, hackers, and security researchers of all types both contribute to a baseline level of security in our digital environment and, in turn, are shaped themselves by this environment, most notably when things they do upset others and result in threats, potential lawsuits, and prosecution. We've published two reports (sponsored by the Hewlett Foundation and MacArthur Foundation) about needed reforms to the law and the myriad of ways that security research directly improves people's lives. To get a more complete picture, we wanted to talk to security researchers themselves and gauge the forces that shape their work; essentially, we wanted to "take the pulse" of the security research community.

Today, we are releasing a third report in service of this effort: "Taking the Pulse of Hacking: A Risk Basis for Security Research." We report findings after having interviewed a set of 20 security researchers and hackers -- half academic and half non-academic -- about what considerations they take into account when starting new projects or engaging in new work, as well as to what extent they or their colleagues have faced threats in the past that chilled their work. The results in our report show that a wide variety of constraints shape the work they do, from technical constraints to ethical boundaries to legal concerns, including the DMCA and especially the CFAA.

Note: I am a signatory on the letter supporting unrestricted security research.

Worse Than FailureCodeSOD: All the Things!

Yasmin needed to fetch some data from a database for a report. Specifically, she needed to get all the order data. All of it. No matter how much there was.

The required query might be long running, but it wouldn’t be complicated. By policy, every query needed to be implemented as a stored procedure. Yasmin, being a smart prograammer, decided to check and see if anybody had already implemented a stored procedure which did what she needed. She found one called GetAllOrders. Perfect! She tested it in her report.

Yasmin expected 250,000 rows. She got 10.

She checked the implementation.

CREATE PROCEDURE initech.GetAllOrders
    FROM initech.orders INNER JOIN…

In the original developer’s defense, at one point, when the company was very young, that might have returned all of the orders. And no, I didn’t elide the ORDER BY. There wasn’t one.

[Advertisement] ProGet can centralize your organization's software applications and components to provide uniform access to developers and servers. Check it out!

TEDPersonally speaking: Notes from Session 10 of TED2018

What does an illustrator’s life look like? Well, says Christoph Niemann, most of the time: this. He spoke at TED2018 on April 13, 2018, in Vancouver. Photo: Jason Redmond / TED

Sketches that speak volumes. When illustrator Christoph Niemann wakes up after falling asleep on an airplane, he says, “I have the most terrible taste in my mouth that cannot be described with words … But it can be drawn.” Then he shows a spot-on sketch of an outstretched tongue with a dead-fish-rat-hybrid creature on it. Trying to recap his intensely visual talk in words resembles his struggle, because this talk speaks largely through witty, whimsical drawings. Niemann believes all people are bilingual, “fluent in the language of reading images,” and most of our fluency comes organically. For example, while you might remember learning to read the words “men” and “women,” can you recall anyone explaining to you what the symbols on the doors of the bathroom meant? You just figured it out. People share a rich and common visual vocabulary, so Niemann likes to take “images from remote cultural areas and bring them together” — hence his putting the words “ceci n’est pas une pipe” in cursive above white iPhone earbuds. Using this collective lexicon, Niemann and other artists can communicate information, satirize people and ideas, express empathy, and make us laugh — all without words. In that way, he says, as deft as his drawings are, they’d be nothing without an audience. He says, “The real magic happens in the mind of the viewer.”

“Once your appliances can talk, who else will they talk to?” Gizmodo writers Kashmir Hill and Surya Mattu survey the world of “smart devices” — the gadgets that “sit in the middle of our home with a microphone on, constantly listening,” and gathering data — to discover just what they’re up to. To do this, Kashmir turned her San Francisco apartment into a full-fledged smart home, loading up on 18 different internet-connected appliances — including a “smart bed” that calculated her nightly “sleep score” to let her know if she was well-rested or not. Her colleague Surya built a special router to figure out how often the devices connected, who they were transmitting to, what they were transmitting — and what of that data could be sold. The results were surprising — and a little creepy. By poring over Kashmir’s family’s data, Surya could decipher their sleep schedules, TV binges,  tooth-brushing habits. And while many appliances connected only for updates, the Amazon Echo connected shockingly often — every three minutes. All of this data can tell companies how rich or poor you are, whether or not you’re an insurance risk, and — perhaps worst of all — the state of your sex life. (A digital vibrator company was caught “data-mining their customers’ orgasms.”) All this may lead you to ask, as Surya does, “Who is the true beneficiary of your smart home? You, or the company mining you?”

Embrace the diversity within. Rebeca Hwang has spent a lifetime juggling identities (Korean heritage, Argentinian upbringing, educated in the United States), and for a long time she had difficulty finding a place in the world to call home. Instead, one day, she had a pivotal realization: it was fruitless to search for total commonality with the people around her. Instead, she decided, she would embrace all the possible versions of herself — and the superpower it grants her to make connections with all kinds of people. Through thoughtful reinvention of her personhood, Hwang rid herself of constant anxiety, by “cultivating diversity within me and not just around me.” In the wake of her personal revolution, she’s continued to live a multifaceted life and accept the endless advantages it brings. She hopes to raise her children, who are already growing up with a unique combination of backgrounds, to help create a world where identities are used not to alienate others but to bring people together.

Life after loss. Jason Rosenthal’s journey of loss and grief began when his wife, Amy Krouse-Rosenthal (a best-selling children’s book author), wrote about their lives in a New York Times article read by millions of people. “You May Want to Marry My Husband” was a meditation on dying, disguised as a personal ad for her soon-to-be-solitary spouse. By writing their story, Amy made Jason’s grief public, and gave him an empty page on which he could inscribe the rest of his life. For Jason, “The key to my being able to persevere is Amy’s express and very public edict that I must go on.” But grief carries memories, especially of the process of dying itself. Amy chose home hospice, which gave her  happiness — but Jason is honest about the complications it caused for the survivors, including the inevitable, indelible memory of when Jason carried a lifeless Amy “down our stairs, through our living and our dining room, to a waiting gurney to have her body cremated.” Jason’s salvation lay in Amy’s challenge to begin anew, which he shares with others who may be grieving: “I would like to offer you what I was given: a blank sheet of paper. What will you do with your intentional empty space, with your fresh start?”

An emotional reset. Many of us in the audience knew Amy Krouse Rosenthal, who had a key role in planning our TED Active conference; session co-host Juliet Blake asks for the house lights to dim for a moment to create some space for quiet reflection. Then the extraordinary violinist Lili Haydn steps onstage for a welcome musical interlude. Unaccompanied by a band, she performs an emotional and elegant piece of her original musical, called “The Last Serenade.”

Can we help every employee be GRACED? Over the years, poet and trainer Tamekia MizLadi Smith has met her share of Miz Margarets — the longtime front-desk employee at a medical office who knows her job perfectly well and doesn’t take kindly to change. So when new rules for data collection come down from the top, and that suddenly she needs to ask every patient to self-identify by gender (with 6 options!), by race (with even more options!) and nationality (with even more options still!!), it’s no wonder that Miz Margaret starts thinking about early retirement. But what if she knew that this data would be used to help her patients, not to stereotype them — to help the office speak more respectfully to people of all genders, to get research funding for under-served groups? Smith shares an acrostic poem on the letters G.R.A.C.E.D. that will inspire bosses, trainers and data collectors to think carefully about the front-line employees who’ll be asking for this data. Bottom line: Always let people know that (and how) their work matters.

A bank that helps women empower themselves. A few years after social entrepreneur Chetna Gala Sinha moved from Mumbai to a remote village in Maharashtra, India, she met a woman named Kantabai. She was a blacksmith who wanted to open a bank account to save her hard-earned money, but when Sinha accompanied her to the bank, she was turned down because they didn’t think her small savings rate was worth their effort or time. Sinha decided that if the bank wouldn’t open an account for poor women like Kantabai, she would start one that would – and the Mann Deshi Bank was born. Today, it has 100,000 accounts and has done over $20 million in business. Over the years, her women customers have consistently pushed Sinha to come up with better solutions to their needs, teaching her one of the biggest lessons she’s learned: “Never provide poor solutions to poor people.” She shares the stories of Kerabai, Sunita, and Sarita – other women like Kantabai who’ve inspired her over the years and profoundly influenced her work. “There are millions of women like Sarita, Kerabai, Sunita, who can be around you also, they can be all over the world, but at first glance, you may think that they do not have anything to say, they do not have anything to share. You would be so wrong,” she says. Encouraged by the women she works with, Sinha is now in the midst of creating the first fund for women micro entrepreneurs in India, and the first Small Finance Bank for women in the world.

Paging through the Chess Records catalog. “You can’t do Chuck Berry better than Chuck, or Fontella Bass better than Fontella,” says Elise LeGrow, but on her latest record, Playing Chess, the Canadian singer pays homage to these greats (and the American label Chess Records that produced them) with intimate, pared-down interpretations of their hits. On the TED stage, she and her band performed Chuck Berry’s “You Never Can Tell,” “Over the Mountain,” first popularized by Johnnie and Joe, and a slinky cover of Fontella Bass’s sensational “Rescue Me.”

Truth comes from the collision of ideas. Legendary artistic director Oskar Eustis closes session 10 with a beautiful message about the place of theater in modern (and ancient) life. Theater and democracy were born together in Athens in the late sixth century BCE, when the idea that power should stem from the consent of the governed — from below to above, not the other way around — was reshaping the world. At the same time, people were exploring how the truth can best emerge from the conflict between two points of view. Through dialogue, empathy with characters and the experience of watching a performance together with others in the audience, the theater and democracy become parts of a whole. Fast-forward 2,500 years to when Joseph Papp founded The Public Theater. Papp wanted everyone in America to be able to experience theater — so he created free Shakespeare in the Park, based on the idea that the best art that we can produce should be available for everybody. Over the next decades, The Public brought art to the people with plays like The Normal Heart, Chorus Line and Angels in America, among many others. In 2005, when Eustis took over artistic direction, he took Shakespeare in the Park on the road, bringing theater to the people and making it about them. With Hamilton, Lin-Manuel Miranda tapped into this idea of art for the people as well. “What Lin was doing is exactly what Shakespeare was doing — he was taking the language of the people, elevating it into verse and by doing so ennobling the language and ennobling the people who spoke the language.” But we need to go a step further on this form of inclusion, Eustis says, outlining his plan to reach (and listen to) people in places across the United States where the theater, like so many other institutions, has turned its back — like the de-industrialized Rust Belt. “Our job is to try to hold up a vision to America that shows not only who all of us are individually but that welds us back into the commonality that we need to be,” Eustis says.


Planet Linux AustraliaDavid Rowe: Testing HAB Telemetry Protocols

On Saturday Mark and I had a pleasant day bench testing High Altitude Balloon (HAB) Telemetry protocols and demodulators.

Project Horus HAB flights use a low power transmitter to send regular updates of the balloons position and status. To date, this has been sent using RTTY, and demodulated using Fldigi, or a special version modified for HAB work called dl-Fldigi.

Lora is becoming common in HAB circles, however I am confident we can do better using a custom protocol and well engineered, and most importantly – open source – modems. While very well designed and conveniently packaged, Lora is not magic – modem performance is defined by physics.

A few year ago, Mark and I developed and flight tested a binary protocol (Horus Binary) for HAB flights. We have dusted this off, and I’ve written a C callable API (horus_api.c) to make Horus RTTY and Binary easy to use. The plan is to release a cross platform GUI application that supports Horus Binary, so anyone with a SSB receiver can join in the fun of tracking Horus flights using Horus Binary.

A good HAB telemetry protocol works at low SNRs, and has fast updates to allow accurate positioning of the payload during the final decent. A way of measuring the performance is Packet Error Rate (PER) – how many telemetry packets get through at a given Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR).

So we generated some synthetic Horus RTTY and Binary packets at calibrated SNRs using GNU Octave simulation code (fsk_horus.m), then played the wave files through several modems.

Here are the results (click for a larger version):

The X-axis is in Eb/No, which is proportional to SNR:

  SNR = EBNodB + 10log10(Rb/BW)

where Rb is the bit rate and BW is the noise bandwidth you want to measure SNR in. Eb/No is handy as it normalises for the effect of bit rate and noise bandwidth, making modem comparison easier.

Protocol dl-Fldigi
(50% PER)
13.0 12.0 11.5 4.5
Rb 100 100 100 200
SNR (3000Hz) -1.7 -2.7 -3.2 -7.2
6 6 6 1.6
Wave File Listen Listen Listen Listen


The older dl-Fldigi is a few dB behind the more modern Fldigi. Our Horus RTTY and especially Binary protocols are doing very well. At the same bit rate (Eb/No curve), Horus Binary is 9dB ahead of dl-Fldigi, which is a very useful gain; at least double the Line of Site (LOS) range, and equivalent to having nearly 10x the transmit power. The Binary packets are fast as well, allowing for rapid position updates in the final descent.

Trade offs are possible, for example if we slowed Horus Binary to 50 bits/s, it’s packet duration would be 6.4s (about the same as RTTY) however 50% PER would occur at a SNR of -13dB, a 15dB improvement over dl-Fldigi.

Reading Further

Project Horus
Binary Telemetry Protocol
All Your Modem are Belong To Us
SNR and Eb/No Worked Example

Planet DebianHideki Yamane: Of course it runs NetBSD

“Of course it runs NetBSD”

Note: It runs Debian squeeze chroot on NetBSD 7.1.2, with Linux emulation

Planet DebianThorsten Glaser: mksh on Jehanne, a guest post by Shamar

Giacomo Tesio referenced mksh(1) in his annual Jehanne report and provided a guest post (dated 2018-01-09, sorry for posting it this late only) for us on his journey on porting mksh to Jehanne, his Plan 9 derivative operating system. Read on for his story!

(read more…)

Planet DebianRuss Allbery: Free software log (March 2018)

I did get a few software releases out this month, although not as much as I'd planned and I still have a lot of new releases pending that are waiting for me to have a bit more free time.

control-archive got a 1.8.0 release, which catches up from accumulated changes over the past year plus and falls back to GnuPG v1 for signature processing. One of the projects that I'd like to find time for is redoing all of my scattered code for making and checking Usenet control messages.

DocKnot 1.03 adds more support for SPDX license identifiers, which I've started using in my projects, and then 1.04 was a quick bug fix release for something I broke in the test suite on Windows systems.

I also redid the Kerberos authentication plugin for INN to use modern Kerberos APIs, which cleared up some build issues when pointing at non-system Kerberos libraries.

Planet DebianDirk Eddelbuettel: #18: Adding Intel MKL easily via a simple script

Welcome to the eighteenth post in the rarely riveting R ramblings series of posts, or R4 for short.

The Intel Math Kernel Library (MKL) is well-know high(er) performance math library tailored for Intel CPUs offering best-in-class numerical performance on a number of low-level operations (BLAS, LAPACK, ...). They are not open source, used to be under commerical or research-only licenses --- but can now be had (still subject to license terms you should study) via apt-get (and even yum). This page describe the installation of the MKL (and other components) in detail (but stops short of the system integration aspect we show here).

Here we present one short script, discussed in detail below, to add the MKL to your Debian or Ubuntu system. Its main advantages are

  • clean standard code using package management tools;
  • additional steps to make it the the system default; and
  • with an option for clean removal leaning again on the package management system.

We put the script and a largely identical to this writeup into this GitHub repo where issues, comments, questions, ... should be filed.

MKL for .deb-based systems: An easy recipe

This post describes how to easily install the Intel Math Kernel Library (MKL) on a Debian or Ubuntu system. Very good basic documentation is provided by Intel at their site. The discussion here is more narrow as it focusses just on the Math Kernel Library (MKL).

The tl;dr version: Use this script which contains the commands described here.

First Step: Set up apt

We download the GnuPG key first and add it to the keyring:

cd /tmp

To add all Intel products we would run first command, but here we focus just on the MKL. The website above lists other suboptions (TBB, DAAL, MPI, ...)

## all products:
#wget -O /etc/apt/sources.list.d/intelproducts.list

## just MKL
sh -c 'echo deb all main > /etc/apt/sources.list.d/intel-mkl.list'

We then update our lists of what is available in the repositories.

apt-get update

As a personal aside, I still use the awesome wajig frontend to dpkg, apt and more by Graham Williams (of rattle fame). Among other tricks, wajig keeps state and therefore "knows" what packages are new. Here, we see a lot:

edd@rob:/tmp$ wajig update
Hit:1 artful InRelease
Ign:2 stable InRelease
Hit:3 artful-updates InRelease
Hit:4 artful InRelease
Hit:5 artful-backports InRelease
Ign:6 artful/ InRelease
Hit:7 artful/ Release
Hit:8 artful-security InRelease
Hit:9 all InRelease
Hit:10 stable Release
Hit:12 jessie InRelease
Reading package lists... Done
This is 367 up on the previous count with 367 new packages.
edd@rob:/tmp$ wajig new
Package                  Description
intel-mkl-gnu-f-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-174   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-196      Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-c-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-f-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-rt-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-239        Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-ps-libs-32bit-jp-174 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-doc-ps-2018    Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-rt-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-cluster-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-ps-libs-jp-196 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-rt-174  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-ps-libs-jp-239 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 5 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-f-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-mic-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-64bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-f95-common-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-psxe-common-2018.2-046 Intel(R) Parallel Studio XE 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-cluster-rt-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-64bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-196     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-tbb-libs-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks 2018 for Linux*
intel-comp-l-all-vars-196 Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-ps-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-f-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-f95-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-openmp-18.0.0-128  OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-ps-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-f95-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-mic-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-c-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-doc-f-jp    Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-f-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-32bit-2018.1-038 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-all-196   OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-rt-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-comp-nomcu-vars-18.0.0-128 Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-64bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-32bit-174  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-ps-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-rt-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-f-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-174   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-196  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-tbb-libs-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-tbb-libs-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-f-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-rt-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-196            Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-196     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-psxe-2018.2-046 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-doc-c          Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-196     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-tbb-libs-174       Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-comp-l-all-vars-174 Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-rt-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-174     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-ps-libs-32bit-jp-196 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-rt-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-openmp-18.0.1-163  OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-64bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-c-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-rt-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-2018.2-046     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-239     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-comp-l-all-vars-18.0.0-128 Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-jp-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-openmp-32bit-18.0.0-128 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 for Linux*
intel-mkl-f95-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-ps-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-tbb-mic-rt-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-psxe-2018.1-038 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-174     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-64bit-2017.4-061 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-rt-jp-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-196        Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-psxe-common-doc-2018 Intel(R) Parallel Studio XE 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-tbb-mic-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-c-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-c-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-rt-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-rt-jp-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-c-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-rt-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-f-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-psxe-050       Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-64bit-2018.2-046 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-rt-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-rt-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-doc-f       Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-174      Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-common-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-rt-jp-196   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-rt-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-f-196   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-tbb-libs-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-64bit-2018.0-033 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-c-239   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-239  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-64bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-openmp-32bit-18.0.2-199 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-rt-jp-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-rt-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-jp-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-tbb-mic-rt-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-psxe-common-061    Intel(R) Parallel Studio XE 2017 Update 5 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-f-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-cluster-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-f-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-tbb-libs-196       Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks 2017 Update 6 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-rt-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-rt-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-all-174   OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-c-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-64bit-2018.1-038 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-f95-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-239            Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-rt-174  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-f-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-common-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-f-64bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-common-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-f-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-jp-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-all-32bit-196 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-rt-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-psxe-common-056    Intel(R) Parallel Studio XE 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-32bit-2018.0-033 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-comp-l-all-vars-18.0.2-199 Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-ps-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-rt-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-c-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-ps-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-rt-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-f95-common-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-all-239   OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 5 for Linux*
intel-mkl-174            Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-rt-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-tbb-libs-239       Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks 2017 Update 8 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-f-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-f-64bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-common-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-comp-nomcu-vars-18.0.2-199 Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-32bit-196      Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-196   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-ps-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-196     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-rt-174         Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-rt-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-f-64bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-rt-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-c-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-doc         Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-rt-32bit-239   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-ps-libs-174 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-rt-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-64bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-c-196   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-239   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-f-239   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-c-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-rt-jp-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-64bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-rt-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-c-174   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-f-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-32bit-239      Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-rt-jp-174   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-239     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-tbb-libs-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-f95-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-ps-libs-239 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 5 for Linux*
intel-mkl-rt-239         Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-c-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-all-32bit-174 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-239     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-rt-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-rt-32bit-196   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-196     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-rt-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-32bit-239  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-174  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-c-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-rt-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-common-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-f-239   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-196  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-ps-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-64bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-64bit-2017.3-056 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-32bit-2017.4-061 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-64bit-2017.2-050 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-rt-196  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-c-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-rt-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-239     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-2017.3-056     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-f-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-rt-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-all-32bit-239 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 5 for Linux*
intel-mkl-rt-196         Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-f-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-2017.4-061     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-239   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-psxe-common-doc    Intel(R) Parallel Studio XE 2017 Update 5 for Linux*
intel-tbb-libs-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-2017.2-050     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-tbb-mic-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-2018.1-038     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-ps-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-tbb-mic-rt-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-rt-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-f-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-psxe-061       Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-rt-jp-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-ps-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-doc-jp      Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-rt-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-f-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-rt-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-rt-239  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-ps-libs-196 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-196   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-32bit-196  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-openmp-18.0.2-199  OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-openmp-32bit-18.0.1-163 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-174     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-comp-l-all-vars-239 Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 5 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-c-196   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-f-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-174  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-c-174   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-rt-jp-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-psxe-common-2018.0-033 Intel(R) Parallel Studio XE 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-mic-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-64bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-psxe-056       Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-c-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-comp-l-all-vars-18.0.1-163 Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-psxe-2018.0-033 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-f95-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-ps-libs-jp-174 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-rt-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-f-174   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-2018.0-033     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-239     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-doc            Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-c-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-f-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-c-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-tbb-mic-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-sta-common-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-32bit-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-f-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-32bit-2018.2-046 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-f-196   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-239      Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-doc-c-jp    Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-rt-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-doc-2018       Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-c-239   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-rt-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-common-239  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-f95-common-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-c-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-cluster-rt-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-cluster-f-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-f-174   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-c-ps-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-common-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-32bit-2017.3-056 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-rt-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-eula-174       Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-rt-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-rt-196  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-psxe-common-2018.1-038 Intel(R) Parallel Studio XE 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-f-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-ps-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-rt-jp-239   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-pgi-rt-239  Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-32bit-2017.2-050 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-f-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-pgi-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-comp-nomcu-vars-18.0.1-163 Intel(R) Compilers 18.0 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-f-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-tbb-rt-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-common-174     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-c-32bit-2018.2-199 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-cluster-rt-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-174     Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-core-2018.1-163 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 Update 1 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-gnu-f-32bit-196 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 3 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-f95-32bit-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-mic-cluster-174 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-psxe-common-050    Intel(R) Parallel Studio XE 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-cluster-c-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-rt-32bit-174   Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-mkl-32bit-174      Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*
intel-openmp-l-ps-libs-32bit-jp-239 OpenMP for Intel(R) Compilers 17.0 Update 5 for Linux*
intel-mkl-ps-ss-tbb-rt-32bit-239 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 4 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-f-rt-32bit-2018.0-128 Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2018 for Linux*
intel-mkl-gnu-174        Intel(R) Math Kernel Library 2017 Update 2 for Linux*

Install MKL

Now that we have everything set up, installing the MKL is as simple as:

apt-get install intel-mkl-64bit-2018.2-046

This picks the 64-bit only variant of the (currently) most recent builds.

There is a slight cost: a 500mb download of 39 packages which install to 1.9 gb! Other than that it is easy: one command! Compare that with the days of yore when we fetched shar archives of NETLIB...

Integrate MKL

One the key advantages of a Debian or Ubuntu system is the overall integration providing a raft of useful features. One of these is the seamless and automatic selection of alternatives. By declaring a particular set of BLAS and LAPACK libraries the default, all application linked against this interface will use the default. Better still, users can switch between these as well.

So here we can make the MKL default for BLAS and LAPACK:

## update alternatives
update-alternatives --install /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/     \
                /opt/intel/mkl/lib/intel64/ 50
update-alternatives --install /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/   \
              /opt/intel/mkl/lib/intel64/ 50
update-alternatives --install /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/   \
              /opt/intel/mkl/lib/intel64/ 50
update-alternatives --install /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/ \
            /opt/intel/mkl/lib/intel64/ 50

Next, we have to tell the dyanmic linker about two directories use by the MKL, and have it update its cache:

echo "/opt/intel/lib/intel64"     >  /etc/
echo "/opt/intel/mkl/lib/intel64" >> /etc/

Use the MKL

Now the MKL is 'known' and the default. If we start R, its sessionInfo() shows the MKL:

# Matrix products: default                            
# BLAS/LAPACK: /opt/intel/compilers_and_libraries_2018.2.199/linux/mkl/lib/intel64_lin/        


# Vanilla r-base Rocker with default reference BLAS 
> n <- 1e3 ; X <- matrix(rnorm(n*n),n,n);  system.time(svd(X)) 
   user  system elapsed 
  2.239   0.004   2.266 

# OpenBlas added to r-base Rocker
>  n <- 1e3 ; X <- matrix(rnorm(n*n),n,n);  system.time(svd(X)) 
   user  system elapsed 
  1.367   2.297   0.353 

# MKL added to r-base Rocker
> n <- 1e3 ; X <- matrix(rnorm(n*n),n,n)  
> system.time(svd(X))                               
   user  system elapsed                             
  1.772   0.056   0.350                             

So just R (with reference BLAS) is slow. (Using Docker is done here to have clean comparisons while not altering the outer host system; impact of running Docker on Linux should be minimal.) Adding OpenBLAS helps quite a bit already by offering multi-core processing -- the, and MKL does not yet improve materially over OpenBLAS. Now, this of course was not any serious benchmarking---we just ran one SVD. More to do as time permits...

Removal, if needed

Another rather nice benefit of the package management is that clean removal is also possible:

root@c9f8062fbd93:/tmp# apt-get autoremove intel-mkl-64bit-2018.2-046
Reading package lists... Done
Building dependency tree       
Reading state information... Done
The following packages will be REMOVED:
  intel-comp-l-all-vars-18.0.2-199 intel-comp-nomcu-vars-18.0.2-199 intel-mkl-64bit-2018.2-046 
  intel-mkl-cluster-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-cluster-c-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-cluster-common-2018.2-199 
  intel-mkl-cluster-f-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-cluster-rt-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-common-2018.2-199 
  intel-mkl-common-c-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-common-c-ps-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-common-f-2018.2-199 
  intel-mkl-common-ps-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-core-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-core-c-2018.2-199 
  intel-mkl-core-f-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-core-ps-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-core-rt-2018.2-199 
  intel-mkl-doc-2018 intel-mkl-doc-ps-2018 intel-mkl-f95-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-f95-common-2018.2-199 
  intel-mkl-gnu-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-gnu-c-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-gnu-f-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-gnu-f-rt-2018.2-199 
  intel-mkl-gnu-rt-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-pgi-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-pgi-c-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-pgi-f-2018.2-199 
  intel-mkl-pgi-rt-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-psxe-2018.2-046 intel-mkl-tbb-2018.2-199 intel-mkl-tbb-rt-2018.2-199 
  intel-openmp-18.0.2-199 intel-psxe-common-2018.2-046 intel-psxe-common-doc-2018 intel-tbb-libs-2018.2-199 
  intel-tbb-libs-32bit-2018.2-199 libisl15
0 upgraded, 0 newly installed, 40 to remove and 0 not upgraded.
After this operation, 1,904 kB disk space will be freed.
Do you want to continue? [Y/n] n                    

where we said 'no' just to illustrate the option.


Package management systems are fabulous. Kudos to Intel for supporting apt (and also yum in case you are on an rpm-based system). We can install the MKL with just a few commands (which we regrouped in this script).

The MKL has a serious footprint with an installed size of just under 2gb. But for those doing extended amounts of numerical analysis, installing this library may well be worth it.

This post by Dirk Eddelbuettel originated on his Thinking inside the box blog. Please report excessive re-aggregation in third-party for-profit settings.

Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: On Selecting a Well Engaged Open Source Vendor


Aptira is in an interesting position in the Open Source market, because we don’t usually sell software. Instead, our customers come to us seeking assistance with deciding which OpenStack to use, or how to embed ONAP into their nationwide networks, or how to move their legacy networks to the software defined future. Therefore, our most common role is as a trusted advisor to help our customers decide which Open Source products to buy.

(My boss would insist that I point out here that we do customisation of Open Source for our customers, and have assisted many in the past with deploying pure upstream solutions. Basically, we do what is the right fit for the customer, and aren’t obsessed with fitting customers into pre-defined moulds that suit our partners.)

That makes it important that we recommend products from companies that are well engaged with their upstream Open Source communities. That might be OpenStack, or ONAP, or even something like Open Daylight. This raises the obvious question – what makes a company well engaged with an upstream project?

Read more over at my employer’s blog


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: Escaping from blosxom


I’ve been running my personal blog on a very hacked version of blosxom for a hilariously long time, and its time to escape. I’ve therefore started converting all of the content to wordpress here, and will eventually redirect the old domain to here as well.

Why blogging when its so 2000? I’m increasingly disinterested in social media like Facebook and Twitter. I figure if I’m going to note something down that looks like it might be useful to others I’ll put it on ye olde blog instead.

I’m sure the conversion isn’t perfect, and I’ve decided not to migrate very old content that simply not interesting any more (linux kernel patches from 2004 for example). If you find a post which has converted badly, just comment on it and I’ll do something about it. I am very sure that pretty much no one will do that thing however.


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: Hugo nominees for 2018


Lifehacker kindly pointed out that the Hugo nominees are out for 2018. They are:

  • The Collapsing Empire, by John Scalzi. I’ve read this one and liked it.
  • New York 2140, by Kim Stanley Robinson. I’ve had a difficult time with Kim’s work in the past, but perhaps I’ll one day read this.
  • Provenance, by Ann Leckie. I liked Ancillary Justice, but failed to fully read the sequel, so I guess we’ll wait and see on this one.
  • Raven Stratagem, by Yoon Ha Lee. I know nothing!
  • Six Wakes, by Mur Lafferty. Again, I know nothing about this book or this author.

So a few there to consider in the future.


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: Giving serial devices meaningful names


This is a hack I’ve been using for ages, but I thought it deserved a write up.

I have USB serial devices. Lots of them. I use them for home automation things, as well as for talking to devices such as the console ports on switches and so forth. For the permanently installed serial devices one of the challenges is having them show up in predictable places so that the scripts which know how to drive each device are talking in the right place.

For the trivial case, this is pretty easy with udev:

$  cat /etc/udev/rules.d/60-local.rules
KERNEL=="ttyUSB*", \
    ATTRS{idVendor}=="0403", ATTRS{idProduct}=="6001", \
    ATTRS{serial}=="A8003Ye7", \

This says for any USB serial device that is discovered (either inserted post boot, or at boot), if the USB vendor and product ID match the relevant values, to symlink the device to “/dev/radish”.

You find out the vendor and product ID from lsusb like this:

$ lsusb
Bus 003 Device 003: ID 0624:0201 Avocent Corp.
Bus 003 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0002 Linux Foundation 2.0 root hub
Bus 007 Device 002: ID 0665:5161 Cypress Semiconductor USB to Serial
Bus 007 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0001 Linux Foundation 1.1 root hub
Bus 006 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0001 Linux Foundation 1.1 root hub
Bus 002 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0002 Linux Foundation 2.0 root hub
Bus 005 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0001 Linux Foundation 1.1 root hub
Bus 001 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0002 Linux Foundation 2.0 root hub
Bus 004 Device 002: ID 0403:6001 Future Technology Devices International, Ltd FT232 Serial (UART) IC
Bus 004 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0001 Linux Foundation 1.1 root hub
Bus 009 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0003 Linux Foundation 3.0 root hub
Bus 008 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0002 Linux Foundation 2.0 root hub

You can play with inserting and removing the device to determine which of these entries is the device you care about.

So that’s great, until you have more than one device with the same USB serial vendor and product id. Then things are a bit more… difficult.

It turns out that you can have udev execute a command on device insert to help you determine what symlink to create. So for example, I have this entry in the rules on one of my machines:

KERNEL=="ttyUSB*", \
    ATTRS{idVendor}=="067b", ATTRS{idProduct}=="2303", \
    PROGRAM="/usr/bin/usbtest /dev/%k", \

This results in /usr/bin/usbtest being run with the path of the device file on its command line for every device detection (of a matching device). The stdout of that program is then used as the name of a symlink in /dev.

So, that script attempts to talk to the device and determine what it is — in my case either a currentcost or a solar panel inverter.


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: Configuring docker to use rexray and Ceph for persistent storage


For various reasons I wanted to play with docker containers backed by persistent Ceph storage. rexray seemed like the way to do that, so here are my notes on getting that working…

First off, I needed to install rexray:

    root@labosa:~/rexray# curl -sSL | sh
    Selecting previously unselected package rexray.
    (Reading database ... 177547 files and directories currently installed.)
    Preparing to unpack rexray_0.9.0-1_amd64.deb ...
    Unpacking rexray (0.9.0-1) ...
    Setting up rexray (0.9.0-1) ...
    rexray has been installed to /usr/bin/rexray
    Binary: /usr/bin/rexray
    Flavor: client+agent+controller
    SemVer: 0.9.0
    OsArch: Linux-x86_64
    Branch: v0.9.0
    Commit: 2a7458dd90a79c673463e14094377baf9fc8695e
    Formed: Thu, 04 May 2017 07:38:11 AEST
    SemVer: 0.6.0
    OsArch: Linux-x86_64
    Branch: v0.9.0
    Commit: fa055d6da595602715bdfd5541b4aa6d4dcbcbd9
    Formed: Thu, 04 May 2017 07:36:11 AEST

Which is of course horrid. What that script seems to have done is install a deb’d version of rexray based on an alien’d package:

    root@labosa:~/rexray# dpkg -s rexray
    Package: rexray
    Status: install ok installed
    Priority: extra
    Section: alien
    Installed-Size: 36140
    Maintainer: Travis CI User <travis@testing-gce-7fbf00fc-f7cd-4e37-a584-810c64fdeeb1>
    Architecture: amd64
    Version: 0.9.0-1
    Depends: libc6 (>= 2.3.2)
    Description: Tool for managing remote & local storage.
     A guest based storage introspection tool that
     allows local visibility and management from cloud
     and storage platforms.
     (Converted from a rpm package by alien version 8.86.)

If I was building anything more than a test environment I think I’d want to do a better job of installing rexray than this, so you’ve been warned.

Next to configure rexray to use Ceph. The configuration details are cunningly hidden in the libstorage docs, and aren’t mentioned at all in the rexray docs, so you probably want to take a look at the libstorage docs on ceph. First off, we need to install the ceph tools, and copy the ceph authentication information from the the ceph we installed using openstack-ansible earlier.

    root@labosa:/etc# apt-get install ceph-common
    root@labosa:/etc# scp -rp .
    The authenticity of host ' (' can't be established.
    ECDSA key fingerprint is SHA256:SA6U2fuXyVbsVJIoCEHL+qlQ3xEIda/MDOnHOZbgtnE.
    Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)? yes
    Warning: Permanently added '' (ECDSA) to the list of known hosts.
    rbdmap                       100%   92     0.1KB/s   00:00
    ceph.conf                    100%  681     0.7KB/s   00:00
    ceph.client.admin.keyring    100%   63     0.1KB/s   00:00
    ceph.client.glance.keyring   100%   64     0.1KB/s   00:00
    ceph.client.cinder.keyring   100%   64     0.1KB/s   00:00
    ceph.client.cinder-backup.keyring   71     0.1KB/s   00:00
    root@labosa:/etc# modprobe rbd

You also need to configure rexray. My first attempt looked like this:

    root@labosa:/var/log# cat /etc/rexray/config.yml
      service: ceph

And the rexray output sure made it look like it worked…

    root@labosa:/etc# rexray service start
    ● rexray.service - rexray
       Loaded: loaded (/etc/systemd/system/rexray.service; enabled; vendor preset: enabled)
       Active: active (running) since Mon 2017-05-29 10:14:07 AEST; 33ms ago
     Main PID: 477423 (rexray)
        Tasks: 5
       Memory: 1.5M
          CPU: 9ms
       CGroup: /system.slice/rexray.service
               └─477423 /usr/bin/rexray start -f
    May 29 10:14:07 labosa systemd[1]: Started rexray.

Which looked good, but /var/log/syslog said:

    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: REX-Ray
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: -------
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: Binary: /usr/bin/rexray
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: Flavor: client+agent+controller
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: SemVer: 0.9.0
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: OsArch: Linux-x86_64
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: Branch: v0.9.0
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: Commit: 2a7458dd90a79c673463e14094377baf9fc8695e
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: Formed: Thu, 04 May 2017 07:38:11 AEST
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: libStorage
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: ----------
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: SemVer: 0.6.0
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: OsArch: Linux-x86_64
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: Branch: v0.9.0
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: Commit: fa055d6da595602715bdfd5541b4aa6d4dcbcbd9
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: Formed: Thu, 04 May 2017 07:36:11 AEST
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: time="2017-05-29T10:14:08+10:00" level=error
    msg="error starting libStorage server" error.driver=ceph time=1496016848215
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: time="2017-05-29T10:14:08+10:00" level=error
    msg="default module(s) failed to initialize" error.driver=ceph time=1496016848216
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: time="2017-05-29T10:14:08+10:00" level=error
    msg="daemon failed to initialize" error.driver=ceph time=1496016848216
    May 29 10:14:08 labosa rexray[477423]: time="2017-05-29T10:14:08+10:00" level=error
    msg="error starting rex-ray" error.driver=ceph time=1496016848216

That’s because the service is called rbd it seems. So, the config file ended up looking like this:

    root@labosa:/var/log# cat /etc/rexray/config.yml
      service: rbd
      defaultPool: rbd

Now to install docker:

    root@labosa:/var/log# sudo apt-get update
    root@labosa:/var/log# sudo apt-get install linux-image-extra-$(uname -r) \
    root@labosa:/var/log# sudo apt-get install apt-transport-https \
        ca-certificates curl software-properties-common
    root@labosa:/var/log# curl -fsSL | sudo apt-key add -
    root@labosa:/var/log# sudo add-apt-repository \
        "deb [arch=amd64] \
        $(lsb_release -cs) \
    root@labosa:/var/log# sudo apt-get update
    root@labosa:/var/log# sudo apt-get install docker-ce

Now let’s make a rexray volume.

    root@labosa:/var/log# rexray volume ls
    ID  Name  Status  Size
    root@labosa:/var/log# docker volume create --driver=rexray --name=mysql \
    A size of 1 here means 1gb
    root@labosa:/var/log# rexray volume ls
    ID         Name   Status     Size
    rbd.mysql  mysql  available  1

Let’s start the container.

    root@labosa:/var/log# docker run --name some-mysql --volume-driver=rexray \
        -v mysql:/var/lib/mysql -e MYSQL_ROOT_PASSWORD=my-secret-pw -d mysql
    Unable to find image 'mysql:latest' locally
    latest: Pulling from library/mysql
    10a267c67f42: Pull complete
    c2dcc7bb2a88: Pull complete
    17e7a0445698: Pull complete
    9a61839a176f: Pull complete
    a1033d2f1825: Pull complete
    0d6792140dcc: Pull complete
    cd3adf03d6e6: Pull complete
    d79d216fd92b: Pull complete
    b3c25bdeb4f4: Pull complete
    02556e8f331f: Pull complete
    4bed508a9e77: Pull complete
    Digest: sha256:2f4b1900c0ee53f344564db8d85733bd8d70b0a78cd00e6d92dc107224fc84a5
    Status: Downloaded newer image for mysql:latest

And now to prove that persistence works and that there’s nothing up my sleeve…

    root@labosa:/var/log# docker run -it --link some-mysql:mysql --rm mysql \
        sh -c 'exec mysql -h"$MYSQL_PORT_3306_TCP_ADDR" \
    mysql: [Warning] Using a password on the command line interface can be insecure.
    Welcome to the MySQL monitor.  Commands end with ; or \g.
    Your MySQL connection id is 3
    Server version: 5.7.18 MySQL Community Server (GPL)
    Copyright (c) 2000, 2017, Oracle and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved.
    Oracle is a registered trademark of Oracle Corporation and/or its
    affiliates. Other names may be trademarks of their respective
    Type 'help;' or '\h' for help. Type '\c' to clear the current input statement.
    mysql> show databases;
    | Database           |
    | information_schema |
    | mysql              |
    | performance_schema |
    | sys                |
    4 rows in set (0.00 sec)
    mysql> create database demo;
    Query OK, 1 row affected (0.03 sec)
    mysql> use demo;
    Database changed
    mysql> create table foo(val char(5));
    Query OK, 0 rows affected (0.14 sec)
    mysql> insert into foo(val) values ('a'), ('b'), ('c');
    Query OK, 3 rows affected (0.08 sec)
    Records: 3  Duplicates: 0  Warnings: 0
    mysql> select * from foo;
    | val  |
    | a    |
    | b    |
    | c    |
    3 rows in set (0.00 sec)

Now let’s re-create the container and prove the data remains.

    root@labosa:/var/log# docker stop some-mysql
    root@labosa:/var/log# docker rm some-mysql
    root@labosa:/var/log# docker run --name some-mysql --volume-driver=rexray \
        -v mysql:/var/lib/mysql -e MYSQL_ROOT_PASSWORD=my-secret-pw -d mysql
    root@labosa:/var/log# docker run -it --link some-mysql:mysql --rm mysql \
        sh -c 'exec mysql -h"$MYSQL_PORT_3306_TCP_ADDR" -\
    mysql: [Warning] Using a password on the command line interface can be insecure.
    Welcome to the MySQL monitor.  Commands end with ; or \g.
    Your MySQL connection id is 3
    Server version: 5.7.18 MySQL Community Server (GPL)
    Copyright (c) 2000, 2017, Oracle and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved.
    Oracle is a registered trademark of Oracle Corporation and/or its
    affiliates. Other names may be trademarks of their respective
    Type 'help;' or '\h' for help. Type '\c' to clear the current input statement.
    mysql> use demo;
    Reading table information for completion of table and column names
    You can turn off this feature to get a quicker startup with -A
    Database changed
    mysql> select * from foo;
    | val  |
    | a    |
    | b    |
    | c    |
    3 rows in set (0.00 sec)

So there you go.


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: I think I found a bug in python’s unittest.mock library


Mocking is a pretty common thing to do in unit tests covering OpenStack Nova code. Over the years we’ve used various mock libraries to do that, with the flavor de jour being unittest.mock. I must say that I strongly prefer unittest.mock to the old mox code we used to write, but I think I just accidentally found a fairly big bug.

The problem is that python mocks are magical. Its an object where you can call any method name, and the mock will happily pretend it has that method, and return None. You can then later ask what “methods” were called on the mock.

However, you use the same mock object later to make assertions about what was called. Herein is the problem — the mock object doesn’t know if you’re the code under test, or the code that’s making assertions. So, if you fat finger the assertion in your test code, the assertion will just quietly map to a non-existent method which returns None, and your code will pass.

Here’s an example:


from unittest import mock

class foo(object):
    def dummy(a, b):
        return a + b

@mock.patch.object(foo, 'dummy')
def call_dummy(mock_dummy):
    f = foo()
    f.dummy(1, 2)

    print('Asserting a call should work if the call was made')
    mock_dummy.assert_has_calls([, 2)])
    print('Assertion for expected call passed')

    print('Asserting a call should raise an exception if the call wasn\'t made')
    mock_worked = False
        mock_dummy.assert_has_calls([, 4)])
    except AssertionError as e:
        mock_worked = True
        print('Expected failure, %s' % e)

    if not mock_worked:
        print('*** Assertion should have failed ***')

    print('Asserting a call where the assertion has a typo should fail, but '
    mock_worked = False
        mock_dummy.typo_assert_has_calls([, 4)])
    except AssertionError as e:
        mock_worked = True
        print('Expected failure, %s' % e)

    if not mock_worked:
        print('*** Assertion should have failed ***')

if __name__ == '__main__':

If I run that code, I get this:

$ python3
Asserting a call should work if the call was made
Assertion for expected call passed

Asserting a call should raise an exception if the call wasn't made
Expected failure, Calls not found.
Expected: [call(3, 4)]
Actual: [call(1, 2)]

Asserting a call where the assertion has a typo should fail, but doesn't
*** Assertion should have failed ***
[call(1, 2), call.typo_assert_has_calls([call(3, 4)])]

So, we should have been told that typo_assert_has_calls isn’t a thing, but we didn’t notice because it silently failed. I discovered this when I noticed an assertion with a (smaller than this) typo in its call in a code review yesterday.

I don’t really have a solution to this right now (I’m home sick and not thinking straight), but it would be interesting to see what other people think.


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: The Collapsing Empire


This is a fun fast read, as is everything by Mr Scalzi. The basic premise here is that of a set of interdependent colonies that are about to lose their ability to trade with each other, and are therefore doomed. Oh, except they don’t know that and are busy having petty trade wars instead. It isn’t a super intellectual read, but it is fun and does leave me wanting to know what happens to the empire…

The Collapsing Empire Book Cover The Collapsing Empire
John Scalzi
Tor Books
March 21, 2017

Our universe is ruled by physics and faster than light travel is not possible—until the discovery of The Flow, an extra-dimensional field we can access at certain points in space-time that transport us to other worlds, around other stars. Humanity flows away from Earth, into space, and in time forgets our home world and creates a new empire, the Interdependency, whose ethos requires that no one human outpost can survive without the others. It’s a hedge against interstellar war—and a system of control for the rulers of the empire. The Flow is eternal—but it is not static. Just as a river changes course, The Flow changes as well, cutting off worlds from the rest of humanity. When it’s discovered that The Flow is moving, possibly cutting off all human worlds from faster than light travel forever, three individuals -- a scientist, a starship captain and the Empress of the Interdependency—are in a race against time to discover what, if anything, can be salvaged from an interstellar empire on the brink of collapse. “John Scalzi is the most entertaining, accessible writer working in SF today.” —Joe Hill "If anyone stands at the core of the American science fiction tradition at the moment, it is Scalzi." —The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction, Third Edition


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: Python3 venvs for people who are old and grumpy


I’ve been using virtualenvwrapper to make venvs for python2 for probably six or so years. I know it, and understand it. Now some bad man (hi Ramon!) is making me do python3, and virtualenvwrapper just isn’t a thing over there as best as I can tell.

So how do I make a venv? Its really not too bad…

First, install the dependencies:

    git clone git:// .pyenv
    echo 'export PYENV_ROOT="$HOME/.pyenv"' >> ~/.bashrc
    echo 'export PATH="$PYENV_ROOT/bin:$PATH"' >> ~/.bashrc
    echo 'eval "$(pyenv init -)"' >> ~/.bashrc
    git clone ~/.pyenv/plugins/pyenv-virtualenv
    source ~/.bashrc

Now to make a venv, do something like this (in this case, infrasot is the name of the venv):

    mkdir -p ~/.virtualenvs/pyenv-infrasot
    cd ~/.virtualenvs/pyenv-infrasot
    pyenv virtualenv system infrasot

You can see your installed venvs like this:

    $ pyenv versions
    * system (set by /home/user/.pyenv/version)

Where system is the system installed python, and not a venv. To activate and deactivate the venv, do this:

    $ pyenv activate infrasot
    $ ... stuff you're doing ...
    $ pvenv deactivate

I’ll probably write wrappers at some point so that this looks like virtualenvwrapper, but its good enough for now.


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: So you want to setup a Ceph dev environment using OSA


Support for installing and configuring Ceph was added to openstack-ansible in Ocata, so now that I have a need for a Ceph development environment it seems logical that I would build it by building an openstack-ansible Ocata AIO. There were a few gotchas there, so I want to explain the process I used.

First off, Ceph is enabled in an openstack-ansible AIO using a thing I’ve never seen before called a “Scenario”. Basically this means that you need to export an environment variable called “SCENARIO” before running the AIO install. Something like this will do the trick?L:

    export SCENARIO=ceph

Next you need to set the global pg_num in the ceph role or the install will fail. I did that with this patch:

    --- /etc/ansible/roles/ceph.ceph-common/defaults/main.yml       2017-05-26 08:55:07.803635173 +1000
    +++ /etc/ansible/roles/ceph.ceph-common/defaults/main.yml       2017-05-26 08:58:30.417019878 +1000
    @@ -338,7 +338,9 @@
     #     foo: 1234
     #     bar: 5678
    -ceph_conf_overrides: {}
    +  global:
    +    osd_pool_default_pg_num: 8
    @@ -373,4 +375,4 @@
     # Set this to true to enable File access via NFS.  Requires an MDS role.
     nfs_file_gw: true
     # Set this to true to enable Object access via NFS. Requires an RGW role.
    -nfs_obj_gw: false
    \ No newline at end of file
    +nfs_obj_gw: false

That of course needs to be done after the Ceph role has been fetched, but before it is executed, so in other words after the AIO bootstrap, but before the install.

And that was about it (although of course that took a fair while to work out). I have this automated in my little install helper thing, so I’ll never need to think about it again which is nice.

Once Ceph is installed, you interact with it via the monitor container, not the utility container, which is a bit odd. That said, all you really need is the Ceph config file and the Ceph utilities, so you could move those elsewhere.

    root@labosa:/etc/openstack_deploy# lxc-attach -n aio1_ceph-mon_container-a3d8b8b1
    root@aio1-ceph-mon-container-a3d8b8b1:/# ceph -s
        cluster 24424319-b5e9-49d2-a57a-6087ab7f45bd
         health HEALTH_OK
         monmap e1: 1 mons at {aio1-ceph-mon-container-a3d8b8b1=}
                election epoch 3, quorum 0 aio1-ceph-mon-container-a3d8b8b1
         osdmap e20: 3 osds: 3 up, 3 in
                flags sortbitwise,require_jewel_osds
          pgmap v36: 40 pgs, 5 pools, 0 bytes data, 0 objects
                102156 kB used, 3070 GB / 3070 GB avail
                      40 active+clean
    root@aio1-ceph-mon-container-a3d8b8b1:/# ceph osd tree
    -1 2.99817 root default
    -2 2.99817     host labosa
     0 0.99939         osd.0        up  1.00000          1.00000
     1 0.99939         osd.1        up  1.00000          1.00000
     2 0.99939         osd.2        up  1.00000          1.00000


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: Nova vendordata deployment, an excessively detailed guide


Nova presents configuration information to instances it starts via a mechanism called metadata. This metadata is made available via either a configdrive, or the metadata service. These mechanisms are widely used via helpers such as cloud-init to specify things like the root password the instance should use. There are three separate groups of people who need to be able to specify metadata for an instance.

User provided data

The user who booted the instance can pass metadata to the instance in several ways. For authentication keypairs, the keypairs functionality of the Nova APIs can be used to upload a key and then specify that key during the Nova boot API request. For less structured data, a small opaque blob of data may be passed via the user-data feature of the Nova API. Examples of such unstructured data would be the puppet role that the instance should use, or the HTTP address of a server to fetch post-boot configuration information from.

Nova provided data

Nova itself needs to pass information to the instance via its internal implementation of the metadata system. Such information includes the network configuration for the instance, as well as the requested hostname for the instance. This happens by default and requires no configuration by the user or deployer.

Deployer provided data

There is however a third type of data. It is possible that the deployer of OpenStack needs to pass data to an instance. It is also possible that this data is not known to the user starting the instance. An example might be a cryptographic token to be used to register the instance with Active Directory post boot — the user starting the instance should not have access to Active Directory to create this token, but the Nova deployment might have permissions to generate the token on the user’s behalf.

Nova supports a mechanism to add “vendordata” to the metadata handed to instances. This is done by loading named modules, which must appear in the nova source code. We provide two such modules:

  • StaticJSON: a module which can include the contents of a static JSON file loaded from disk. This can be used for things which don’t change between instances, such as the location of the corporate puppet server.
  • DynamicJSON: a module which will make a request to an external REST service to determine what metadata to add to an instance. This is how we recommend you generate things like Active Directory tokens which change per instance.

Tell me more about DynamicJSON

Having said all that, this post is about how to configure the DynamicJSON plugin, as I think its the most interesting bit here.

To use DynamicJSON, you configure it like this:

  • Add “DynamicJSON” to the vendordata_providers configuration option. This can also include “StaticJSON” if you’d like.
  • Specify the REST services to be contacted to generate metadata in the vendordata_dynamic_targets configuration option. There can be more than one of these, but note that they will be queried once per metadata request from the instance, which can mean a fair bit of traffic depending on your configuration and the configuration of the instance.

The format for an entry in vendordata_dynamic_targets is like this:


Where name is a short string not including the ‘@’ character, and where the URL can include a port number if so required. An example would be:


Metadata fetched from this target will appear in the metadata service at a new file called vendordata2.json, with a path (either in the metadata service URL or in the configdrive) like this:


For each dynamic target, there will be an entry in the JSON file named after that target. For example:

            "testing": {
                "value1": 1,
                "value2": 2,
                "value3": "three"

Do not specify the same name more than once. If you do, we will ignore subsequent uses of a previously used name.

The following data is passed to your REST service as a JSON encoded POST:

  • project-id: the UUID of the project that owns the instance
  • instance-id: the UUID of the instance
  • image-id: the UUID of the image used to boot this instance
  • user-data: as specified by the user at boot time
  • hostname: the hostname of the instance
  • metadata: as specified by the user at boot time

Deployment considerations

Nova provides authentication to external metadata services in order to provide some level of certainty that the request came from nova. This is done by providing a service token with the request — you can then just deploy your metadata service with the keystone authentication WSGI middleware. This is configured using the keystone authentication parameters in the vendordata_dynamic_auth configuration group.

This behaviour is optional however, if you do not configure a service user nova will not authenticate with the external metadata service.

Deploying the same vendordata service

There is a sample vendordata service that is meant to model what a deployer would use for their custom metadata at Deploying that service is relatively simple:

$ git clone
$ cd vendordata
$ apt-get install virtualenvwrapper
$ . /etc/bash_completion.d/virtualenvwrapper (only needed if virtualenvwrapper wasn't already installed)
$ mkvirtualenv vendordata
$ pip install -r requirements.txt

We need to configure the keystone WSGI middleware to authenticate against the right keystone service. There is a sample configuration file in git, but its configured to work with an openstack-ansible all in one install that I setup up for my private testing, which probably isn’t what you’re using:

insecure = False
auth_plugin = password
auth_url =
auth_uri =
project_domain_id = default
user_domain_id = default
project_name = service
username = nova
password = 5dff06ac0c43685de108cc799300ba36dfaf29e4
region_name = RegionOne

Per the README file in the vendordata sample repository, you can test the vendordata server in a stand alone manner by generating a token manually from keystone:

$ curl -d @credentials.json -H "Content-Type: application/json" > token.json
$ token=`cat token.json | python -c "import sys, json; print json.loads(['access']['token']['id'];"`

We then include that token in a test request to the vendordata service:

curl -H "X-Auth-Token: $token"

Configuring nova to use the external metadata service

Now we’re ready to wire up the sample metadata service with nova. You do that by adding something like this to the nova.conf configuration file:


Where is the IP address or hostname of the server running the external metadata service. Now if we boot an instance like this:

nova boot --image 2f6e96ca-9f58-4832-9136-21ed6c1e3b1f --flavor tempest1 --nic net-name=public --config-drive true foo

We end up with a config drive which contains the information or external metadata service returned (in the example case, handy Carrie Fischer quotes):

# cat openstack/latest/vendor_data2.json | python -m json.tool
    "testing": {
        "carrie_says": "I really love the internet. They say chat-rooms are the trailer park of the internet but I find it amazing."


Planet Linux AustraliaMichael Still: Things I read today: the best description I’ve seen of metadata routing in neutron


I happened upon a thread about OVN’s proposal for how to handle nova metadata traffic, which linked to this very good Suse blog post about how metadata traffic is routed in neutron. I’m just adding the link here because I think it will be useful to others. The OVN proposal is also an interesting read.


Planet Linux AustraliaOpenSTEM: Australia and the Commonwealth Games

Australia has been doing exceptionally well at the 2018 Commonwealth Games, held at the Gold Coast, Queensland. We can be very proud of our athletes, not only for their sporting prowess, but also because of their friendly demeanour and wonderful examples of the spirit of sportsmanship. I’m sure we all felt proud when the Australian […]

TEDSteelcase at TED2018: Here’s what a desk chair inspired by a TED Talk looks like

But would it be a dream to sit on? Steelcase showed off its SILQ Chair at TED2018: The Age of Amazement, April 10 – 14, 2018, Vancouver. Photo: Jason Redmond / TEDs

It’s only fitting that the chair which serves as the focal point of the Steelcase exhibit space at TED2018 was inspired, in part, by a TED Talk. Back at TED2009, Steelcase VP of Global Design and Product Engineering James Ludwig saw athlete and Paralympian Aimee Mullins speak about her different prostheses (TED Talk: My 12 pairs of legs). He was especially intrigued by her carbon-fiber “cheetah feet” and how they could store and release energy. He wondered: Could this wondrously light yet stiff yet flexible material — revolutionizing airplane, car and bicycle manufacturing — be used in a desk chair?

Carbon fiber hadn’t been used in mainstream furniture, but Ludwig was also bent on following a vision he’d had the previous year. The standard high-tech office chair had become what he calls “an exquisite machine” — consisting of up to 250 parts — but he’d tired of these contraptions. “I didn’t want to feel like I was sitting on a mechanical bull,” says Ludwig (can we get an amen?). He wanted to make a chair that was far simpler, so he sketched one that sat on “four leaf-like tendrils.” He had no idea how he’d build it, but that’s the task of industrial designers: envisioning what doesn’t exist — and then making it happen.

Mullins’s feet lingered in his mind, and he thought back to his dream seating and realized he might have found a solution. His next step was to see if a chair could even been made from carbon fiber. The result, which took him and his team several years to design and execute, was the LessThanFive, named because it weighs less than five pounds.

The game was on. In the Steelcase Innovation Center in Grand Rapids, Michigan, Ludwig found a corner space, papered the windows, gathered a handful of colleagues, and set to realizing the chair that he’d seen only in his mind. Six months later, he had a prototype. It was everything he wanted — responsive and streamlined — except for its price: it would be prohibitively expensive to produce. “Carbon fiber is a handicraft; it needs to be finished by hand,” explains Ludwig.

He told his engineers that they needed to figure out how to do it more cheaply. After some grumbling and sighing, they returned to work and created what Ludwig evasively refers to as a “proprietary fiber and material composition” — in other words, a patent-pending substance that was made from a high-performance polymer. Upholstery, molding and operations teams were called in, and 18 months later, Ludwig’s creation was released in January 2018: the SILQ chair.

He had a lofty mission: “I wanted it to look like Isamu Noguchi had an aerospace degree.” And with its soft curves and sculptural lines, it kind of does. It also drastically reduced the number of parts: just 30. The special polymer replaced many of the springs and hinges that provide flex and support in the typical desk chair. And in a welcome development to anyone who’s hit the wrong switch and made their chair plummet ridiculously during a meeting, it has only one lever that raises and lowers the seat.

But how does it feel? Well, when I sat in the SILQ, it felt like it was made for someone my size. In some sort of industrial-design wizardry, the back cradled my lower back and my head in the right spots — it was the opposite experience of sitting in an airplane seat where I always feel like I’m wearing someone else’s shoes. “This is a once-in-a-decade chair,” pronounces Ludwig.”It’s intuitive and material-based.” Maybe so, but to me, it was something much more special: comfortable.


TEDEnlightenment? Or entitlement? A response to Steven Pinker from a panel of TED Fellows

Linguist and psychologist Steven Pinker’s talk at the end of TED2018 Session 1 argued enthusiastically that humanity has, as a whole, made remarkable progress toward more prosperity, peace and happiness — backing up his assertions with charts that appeared to agree with his optimistic trajectory. But is that the whole story? We convened a roundtable of TED Fellows — including scientists and journalists — to articulate why they are troubled by some of Pinker’s ideas, as presented in his talk on Tuesday night, his larger body of work and, in particular, his attitude toward identity politics in the scientific field. Below, an edited transcript of the conversation

I watched Steven Pinker’s talk, and I listened to it again afterwards. If I hadn’t had personal run-ins with him, I would’ve thought most of what he said was okay. He presented a nice, sanitized version of his thoughts. So I can see how so many people aren’t fully engaged and critical of his larger body of work. Pinker presents a Western perspective of science in which brown people don’t exist — as if indigenous ways of knowing and non-Western canonized ways of science don’t exist. In his talk, he doesn’t even give it a nod, so it’s a less-than-complete story. –– Danielle Lee, evolutionary biologist

I just find that in his talk and in his work, he never unpacks his assumptions underlying the ways we interact with data. By not unpacking those, most people are not understanding how, then, his lens frames the data that he chooses — or the stories or the interpretations that he gets out of that data. That’s a larger issue in the sciences. There’s this idea that the scientific method is purely objective, and replicable. But it always starts with a subjective lens. — Michele Koppes, glaciologist

I do a lot of work in East Africa. The majority of my research on whitefly-borne cassava disease is there. Regarding cherry-picking data, what I experience on the ground around famine and electricity is very different from the picture Pinker presents. His electricity and famine slides didn’t seem to include African countries, but Africa was included in some others. The data didn’t add up. — Laura Boykin, computational biologist

The first graph he showed, to prove that news is so pessimistic now, was a graph starting in 1945. Yet almost all his other graphs started much earlier — 1300, 1751, and so on. Yes, of course — I think we can agree that life is a little better now than it was in the Middle Ages. That’s not the point that people have been making about how society has progressed since 1945. He ignores the stagnation that has happened — not just in the US, but around the world — when it comes to inequality. The number of people in jail, the fact that schools are still segregated as much as they were 40 years ago, don’t really fit into his narrative.

His critics all accept that we probably live better lives than we did in 1820, but that is entirely not the point. He gives very wealthy people an excuse to be like, “Well, things are fine, so I don’t have to do anything.” And as for his hypothesis that intellectuals don’t like progress, it’s entirely untrue: intellectuals just like to think about things with a little more nuance. — Trevor Timm, investigative journalist + free speech advocate

As humans — even intellectual ones — whenever we see a graph with some lines, everybody’s like, “Ah, science!” And it’s just not science. But it looks like it, and so you believe it. This is the problem with scientific integrity: you posit something, and you make it seem “objective” — which really just means positive toward your frame of reference — and everything else be damned. I thought it was interesting how he constructs this notion of, if you disagree, it’s because you don’t understand. So if someone has a counterpoint, it implies they have less understanding, less knowledge, and less critical thought — ”enlightenment,” as he says — than everybody else. So he’s now attacked everyone, and made it harder for folks to disagree, and also painted a skewed image.  — Jedidah Isler, astrophysicist

If you are going to present graphs and say, “Ooh, science,” I think maybe we should dig a little deeper into that, and say, “Let’s really look at the data.” Anybody who’s quantitative — and we have experts in this room—will tell us that you can’t just look at an average and say, “Yeah, that’s the whole story!” You have to look at things like the spread, and what is their distribution? How does it change over time? — Shohini Ghose, physicist

I just want to take it a little bit away from the book and the lecture, and talk about the science march. For me, in college as a zoology major, Pinker was one of my heroes with his book How the Mind Works. But there were some events around the March for Science and inclusivity that should have kept him from being here in the first place.  — Prosanta Chakrabarty, evolutionary biologist

I did not participate in the March for Science and I never officially supported it, precisely because I was waiting to see how its leaders were going to handle inclusiveness. There were people — just regular scientists — who came out early, saying, “Don’t you dare make this about inclusiveness and identity politics.” They were emboldened by Pinker, who came on hard supporting that stance.

The debate evolved a new hashtag called #MarginSci, which specifically focused on people from marginalized groups talking about why we needed inclusiveness in the March for Science. The march flip-flopped on the issue: basic inclusion — not even necessarily ethnic inclusion, but making sure the march would be accessible to people who had mobility issues, and so on.

Pinker came out saying that he thought that diversity and inclusion were simply identity politics, and that they were a waste of time. He attacked individuals as not authentically scientists. He made it clear that he was anti-identity, anti-inclusiveness. A few months later, he doubled down and said he would spend his career ruining us professionally for the work the we did with diversity and inclusion, because he’d thought we tried to break March for Science up. We didn’t — loads of us just backed away and didn’t participate.

He’s technically a scientific hero saying publicly we were all ridiculous for wanting to make science inclusive, to fight for science and where it stands in policy, and fighting for individual scientists and funding. His stance is that “identity politics” (he uses this phrase as a pejorative) — in other words, those of us who acknowledge and are proud of our identities and want our whole selves included — distracts from science, that it’s not a part of the scientific context, and it’s the antithesis of objectivity and merit in the science process.  — DL

Pinker frames science as this beautiful, pure thing: if you allow any form of identity discussion into it, it’s not science. To him, science is pure: the person, the practitioner, should not be in that argument. Those who do are at war on science.

I’m a geographer-glaciologist, and my work says we should have an inclusive, diverse range of voices in glaciology, to address the fact that this field really so far has had white male Western voices only. I use the phrase “feminist glaciology,” and that’s been the thing that Pinker’s had a hard time with, and pushes back on it in his book and in articles he writes. What’s sexier than to point out a war on science, and then point to feminist glaciology? It sure sounds ridiculous when you frame it that way.

If you read his book, there is no actual argument with the work I do. But he grabbed an example of an academic article that I coauthored with Glacier Lab members, slapped it in his book, and said, “Here is a war on science.” When I spoke with him last night, he didn’t know who I was — it’s not my work, it’s not me. He just used it as another example of this war on science. Glaciology has a very long history of marginalizing or erasing any other voices: not just women’s voices — indigenous voices, all voices. But that doesn’t mean that those voices didn’t participate, they just tended to get dismissed. If we don’t look at that, not only in glaciology, but across science, what is it that we’re actually making today? — M Jackson, geographer + glaciologist

May I just add to that point? Regarding the idea of the impunity of science: I haven’t read the whole book, but of particular concern to me was acknowledgement of the history of statistics. Pinker made the point that eugenics was almost a side tangent — and that it wasn’t the aim of science, and science is good. Having worked quite a lot on this history, the origins of statistics are in eugenics. Pinker briefly mentioned Galton, but when Galton and Pearson developed statistical regression, it was to study “regression to mediocrity.” Pearson held a chair in eugenics. He said the scientific approach was to improve nations by making sure people came from the “better stocks” and to wage war against “inferior races.” It’s important to have that historical context when we’re talking about scientific ideas. Science is not always a pure, objective thing. All those arguments for eugenics were data-driven and statistical, but we’ve got to acknowledge where modern statistical ideas came from, and their uncomfortable background. — Adam Kucharski, infectious disease scientist

Context matters, and I don’t think that’s part of his worldview at all. I think that even for Pinker to acknowledge that there’s more than one way to think about science is to acknowledge that identity matters. There isn’t a positioning of himself within that greater discourse because he already views himself as an objective scientist. Therefore he doesn’t need to try and unpack these other ideas. If you even try to engage with him and have a conversation that involves context mattering, or identity mattering, you get pushed aside because none of that is “pure science.” — MJ

He gives us two options: either you’re a pessimist, or you’re part of the new enlightenment. He never gives us the scientific third option — which is that he could be wrong. As a scientist, I am always thinking, “I could be wrong.” You’re not a good scientist if you can’t admit that. — LB

That’s the ultimate form of privilege, when you don’t have to acknowledge what your positionality is, what your worldview is, and just assume and move forward. We all get to push back on that, but we’ve already been dealt with, really. We’re over here, we’re “pessimists.” — MJ

He takes that privilege even further. On one hand, he says it shouldn’t be contextual, but of course, he is absolutely framing his stance in the context of his take on a European Enlightenment that’s driven all science. He then cherry-picks and claims all that science as what’s good, objective science, but leaves out all the “science” that led to things like eugenics, the justification of slavery and so on. He uses his privilege, and leaves out parts of his own context. — SG

A lot of this stuff has already been named and studied. People have written about white normativity, and how whiteness is rendered invisible in a way that it is the norm: you never even have to talk about it. So when you’re talking about people, you’re talking about white people, right? And any other people get an adjective.

We are at a significant disadvantage in the sciences because we don’t have the language to call this out for what it is. The field has to know more about how people work, how politics work, how sociology works, in order to recognize when the data — or lack of data — itself imprints a powerful bias on the conclusions drawn. — JI

We’re also representing the sciences that he deems nonscience. There is a whole field in the social sciences of critical theory and critical studies that does exactly this, that looks at these power and privilege dynamics within the sciences. We’re doing this in the field of geography right now. But he pushes back on that, as though it’s irrelevant — he sees a hierarchy of purity in the sciences. The highest of the sciences are the physical and the chemical — physics, and then it trickles down from there. — MK

He doesn’t realize that he has this huge platform — a lot of it which he did earn — but that he was three steps up the ladder from everyone else when he started. He became a great scientist, but he had benefits that he believes everybody has access to: that science is a democracy available to everyone equally.

That’s why it’s so offensive when he picks on women, and people of color, or anyone else who he thinks has a level playing field. His not recognizing that science is not a level playing field is the biggest problem. That, and his stance that life is better for the Steven Pinkers of the world, so he thinks life is better for everyone. — TT

That part of his talk drove me bananas, the “happiness curve.” How do you define happiness? He never said explicitly, but you could tell he had a definition of happiness in his head that he thought was shared with everybody in his audience. But there was never any question of, what does that mean? How are you defining that? — MK

I think that’s dead-on. His big assumption is that human beings are data points, not complex interacting communities. — MJ

There’s one talk I heard in Vancouver years ago by the Dalai Lama. He said that we need to consider the morality of making people a statistic. And that’s what Pinker’s presentation was like — lumping the whole of humanity together, and lumping their suffering together. How ethical is it for us to do such a thing? That’s a question that will always resonate with me, whenever I see someone using statistics to average out human experience. Is that the moral system that we want? — MK

All knowledge that we’re creating is mediated through our human experience, and that’s an individual, or a community, or an identity—all human experience. And if we acknowledge that within science, I think that changes the fundamentals of science. I’m not arguing that gravity doesn’t exist, or the theory of evolution doesn’t exist. What I am saying is that the human participant within science matters, and acknowledging this is a great place to begin. — MJ

And the scientific method doesn’t happen in a vacuum. People are the ones who actually apply this made-up framework that we’ve decided to call the scientific method. What happens through that methodology is a product where the input is humans, and the output is interpreted by humans. — SG

A better approach than Pinker’s to understanding human progress and history would be to let people at the table talk who haven’t talked before. As Jedidah said, he’s not saying anything new. He represents the one demographic that has had the mic for thousands of days. It’s time to let other groups talk — particularly those who have been the most underrepresented, the most erased.

What would the soundscape be like, just hearing from people who have not been allowed to talk? We will discover folks who we didn’t even know existed. That’s also part of the lie — that certain groups don’t even exist, so they don’t have a voice, or they don’t participate in things. So the progress is: Let’s let other folks to the table, and stand back and listen. — DL

TEDScreen gems: The art onscreen at TED2018

A monumental part of what brings the TED conference to life is the speakers and the amazing ideas they share on the TED stage. But here’s a riddle: What also shares the spotlight with each person who spends their 3 to 18 minutes speaking on the red dot? The magnificent session art, of course!

TED has collaborated with design firm Colours & Shapes since 2014. They are the minds behind the mesmerizing animated art seen at the start and throughout each session, which is tailored specifically to that session’s theme.

We caught up with Colours & Shapes in their hometown of Vancouver, BC, to learn more about the process behind an integral part of what’s brought TED2018: The Age of Amazement to life.


A globally changing landscape forms the backdrop for Session 4, the Audacious Project. Over the course of the evening’s session, the light slowly fades onscreen.

Q: Tell us about your team and company:

Colours & Shapes was founded in 2012 by Gordie Cochran and Anthony Diehl. We actually sort of stumbled into it. We saw an opportunity to leverage our diverse backgrounds in film, events and tech to craft amazing, meaningful experiences. Our passion has really been to architect “moments” that stick with you; moments that resonate with that deep “why” behind any event or experience.

Q: Take us through the creative process: from receiving the prompts to fruition … were there technical considerations or concerns you had to troubleshoot?

The creative process has been really wonderful. We love how open the TED curation team is to some pretty “out there” visual ideas. Our process was really all about understanding the session themes and curation and finding ways to to unpack “amazement” in each. We started with really rough sketches and motifs. We gave particular consideration to how we could use projection on the stage and the beautiful wood cases. We knew from the start that we wanted to treat the entire stage and screens as one unified canvas for content. We worked really closely with Mina, Mike and Martha to find just the right tone for each session. Our looks moved pretty quickly from sketches and moodboards to illustration and animation.

The creative process really followed the development of the sessions. As we learned more about the speakers and topics, there was so much great inspiration to draw on visually. From the unique red laser light in Mary Lou Jepsen’s talk to ocean exploration and intimate storytelling, we wanted each session to feel like the perfect space to hear each TED Talk. Our team worked incredibly hard in the weeks leading up to TED to produce all these diverse session environments. And we worked in a lot of different mediums! Traditional animation, illustration, film, compositing, VFX … At one point we found ourselves smearing around a lot of tea, cream and sugar in macro videography for one session look (Session 5: Space to Dream).

Q: What were you most excited about when you heard this year’s theme was Age of Amazement?

Love the theme! We were immediately intrigued and drawn in when we starting talking about this year theme. Each session really has its own way that it interacts with the theme in a way that is really fun and interesting. The early creative motifs we developed were all about exploring “amazement” through a variety of lenses: emotions, optical illusions, perspective shifts, shadow play, etc.

Q: The art for each session is based on the session title — any secret inspirations? (A little birdy told me about song lyrics inspiring Session 5 … are there others like that?)

  • There were a few sessions that we really wanted to tie into. The red laser light for Session 9: Body Electric is a nod to Mary Lou Jepsen’s talk.
  • Nerdish Delight is a playful nod to the ubiquitous “sexy tech product reveal” video. It’s all cool sculpted lines, slick materials and studio lighting … except we never get to see just what the product is!
  • “Wow. Just wow.” is an M.C. Escher-esque optical illusion. It’s all about the thrill of a perspective shift, that “wow” moment when you realize you are seeing something completely new and exciting.
  • “Space to Dream” really started as we asked ourselves, “What do astrophysicist daydream about?” We imagined ourselves staring into a cup of tea and losing ourselves in a waking dream about beautiful unseen corners of the universe. In one of our creative meetings with the TED team the lyrics to the Blondie song “Dreaming” came up: “I’ll have a cup of tea and tell you of my dreaming …” It’s a beautiful deep space daydream that is built entirely from filmed elements like tea, sugar, cream and food coloring. No actual nebulae were harmed in the filming of that session.

Q: Any “easter eggs” we should look for?

The Blondie song connection above is a fun one.

Session 10, Personally Speaking, is a session all about little scenes and objects that suggest a story, but don’t quite give you all the info. Sort of like the opening line of a good short story. The wood cases on stage and “rooms” in the session environment shift and turn.

Q: What do you want the audience to experience while watching your art?

In a word? Amazement! Our hope is that each visual environment serves to support the deep, intentional and thoughtful curation that has gone into each session for TED 2018. In working closely with the team at TED, we have worked to extract as many insights, themes, inspirations for each session and then have endeavoured to create visual environments that effectively captures the DNA of each session in thoughtful, creative and whimsical ways.


The shifting panels and details of Session 2’s screen reflects the session title: “After the end of history …”

Q: What are you most proud of from this project?

Definitely our talented team members! Producing great experiences and beautiful creative takes a team that can bend and bow with evolving ideas and creative discovery. Getting to partner with the brilliant team at TED and come alongside and be able to visually bring big ideas to life in the theatre has been a really fantastic and creatively rich experience for C&S. Hard to pick favourites from the content but we really love how the conference opener came out. Jorge Canedo Estrada’s sumptuous animation is second to none. Also, seeing Mike Ellis’ gorgeous illustration come to life in a crazy shifting 3D world in “Wow. Just Wow.” is something we could watch all day!

Q: How many people work on making this happen?

We pulled together a team of multidisciplinary creatives to built out the visual worlds for TED2018. We have collaborated with a team of illustrators, designers, animators and composers, 13 people total.

Q: Any interesting or fun stories you’d like to share that happened during the process?

The intensity of taking everything on with a short timeline, and then throwing the opener into the mix weeks before the event. This led to some long nights in animation! But seeing it all come to life in the theatre was incredibly rewarding.

Q: Anything I’m missing? Anything you’d like to add?

Thank you to Chris, Mina, Mike, Martha and the TED team for having us along for the ride this year!

Bright colors and natural motifs tell the story of Session 11, “What matters.”

Cory DoctorowInterview with Monocle’s Meet the Writers

Last month, while at Adelaide Writers Week, I sat down with the excellent Georgina Godwin to record an interview (MP3) for Monocole’s “Meet the Writers” podcast. They’ve only just published it and I’m very pleased with how it turned out: we got into some territory that I don’t usually cover. Also: they had the interview in a bar and bought me whatever whisky I asked for, which was quite a bonus.

Don MartiWhen can deceptive sellers outbid honest sellers for ad impressions?

Why does the Peak Advertising effect occur most in the most accurately targeted ad media? Why do people tend to filter out targeted ads, using habit power, technology, and regulation, while paying more attention to less finely targeted ad media?

One explanation is that buying ad space is an example of costly signaling. On this view, advertising is basically an exchange of signal for attention, and ads that don't pay their way with some kind of proof of spend are not worth paying attention to because they don't convey useful information about the seller's beliefs on how valuable the audience would find the product.

Another possible explanation is that targetable ad media are more suitable for deception, and that where advertisers bid for space in a medium, deceptive advertisers will tend to outbid the honest ones.

This seems counterintuitive, since we might suppose that the customer lifetime value of an honest seller's newly acquired customer could in many cases be greater than the profit from a quick score by a deceptive seller. But targeting doesn't just match ad impressions with prospective buyers. When used by a deceptive seller, it can also conceal an ad impression from potentially costly attention.

For honest direct marketers, the expected profit from reaching a buyer is positive, and the expected profit from reaching a non-buyer is zero. But the audience does not just contain buyers and non-buyers. People can also be divided into enforcers and non-enforcers. Enforcers can be anything from professional law enforcement people, to someone who takes apart a bogus product and makes a video about it, to just the writer of a bad online review. What enforcers have in common is that for a dishonest seller, the expected profit from reaching an enforcer is negative.

Some kinds of enforcer can impose costs even without buying. For example, a reader might send the publisher a screenshot containing a scam ad and get the advertiser added to an advertiser exclusion list. Other kinds of enforcer might only take action if they buy the product and find it to be a scam. A deceptive advertiser might incur costs when their ad is shown to either kind of enforcer.

For the honest advertiser, the expected profit from a single impression is:

probability of reaching a buyer × expected profit per sale

For the dishonest advertiser, the expected profit is:

probability of reaching a buyer × expected profit per sale − probability of reaching an enforcer × expected loss per enforcer

The expected loss per enforcer is typically high compared to the profit per sale. For example, a small number of contacts with review writers might require a seller to re-launch under a new name. In an ad impression market with both honest and deceptive sellers, where sellers can choose which impressions to bid on, an ad impression that a deceptive seller believes is unlikely to reach an enforcer has extra value to that deceptive advertiser but not to an honest advertiser. Deceptive sellers will tend to outbid honest ones for certain impressions.

A member of the audience might be able to see targeting criteria, but not the advertiser's internal weighting of targeting criteria. (For example, a targeted ad platform might reveal to you that you are being targeted for an ad because your computer is running the latest release of the OS. What they won't tell you is that the seller is bidding on impressions to your OS version because they're selling a tainted nutritional supplement, and the lead testing department at the Ministry of Health is still on the old OS version.)

So, some ad impressions will tend to be purchased by deceptive sellers, but a low-information member of the audience can't tell which impressions those are. Is this an ad from an honest seller that might be reaching both me and enforcers, or is this an ad from a dishonest seller targeted to reach me but not enforcers? When you read a magazine that reaches a community of practice of which you're a member, you can be confident that product reviewers and editors are seeing the same ads you are. A web ad could be targeted to avoid experienced and better-connected members of the community of practice.

One possible explanation for the Peak Advertising effect is the interaction between deceptive sellers discovering how to use a new ad medium's targeting capabilities to avoid enforcers, and the audience discovering the fraction of deceptive sellers.

Related: Ban Targeted Advertising by David Dayen in The New Republic. (I'm not so much interested in whether or not targeted advertising should be banned as I am in the reasoning behind why people choose to protect themselves from it. The story of matching the exact right buyer to the exact right product is much less compelling for most purchase decisions than the buyer's story of finding an adequate product and avoiding deceptive sellers.)

TEDBMW at TED2018: Putting its self-driving car to the reading, mascara and ramen test

“Driving” this autonomous vehicle is as easy as using a microwave, discovered TED Ideas Editor Daryl Chen at the BMW Personal CoPilot Experience at TED2018: The Age of Amazement, April 10. Photo: Lawrence Sumulong / TED

“The ultimate sitting machine.”

Please be kind — this is only my first attempt at a tagline for the BMW autonomous vehicle which I just went for a test drive, er, test ride in.

Yes, I can proudly say that I’ve gone for a ride in the future — and it’s smooth enough to eat ramen in.

Wait, let me back up (just like a car, get it?). At TED2018, BMW has been treating attendees to rides in its i3 cars that have been kitted out with level 5 autonomous vehicle capability. It’s not exaggerating for me to call this vehicle the future. “You will not be able to buy this in the next three years, but today BMW is working on this technology,” says BMW’s US Technology Office Vice President Simon Euringer. “Normally, we don’t do that but because of all the noise about the autonomous vehicles, we think it makes sense to give people a preview.” Even though BMW has been relatively quiet about its self-driving plans compared to some of its rivals, there’s plenty of action happening behind the scenes. In fact, the company just opened an Autonomous Driving Campus near Munich that brings together 80 teams that are working on this effort. The number of people at BMW focused on self-driving cars is estimated by Euringer to be “way north of 1,000.” He adds, “This is one of the biggest investments in car industry; this is probably a bigger investment than electro-mobility.

Level 5 means there is no driver in the vehicle, no person behind the wheel. In fact, speculates Euringer, “the car would probably not have even a steering wheel.” BMW, like the other auto companies, foresees driverless cars being used by children and other people who don’t have driver’s licenses.

Before my ride, I decided to put the car to a series of tests; I wanted to see if I was able to accomplish three common activities that are challenging in a moving car. My first activity: reading a book. I am an avid reader, but I’m unable to do so in a traditional car because I get carsick. Novel in hand, I got into the backseat of the BMW in the basement of the Vancouver Convention Center. Then, I started the car. “Driving” this autonomous vehicle was like watching a video or using a microwave — I used a touchscreen to enter a destination, hit the “start here” button, and the car began moving. That’s it. Whenever I wanted to stop, I hit the “pause” button and it slowed to a halt. The vehicle glided right through my reading test — the ride was smooth enough that it felt like I was enjoying my book in a comfy leather armchair. I dove into my novel and didn’t emerge until it came time for my next challenge.

TED Ideas Editor Daryl Chen puts the vehicle to the all-important mascara test at the BMW Personal CoPilot Experience at TED2018: The Age of Amazement, April 10, Vancouver. Photo: Lawrence Sumulong / TED

My second activity was applying mascara. As anyone who has ever put on makeup in a traveling car can tell you, the results are often not so pretty, and mascara is among the most difficult cosmetics to handle. Unfortunately, I must report that self-driving capabilities did not make my task that much easier. While the ride was mercifully bump-free, the turns were still enough to make my wand hand shake and smudge; the process was also complicated by the lack of mirror in the backseat for me to use (note to BMW execs: can you fix this?).

Finally, I was ready for my third and final activity: eating noodles. Noodles are an important part of my diet — and in a conventional car, consuming them means spilling, splattering, and needing a change of clothing. Riding in the car, I took out my piping-hot cup of instant ramen and a pair of chopsticks. And I’m glad to say — for me, my dress, the vehicle, but most especially, for the worried BMW representative — that I did not drip a drop. I ate happily and neatly.

With a final tap of the touchscreen, I ended my ride.

Okay, I think I’ve figured out the perfect tagline for this autonomous vehicle: the ultimate noodle machine. What do you think, BMW?

TEDAnnounced at TED2018: TED’s Hindi-language Star Plus TV series “TED Talks India: Nayi Soch” renewed for three seasons

Shah Rukh Khan hosts Season 1 of TED Talks India: Nayi Soch, which was just renewed for three more seasons on Star Plus. Photo: Amit Madheshiya / TED

New York, NY (April 13, 2018)—TED announced today that its highly acclaimed Star Plus TV prime-time series TED Talks India: Nayi Soch, a Hindi-language TV and digital series hosted by Shah Rukh Khan which premiered last fall, has been renewed for three more seasons.

The first season, which featured speakers delivering inspiring and informative talks in TED’s signature style of 18 minutes or less, drew an astounding 96 million viewers over its first season in fall 2017.

TED Talks India: Nayi Soch speakers deliver TED Talks in Hindi on topics as varied as science and social justice before a live studio audience, with professional subtitles in Hindi and in English provided for viewers at home. Almost every talk features a short Q&A between the speaker and Khan that dives deeper into the ideas shared onstage.

TED Talks India: Nayi Soch host and Bollywood star Shah Rukh Khan said: “I believe passionately that India is brimming with brave and brilliant ideas—and that those ideas have never mattered more. This program features India’s finest storytellers in a surprising blend of entertainment, inspiration and intellectualism, and I‘m more committed than ever to spreading their ideas to my country and the rest of the world.”

TED’s Head of Television Juliet Blake, who executive-produced the series, said: “We’re incredibly proud of this show’s accomplishments breaking barriers to reach new audiences, and look forward to spending the next several seasons inspiring a nation to embrace ideas and curiosity.”

Star TV CEO and Chairman Uday Shankar said: “Star TV is committed to developing programming that goes beyond pure entertainment to inspire and educate our massive audience. Both the critical response and the tremendous viewer love for this series were key factors in our decision to bring Ted Talks India: Nayi Soch back for at least three more seasons.”

Head of TED Chris Anderson said: “Ultimately TED’s goal is to develop compelling new content formats that can make ideas available and relevant to billions of people we haven’t reached yet. This journey with Star TV and Shah Rukh Khan has allowed us to make significant progress spreading ideas.”

Here’s what audiences have had to say:

  • “Amidst all the ruckus of daily soaps fighting for TRPs we’ve finally got a TV show that’s absolutely worth watching.” – Neeraj Chavan (via Quora)
  • “#TEDTalksIndiaNayiSoch is one of the best initiatives ever, I loved watching @TEDTalks and now that idea and platform have been brought to India I am amazed to see that how much potential India has! –@Umangkelani (via Twitter)
  • “This action-packed one hour show airing on Star Plus is definitely a great way to explore revolutionary ideas from Indians.” – Anuj Shikarkhane (via Quora)
  • “It is clear from today’s scenario of world that number of problems are way more than the problem solvers and we need crowd support to solve them. This is where TED Talks India helps. It makes people aware about the issues and ways to address it. This is the need of the hour.” – Aayush Wadhwa (via Quora)
  • “This show shows us that there are great undiscovered minds in our country and a [number] of unsung heroes. TED is like a light bulb in the dark field of the daily soaps which we experiencing for years.” – Rishabh Nayan (via Quora)

Here’s what reviewers have had to say:

  • “[P]robably the best show to have premiered on Indian television, in recent times.” – First Post
  • “The content is great with a host of speakers discussing ideas that leave people inspired and positive.” – India Today
  • “The best part about the show is that you get to learn so much. It is enlightening to say the least.” – Bollywood Life
  • “[S]omething absolutely must for Indian audiences.” – Chandigarh Metro

The TED Talks India: Nayi Soch audience stretches beyond television on and for TED mobile app users in India. Each episode has been conveniently broken out into individual TED Talks, one talk for each speaker on the program. Viewers can watch and share them on their own, or download them as playlists to watch one after another.

Host Shah Rukh Khan and TED’s head of television, Juliet Blake, wrap production of TED Talks India: Nayi Soch season 1. The show has been renewed after garnering 96 million viewers and sparkling reviews in its first season. Photo: Amit Madheshiya / TED

TEDBody electric: Notes from Session 9 of TED2018

Mary Lou Jepsen demonstrates the ability of red light to scatter when it hits our bodies. Can we leverage this property to see inside ourselves? She speaks at TED2018 on April 13, 2018. Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

During the week of TED, it’s tempting to feel like a brain in a jar — to think on a highly abstracted, intellectual, hypertechnical level about every single human issue. But the speakers in this session remind us that we’re still just made of meat. And that our carbon-based life forms aren’t problems to be transcended but, if you will, platforms. Let’s build on them, explore them, and above all feel at home in them.

When red light means go. The last time Mary Lou Jepsen took the TED stage, she shared the science of knowing what’s inside another person’s mind. This time, the celebrated optical engineer shares an exciting new tool for reading what’s inside our bodies. It exploits the properties of red light, which behaves differently in different body materials. Our bones and flesh scatter red light (as she demonstrates on a piece of raw chicken breast), while our red blood absorbs it. By measuring how light scatters, or doesn’t, inside our bodies, and using a technique called holography to study the resulting patterns as the light comes through the other side, Jepsen believe we can gain a new way to spot tumors and other anomalies, and eventually to create a smaller, more efficient replacement for the bulky MRI. Her demo doubles as a crash course in optics, with red and green lasers and all kinds of cool gear (some of which juuuuust squeaked through customs in time). And it’s a wildly inspiring look at a bold effort to solve an old problem in a new way.

Floyd E. Romesberg imagines a couple new letters in DNA that might allow us to create … who knows what. Photo: Jason Redmond / TED

What if DNA had more letters to work with? DNA is built on only four letters: G, C, A, T. These letters determine the sequences of the 20 amino acids in our cells that build the proteins that make life possible. But what if that “alphabet” got bigger? Synthetic biologist and chemist Floyd Romesberg suggests that the letters of the genetic alphabet are not all that unique. For the problem of life, perhaps, “maybe we’re not the only solution, maybe not even the best solution — just a solution.” And maybe new parts can be built to work alongside the natural parts. Inspired by these insights, Romesberg and his colleagues constructed the first “semi-synthetic” life forms based on a 6-letter DNA. With these extra building blocks, cells can construct hitherto unseen proteins. Someday, we could tailor these cells to fulfill all sorts of functions — building new, hyper-targeted medicines, seeking out and destroying cancer, or “eating” toxic materials. Worried about unintended consequences? Romesberg says that his augmented 6-letter DNA cannot be replenished within the body. As the unnatural genetic materials are depleted, the semi-synthetic cells die off, protecting us against nightmarish sci-fi scenarios of rogue microorganisms.

On the slide behind Dan Gibson: a teleportation machine, more or less. It’s a “printer” that can convert digital information into biological material, and it holds the promise of sending things like vaccines and medicines over the internet. Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

Beam our DNA up, Scotty. Teleportation is real. That’s right, you read it here first. This method isn’t quite like what the minds behind Star Trek brought to life, but the massive implications attached are just as futuristic. Biologist and engineer Dan Gibson reports from the front lines of science fact, that we are now able to transmit not our entire selves, but the most fundamental parts of who we are: our DNA. Or, simply put, biological teleportation. “The characteristics and functions of all biological entities including viruses and living cells are written into the code of DNA,” says Gibson. “They can be reconstructed in a distant location if we can read and write the sequence of that DNA code.” The machines that perform this fantastic feat, the BioXP and the DBC, stitch together both long and short forms of genetic code that can be downloaded from the internet. That means that in the future, with an at-home version of these machines (or even one literally worlds away, say like, Mars), we may be able to download and print personalized therapeutic medications, prescriptions and even vaccines. The process takes weeks now, but could someday come down to 1–2 days. (And don’t worry: Gibson, his team and the government screen every synthesis order against a database to make sure viruses and pathogens aren’t being made.) He says: “For now, I will be satisfied beaming new medicines across the globe, fully automated and on-demand to save lives from emerging deadly infectious diseases and to create personalized cancer medicines for those who don’t have time to wait.”

In a powerful talk, sex educator Emily Nagoski educates us about emotional nonconcordance — when our body and our mind “say” different things in an intimate situation. Which to listen to? Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

Busting one of our most dangerous myths about sex. When it comes to pleasure, humans have something that’s often called “the reward center” — but, explains sex educator Emily Nagoski, that “reward center” is actually three intertwined, separate systems: liking, or whether it feels good or bad; wanting, which motivates us to move toward or away from a stimulus; and learning. Learning is best explained by Pavlov’s dogs, whom he trained to salivate when he rang a bell. Were the dogs hungry for the bell (wanting)? Did they find the bell delicious (liking)? Of course not: “What Pavlov did was make the bell food-related.” The separateness of these three things, wanting, liking and learning, helps explain a phenomenon called emotional nonconcordance, when our physiological response doesn’t match our subjective experience. This happens with all sorts of emotional and motivational systems, including sex. “Research over the last thirty years has found that genital blood flow can increase in response to sex-related stimuli, even if those sex-related stimuli are not also associated with a subjective experience of wanting and liking,” she says. The problem is that we don’t recognize nonconcordance when it comes to sex: in fact, there is a dangerous myth that even if someone says they don’t want it or don’t like it, their body can say differently, and the body is the one telling the “truth.” This myth has serious consequences for victims of unwanted and nonconsensual sexual contact, who are sometimes told that their nonconcordant genital response invalidates their experience … and who can even have that response held up as evidence in sexual assault cases. Nagoski urges all of us to share this crucial information with someone — judges, lawyers, your partners, your kids. “The roots of this myth are deep and they are entangled with some very dark forces in our culture, but with every brave conversation we have, we make the world that little bit better,” she says to one of the biggest standing Os in a standing-O-heavy session.

The musicians and songwriters of LADAMA perform and speak at TED2018. Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

Bringing Latin alternative music to Vancouver. Singing in Spanish, Portuguese and English, LADAMA enliven the TED stage with a vibrant, energizing and utterly danceable musical set. The multinational ensemble of women — Maria Fernanda Gonzalez from Venezuela, Lara Klaus from Brazil, Daniela Serna of Colombia, and Sara Lucas from the US — and their bass player collaborator combine traditional South American and Caribbean styles like cumbia, maracatu and joropo with pop, soul and R&B to deliver a pulsing musical experience. The group took attendees on a musical journey with their modern and soulful compositions, playing original songs “Night Traveler” and “Porro Maracatu.”

Hugh Herr lost both legs below the knee, but the new legs he built allow him once again to run, climb and even dance. Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

“The robot became part of me.” MIT professor Hugh Herr takes the TED stage, his sleek bionic legs conspicuous under his sharp grey suit. “I’m basically nuts and bolts from the knee down,” Herr says, demonstrating how his bionic legs — made up of 24 sensors, 6 microprocessors and muscle-tendon-like actuators — allow him to walk, skip and run. Herr builds body parts, and he’s working toward realizing a goal that has long been thought of as science fiction: for synthetic limbs to be integrated into the human nervous system. He calls it neural embodied design, a methodology to create cyborg function where the lines between the natural and synthetic world are blurred. This future will provide humanity with new bodies and end disability, Herr says — and it’s already happening. He introduces us to Jim Ewing, a friend of Herr’s who was in a climbing accident that resulted in the amputation of his foot. Using the Agonist-antagonist Myoneural Interface, a method Herr and his team developed at MIT to connect nerves to a prosthetic, Jim’s bones and muscles were integrated with a synthetic limb, re-establishing the neural connection between his ankle and foot muscles and his brain. “Jim moves and behaves as if the synthetic limb is part of him,” Herr says. And he’s even back climbing again. Taking a few moments to dream, Herr describes a future where humans have augmented their bodies in a way that fundamentally redefines human potential, giving us unimaginable physical strength — and, maybe, the ability to fly. “I believe humans will become superheroes,” Herr says. “During the twilight years of this century, I believe humans will be unrecognizable in morphology and dynamics from what we are today. Humanity will take flight and soar.”

Jim Ewing, left, lost a limb in a climbing accident; he partnered with MIT professor Hugh Herr, right, to build a limb that got him back up and climbing again. Photo: Ryan Lash / TED


TEDHow to rebuild trust … Frances Frei speaks at TED2018

Authenticity is critical to trust, but “if those of us who are different give in to the temptation to hold back our authentic selves, then the most interesting thing about us — our difference — is muted,” says Harvard Business School professor Frances Frei at TED2018: The Age of Amazement on April 13, Vancouver. Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

“It’s my belief that trust is the foundation for everything we do,” says Harvard Business School professor Frances Frei, “and that if we can learn to trust on another more, we can have unprecedented human progress.”

What to do, then, when trust is broken? In companies, there are many reasons that a rupture can happen. Things like data breaches, a culture of bias and discrimination, a CEO caught disparaging an employee, even a technological error that costs human life. And all those things were happening at Uber. Which is why, in 2017, Frei embedded as a full-time employee at Uber to help them figure out how to rebuild trust after the company had so completely lost it. The sheer scale of the hole that Uber had fallen into is what attracted her. “My favorite trait is redemption,” she says, “I believe that there is a better version of us around every corner, and I have seen firsthand how organizations and communities and individuals change at breathtaking speed.”

A loss of trust is no different than most problems — before you can solve it, first you have to understand how it works. Trust has three components, say Frei: authenticity, logic and empathy.  “When all three of these things are working, we have great trust,” she says, “but if any one of these three gets shaky, if any one of these three wobbles, trust is threatened.”

Frei believes the way to rebuild trust is to understand where you wobble — whether it’s authenticity, empathy or logic that generally gets in the way of someone trusting you — and learn strategies to correct that wobble.

“The most common wobble is empathy,” she says, because “people just don’t believe that we’re mostly in it for them, and they believe that we’re too self-distracted.” Due to the constant demands and distractions of daily life, it can be hard to create the time and space that empathy needs. The fix is pretty easy: “Identify where, when and to whom you are likely to offer your distraction,” says Frei. “That should trace pretty perfectly to when, where and to whom you are likely to withhold your empathy.” If you can truly listen to the people you’re with, you have a chance to fix the wobble.

Logic is a wobble either because your reasoning itself is shaky (in which case, Frei says, “I can’t really help you”) or your ability to communicate it is weak. If your tendency is the latter, consider changing the way you structure your communication. Instead of starting with a story and ending with your point, begin with your point in a crisp half sentence and then support your conclusion — rather than the other way around. Bonus to this approach: If you’re interrupted, you’ve already made your point!

The toughest of the three wobbles to correct is authenticity. While Frei’s prescription is simple — just be you — being your true self isn’t always easy, especially if you are different from the majority in any way. But remember this: Not being authentic damages trust, which can lead to all sorts of unintended consequences. “So, here’s my advice,” she says: “Wear whatever makes you feel fabulous. Pay less attention to what you think people want to hear from you and far more attention to what your authentic awesome self needs to say.” She urges leaders to make sure that their organizations are safe, welcome spaces for people to show up as themselves.

What was Uber’s wobble? “Empathy, logic, authenticity were all wobbling like crazy,” she says, “but we were able to find super-effective, super-quick fixes” for the first two. For example, it had become common practice at Uber meetings for people to text each other – about the meeting. “It did not create a safe, empathetic environment,” Frei smiles. The simple solution: Ask people to turn off their tech, and put it away while talking. When it came to logic, Uber had grown so rapidly that managers had been continuously promoted until they reached positions that outstripped their capabilities. “It was not their fault,” she says. The remedy: They brought in executive education that focused on logic, strategy and leadership.

The last wobble — authenticity — proved harder to change, which is common. “It is still much easier to coach people to fit in; it is still much easier to reward people when they say something that you were going to say.” But, she says, “when we figure out how to celebrate difference and how to let people bring the best version of themselves forward, well, holy cow, is that the world I want my sons to grow up in.”

In a post-talk Q&A with TED curator Helen Walters, Frei says she remains hopeful that trust can be rebuilt within our businesses and institutions, but it won’t happen right away: “I am super-optimistic that everyone can set the conditions to to be more empathic, to use more rigorous logic, to be their authentic selves.”

TEDAnnounced at TED2018: Google’s new TalkToBooks search

Here onstage at TED2018, futurist Ray Kurzweil has just formally announced a new way to query the text inside books using something called semantic search — which is a search on ideas and concepts, rather than specific words. Called TalkToBooks, the beta-stage product uses an experimental AI to query a database of 120,000 books in about a half a second. (As Kurzweil jokes: “It takes me hours to read a hundred thousand books.”)

Jump in and play with TalkToBooks »

Kurzweil suggests some questions to ask it:

How can I stop thinking and fall asleep?
What is the meaning of life?
How does eating fiber help you lose weight?
Why is the Turing test important?

Some answers are relevant, and others, while maybe not quite correct, intriguingly reveal the way the machine “thinks,” the kinds of connections it wants to make. If you want to dig further, read this blog post from Google’s Semantic Experiences group, and this detailed coverage from The Verge.

CryptogramFriday Squid Blogging: Eating Firefly Squid

In Tokama, Japan, you can watch the firefly squid catch and eat them in various ways:

"It's great to eat hotaruika around when the seasons change, which is when people tend to get sick," said Ryoji Tanaka, an executive at the Toyama prefectural federation of fishing cooperatives. "In addition to popular cooking methods, such as boiling them in salted water, you can also add them to pasta or pizza."

Now there is a new addition: eating hotaruika raw as sashimi. However, due to reports that parasites have been found in their internal organs, the Health, Labor and Welfare Ministry recommends eating the squid after its internal organs have been removed, or after it has been frozen for at least four days at minus 30 C or lower.

As usual, you can also use this squid post to talk about the security stories in the news that I haven't covered.

Read my blog posting guidelines here.

TEDAnnounced at TED2018: Explore satellite images with Planet Stories

Will Marshall and his company, Planet, has launched a fleet of small satellites to image the Earth every day, watching over changes both natural and human-made. At TED this week, he announced a way for all of us to play with this rich data set — 500 or so images of every location on Earth over time. Photo: Ryan Lash / TED

Back in 2014, Will Marshall took the TED stage to introduce us to his company, Planet, and their proposed fleet of tiny satellites. The goal: to image the planet every day, showing us how Earth changes in near-real time. In 2018, that vision has come good: Every day, a fleet of about 200 small satellites pictures every inch of the planet, taking 1.5 million 29mp images every day (about 6T of data daily), gathering data on changes both natural and human-made. The images are used by businesses, academics and other professionals to monitor our lovely planet.

This week at TED, Marshall announced a consumer version of Planet, called Planet Stories, to let ordinary people play with these images too. You can compare satellite images over time, at any location you choose, and produce time-lapse images that show change and movement. Watch a new neighborhood rise, see slow but dramatic changes in the environment, or watch the tides in a before-and-after comparison of seasonal change. It’s just a little bit addictive.

Two simple tutorials will get you started for two weeks of exploring this data set. Create an account on Planet Stories and start playing >>


TEDScenes from the Tech Playground at TED2018

Assembled by our tech curator Alex Moura, six exhibits around the theater explore the hands-on, playful and human side of tech. Every exhibit is in some way touchable, relatable — not a piece of shiny gear in a plexiglas box but instead something to step into and be part of and play with. Meet our Tech Playground:

What are Victoria and M doing here? Well, if you could see what Victoria sees, she is interacting with a piece of sculpture with height, depth and a space to crawl into. As sculptor M Eifler describes it: “Their act of looking will reveal the size and position of the sculpture to the rest of us.” Learn more about Invisible Sculpture. Photo: Jason Redmond / TED

Have a minute for magic? How about 3 minutes, or 5? If you press one of these buttons, the Short Edition machine at TED2018 will print you a short story or a poem. It’s a small reminder to make and take art every day. Bonus: You can enter a short story contest this week, and maybe see your own short story in these printers as they roll out across North America this year. Photo: Jason Redmond / TED

Each of these scrolls contains a short story to read and share. Photo: Jason Redmond / TED

Spatial AR is a computing platform based on AR; imagine a 3D interface that turns your computer into a collaborative creative canvas. It’s being developed by interface gurus Jinha Lee and Anand Agarawala, whom you may know from their previous TED Talks about making smarter, better user interfaces. Photo: Lawrence Sumulong / TED

Root Robotics is on a mission to help people explore the amazing things you can do with your imagination and a little bit of code. Root’s app is designed for all ages, and uses music, art and adventure to teach coding in simple, colorful ways. Photo: Jason Redmond / TED

In the Mira Prism experience, attendees can collaborate to solve a series of challenges assisted by holographic work instructions, all powered by a smartphone and seen through the transparent lenses of the Mira Prism headset. Photo: Lawrence Sumulong / TED

This is Kuri, the autonomous robot designed with personality, awareness, and mobility. Kuri’s job is to capture life’s little moments while learning the rhythm of your household. She can wake you up in time for work and greet you when you come home at night. Her expressive eyes and robot language add to her uniquely adorable personality. Photo: Jason Redmond / TED